Mini 1836: Space Mafia (Game Over)

[Zachstralkita]

Just throwing this out there that I actually think Gerry/Dunn are scum together. I fee pretty good saying Dunn wasn't roleblocked which is odd as shit statement to make and doesn't really make any sense to me as I say it, but I absolutely believe it to be true unless pip didn't submit a night action

Look at these garbage reads lmao

..but dont u think dunn scum

I'm happy to trade 1 v 1 with scum.

ya but what if you're both town like ive been saying...

[TwoFace]

Why discuss something that isn't true?

[TwoFace]

He's not flipping town. Nothing about his play looks town.

[Zachstralkita]

Why discuss something that isn't true?

Why blatantly allow your opinion to overshadow a very likely possibility?

[TwoFace]

Why is it likely? How on earth is he town? Explain in as much detail as possible

Make sure to cover how if he's town how he managed to falsely accuse the wrong person while ignoring the person who actually did it.
Naomi tried and failed. Maybe you can do a better job since you're so sure he's town.

[Something_Smart]

VC 2.7

gerryoat (4) - TwoFace, massive, Xkfyu, Dunnstral
Toto (2) - grapes, Nosferatu
Dunnstral (2) - Zachstralkita, gerryoat
Zachstralkita (1) - PantherPunt

Not voting (2)- Naomi-Tan, Toto

With 11 alive it takes 6 to lynch.

(expired on 2016-10-29 12:00:00)

Mod notes:

[Zachstralkita]

there is no SEMBLANCE of self-preservation that comes from scum in his play. Of course you will not see this now. next time be smarter tho.

[TwoFace]

See, you want me to drop my opinion and listen to yours and that's all you can give me?

[Naomi-Tan]

Why is it likely? How on earth is he town? Explain in as much detail as possible

Make sure to cover how if he's town how he managed to falsely accuse the wrong person while ignoring the person who actually did it.
Naomi tried and failed. Maybe you can do a better job since you're so sure he's town.

I wasn't trying to convince you he was red or green.. mine was more just a look at it from a game style.. TBH I wasn't feeling the train.. just too easy, But I also wasn't against it.. but given time is catching up with us again..

VOTE: Garryoat

Garry Oat is now L-1

Lets at least get that full claim now.

[TwoFace]

nah you were definitely more on the green side of things with regards to gerry.

unvote

for now.

I was feeling good about gerry up until you're vote.

[TwoFace]

I'll probably vote gerry again but I want somebody town reading gerry to actually answer the questions I directed towards zach.

Gerry, you can feel free to answer them also.

if I can't see a compelling reason why he is town, I'll know my original read is correct and i'll gladly hammer

[Naomi-Tan]

nah you were definitely more on the green side of things with regards to gerry.

unvote

for now.

I was feeling good about gerry up until you're vote.

This is just what happened at the end of D1 :I we don't have time for coyness now..

PEDIT: I'm not sure that anyone is green reading him..

[TwoFace]

gonna tell ya the truth. its not great. Not in an alignment way. Just generally... on its own it helps plot your two interactions but you missed the catalyst which was the original post that was thought to be yourself. I don't find it rather redish just kinda dumb on garry's part.. like.. If you was red. what would persistently using that do? given that everyone can look it up and see your lying.. nothing.. so.. it only really makes sense in Green! which although dumb isn't red.. if that makes sense.

this is you basically saying his actions point to green not red

[TwoFace]

So I went and skimmed the 2 scum games I could find for gerry and his play here is different. That means that either gerry is scum and he's playing different or for some reason he is playing anti-town but is actually town. smh I don't know what to do anymore.

[Xkfyu]

So I went and skimmed the 2 scum games I could find for gerry and his play here is different. That means that either gerry is scum and he's playing different or for some reason he is playing anti-town but is actually town. smh I don't know what to do anymore.

What's different about his play?

[TwoFace]

He looked like he was trying to appear town, where as here he isn't trying to look like he is town

[Xkfyu]

He looked like he was trying to appear town, where as here he isn't trying to look like he is town

I hate meta, but honestly, that's a pretty big difference.

[TwoFace]

yeah I hate it also and tbh I wouldn't have even thought to look at it but when naomi is trying to convince me that gerry is town and now does a 180 and puts him at l-1 and asks for a claim (which isn't how it works) and denies trying to convince me. I got the heebie jeebies

[Xkfyu]

I don't know, I feel like Naomi is very likely town, but I still have doubts about lynching Gerry now.

Who do we lynch if not Gerry?

[TwoFace]

idk. I mean for the sake of a more enjoyable game i'll still lynch gerry and part of me still thinks he could be scum, I am just not as sold as I was an hour ago.

[gerryoat]

I'm Town Roleblocker. Which is why I think Dunn is mafia as I doubt both town and maf have a RB. You guys are fucking morons lmao

[Xkfyu]

Who'd you target last night and why?

[gerryoat]

Naomi might not be town anymore, or they are just really fucking bad too lol

[gerryoat]

I targeted itep cause he was my scumread

[gerryoat]

I targeted itep cause he was my scumread