Mini Normal 1839 - Game Over!

[Fire Assassin]

Your going to have to be very explicit on how I am feeding scum Info here.

[PenguinPower]

Um...you're asking everyone what they want to see happen. How does that not help scum tailor their NK and roll in to D2 play?

[Fire Assassin]

Um...you're asking everyone what they want to see happen. How does that not help scum tailor their NK and roll in to D2 play?

I am wondering how you do you mean they would tailor their NK? And want to see happen?
Are you saying that they will avoid killing people are suggesing to prot, and killing someone who is invest target and not killing?

I am lost how this helps them beyond giving it more WIFOM.

[LmkGuy]

Um...you're asking everyone what they want to see happen. How does that not help scum tailor their NK and roll in to D2 play?

I am wondering how you do you mean they would tailor their NK? And want to see happen?
Are you saying that they will avoid killing people are suggesing to prot, and killing someone who is invest target and not killing?

I am lost how this helps them beyond giving it more WIFOM.

I think he means that you listed who you were thinking of investigate/kill/protecting which means scum can avoid these listed people and NK someone else to avoid your potential power role. They could of course role blocker you too (I am assuming there can be a RB in normal, soz if not, first normal game).

Anyway, him asking that question is almost like asking people for a reads list. Looking at the people that a person lists actually shows what that player thinks of the listed people.

[ironstove]

flip coin investigate nero/karnos, protect your town read, and flip a coin to shoot lowell/lmk

[ironstove]

lmkguy coming back into this thread after being prodded (been mia for 2 days), and the first thing he posts is opposition to the mal train that is forming and says we should really be lynching lowell instead.

[ironstove]

I'd like to flip lmkguy but that prob won't happen, so I'd like to lynch between mal/lowell. Seems like mal is the lynch, so jump on board.

[Fire Assassin]

I think he means that you listed who you were thinking of investigate/kill/protecting which means scum can avoid these listed people and NK someone else to avoid your potential power role. They could of course role blocker you too (I am assuming there can be a RB in normal, soz if not, first normal game).

Anyway, him asking that question is almost like asking people for a reads list. Looking at the people that a person lists actually shows what that player thinks of the listed people.

Yeah, no thats stupid.

[LmkGuy]

lmkguy coming back into this thread after being prodded (been mia for 2 days), and the first thing he posts is opposition to the mal train that is forming and says we should really be lynching lowell instead.

weekends are always shit for me, and I oppose the mal train because there is no actual reason to lynch him other than he is not playing the game. You could make the argument that he has posted little value to the thread, but is that really what we want to lynch over? It's not something I am ruling out completely, but if we have a proper reason to lynch someone, isnt that better? At least we will get some sort of information from it. If mal flips town, we literally gain nothing.

So either we find a better alternative or make a high risk lynch.

@mod: Surely mal needs to give some sort of estimate as to when he will be back. He can't just say indefinite V/LA and then come back D6 and win the game (exaggeration of course). I mean we could lynch him but again, that seems unfair to force town to lynch someone purely for V/LA'ing 5eva

I think he means that you listed who you were thinking of investigate/kill/protecting which means scum can avoid these listed people and NK someone else to avoid your potential power role. They could of course role blocker you too (I am assuming there can be a RB in normal, soz if not, first normal game).

Anyway, him asking that question is almost like asking people for a reads list. Looking at the people that a person lists actually shows what that player thinks of the listed people.

Yeah, no thats stupid.

That's what I think penguin means btw, feel free to correct me penguin

[Foxbird]

Votecount 1.24

LmkGuy

(1) - AlpacaAlpaca

Saru

(4) - GreyICE, karnos, PenguinPower, Lowell

Thor665

(2) - Saru, malpascp

malpascp

(5) - Nero Cain, Fire Assassin, Thor665, ironstove, aronagrundy

(L-2!)

Lowell

(1) - LmkGuy

Not Voting

(0) - No one!

With

13

players eligible to vote, it’s

7

to lynch!

Day 1 will end in

(expired on 2016-10-26 03:25:36).

Mod Notes:

malpascp is V/LA until the 25th of October.

[Foxbird]

@mod: Surely mal needs to give some sort of estimate as to when he will be back. He can't just say indefinite V/LA and then come back D6 and win the game (exaggeration of course). I mean we could lynch him but again, that seems unfair to force town to lynch someone purely for V/LA'ing 5eva

His V/LA officially ends on the 25th, according to his profile. After that he will be subject to prods and/or replacement.

[LmkGuy]

@mod: Surely mal needs to give some sort of estimate as to when he will be back. He can't just say indefinite V/LA and then come back D6 and win the game (exaggeration of course). I mean we could lynch him but again, that seems unfair to force town to lynch someone purely for V/LA'ing 5eva

His V/LA officially ends on the 25th, according to his profile. After that he will be subject to prods and/or replacement.

Does this seem a little convenient to anyone else? V/LA ends right as this day ends? Am I reading into this too much?

[karnos]

vote:Mal

since we have a extension

Why does having an extension make you want to vote a V/LA lurker?

[karnos]

@mod: Surely mal needs to give some sort of estimate as to when he will be back. He can't just say indefinite V/LA and then come back D6 and win the game (exaggeration of course). I mean we could lynch him but again, that seems unfair to force town to lynch someone purely for V/LA'ing 5eva

His V/LA officially ends on the 25th, according to his profile. After that he will be subject to prods and/or replacement.

Does this seem a little convenient to anyone else? V/LA ends right as this day ends? Am I reading into this too much?

If the V/LA was changed after the game deadline changed, that would be suspicious. If Mal set V/LA before the deadline extension it can only be a coincidence.

I don't really like this last minute counter wagon. I still think Saru/Thor are scum. At least one of them, probably Saru.

Mal might be scum too, hard to say given his lurking, but lets not rush and lynch him when he isn't here to defend of claim.

[karnos]

Power-role advice, since it was requested:

Investigate: thor/me/nero
Protect: me/iron/your main townread
Roleblock: thor/saru if not lynched/mal
Kill: mal/thor/saru if not lynched

[karnos]

Actually investigate penguin, I'd like to know if he is actually town with some certainty.

[LmkGuy]

@mod: Surely mal needs to give some sort of estimate as to when he will be back. He can't just say indefinite V/LA and then come back D6 and win the game (exaggeration of course). I mean we could lynch him but again, that seems unfair to force town to lynch someone purely for V/LA'ing 5eva

His V/LA officially ends on the 25th, according to his profile. After that he will be subject to prods and/or replacement.

Does this seem a little convenient to anyone else? V/LA ends right as this day ends? Am I reading into this too much?

If the V/LA was changed after the game deadline changed, that would be suspicious. If Mal set V/LA before the deadline extension it can only be a coincidence.

I don't really like this last minute counter wagon. I still think Saru/Thor are scum. At least one of them, probably Saru.

Mal might be scum too, hard to say given his lurking, but lets not rush and lynch him when he isn't here to defend of claim.

I don't quite remember, but when I looked at activity overview when I put up my first post today, I dont remember it saying 25th (which is why I was surprised when the mod told me the date). I can't say with 100% confidence though, so I'm feeling a bit iffy about lynching him again.

Either way we need to get shit sorted and work out the lynch. its getting pretty close to deadline now. Maybe everyone should post a few reason why they want a certain person lynched. Think the most popular targets are Saru/Thor/Malpa. I would like Lowell/Alpaca/ maybe?arona???

I would be down to vote one of the first three I listed, as long as someone provides a few reasons that resonate with me.

[Nero Cain]

vote:Mal

since we have a extension

Why does having an extension make you want to vote a V/LA lurker?

he's a scummy lurker and with the extension we have time to get r done

[Nero Cain]

Investigate: pp/lmk/iron/karnos
Protect: thor
Roleblock: pp/lmk/iron/karnos
Kill: pp/lmk/iron/karnos

[Foxbird]

Wheeeeeee

[Foxbird]

yoink

[Foxbird]

OH GOD I CAN'T READ

[GreyICE]

Mal vote is garbage. Would lynch Thor for his response post. Would lynch Saru in general.

[GreyICE]

Also why are we doing some fucking rain dance?

This is scum as shit.

[GreyICE]

Like. The only one I care about is vig. Vig lowell, general principke. FA claims first thing tomorrow if he's alive.