Mini 1836: Space Mafia (Game Over)

[massive]

Just as devil's advocate:

Why does Naomi-scum claim when she does? Who does this specific action protect?

Why does Naomi-scum claim to have protected no one N1? Even if she has to say she didn't protect itlepip, why doesn't scum-Naomi pick someone else she was townreading?

[Xkfyu]

Just as devil's advocate:

Why does Naomi-scum claim when she does? Who does this specific action protect?

Why does Naomi-scum claim to have protected no one N1? Even if she has to say she didn't protect itlepip, why doesn't scum-Naomi pick someone else she was townreading?

These are questions that I've been asking myself, and to which I honestly have no good answers to.

I can't make sense of most of what she's done, regardless of her alignment.

[TwoFace]

nobody was really under pressure when she claimed unless she is sacrificing herself to get gerry lynched but that seems unlikely. There was some talks about grapes around that time but I don't really see that as a way to protect grapes.

so assume gerry and naomi are both town, we have 2 town PRs who made bad decisions with their actions. Gerry blocking a claimed PR and Naomi not protecting the said PR.

If we believe these 2 claims, it comes down to do you believe my claim or do you believe dunn's claim. I honestly don't think town has all of these roles. I believed the neighbor claim at first because with my role it made sense, but now with all these other claims I am not so sure.

I think dunn is the way to go today but idk

[massive]

With your role, ALL of these roles makes some kind of sense -- they're lower-power roles that have to move to perform an action. They also fit with itlepip's Tracker. The oddball is probably gerryoat's claim of RB, since he's likely the most powerful of the bunch.

[TwoFace]

All these people lurking...

[Naomi-Tan]

@MOD: Can we get a +48 hour extension for the website being down?

[gerryoat]

Well that was fun.

[Zachstralkita]

arf

[Dunnstral]

bowwow

[TwoFace]

Meow

[Xkfyu]

@Mod: V/LA for the remainder of the weekend.

[Toto]

I think we should lynch either Dunn or Gerry. These two have had L-1 wagons on them so their flip would be most informative. I agree with massive Gerry does seem like the odd ball here.

[gerryoat]

I think we should lynch either Dunn or Gerry. These two have had L-1 wagons on them so their flip would be most informative. I agree with massive Gerry does seem like the odd ball here.

you're being dumb or mafia. which one is it

[Toto]

I think we should lynch either Dunn or Gerry. These two have had L-1 wagons on them so their flip would be most informative. I agree with massive Gerry does seem like the odd ball here.

you're being dumb or mafia. which one is it

Great rhetoric. If you are town your attitude is not helpful.

[TwoFace]

Serious question toto. Have you read what's been going on?

pip was blocked and killed.

Who do you think killed pip? Mafia or vig?

If Mafia that means Gerry being mafia makes little sense

[Something_Smart]

The deadline has been extended by 48 hours to accommodate for the site downtime.

New deadline: (expired on 2016-10-31 12:00:00)

[TwoFace]

^ fix that.

[Something_Smart]

VC 2.10

Xkfyu (2)- Zachstralkita, gerryoat
gerryoat (1) - Naomi-Tan
Dunnstral (1) - grapes
Zachstralkita (1) - PantherPunt
Naomi-Tan (1)- massive
Nosferatu (1)- Xkfyu

Not voting (4)- Toto, TwoFace, Dunnstral, Nosferatu

With 11 alive it takes 6 to lynch.

(expired on 2016-10-31 12:00:00)

Mod notes: Xkfyu is V/LA until Monday.

[grapes]

VOTE: gerry

[Toto]

Serious question toto. Have you read what's been going on?

pip was blocked and killed.

Who do you think killed pip? Mafia or vig?

If Mafia that means Gerry being mafia makes little sense

It makes sense if he is mafia with Dunn or Grapes. Or if mafia has another role altering role.

Rbing and killing itlepip makes sense in case itlepip got protection he wouldnt be able to use his role.

Rbing itlepip as town doesn't seem like the right play.

[Toto]

@mod do we really have 17h left?

[TwoFace]

Yeah toto. You're either really bad or mafia

[Toto]

Ok. It seems you disagree with me but dont want to explain why. Good job.

[TwoFace]

The why is obvious. You aren't making any sense. Aren't using logic.

First you were the one who thought Dunn and grapes are scum together.

Now when pip being blocked and killed 99% confirms Gerry is probably town and not scum, you post theories that make no sense.

Occam's razor usually applies and your applying the least likely scenarios. Unless you're scum and know what's really going on, your theories aren't anything that a rational person would come up with.

[PantherPunt]

Serious question toto. Have you read what's been going on?

pip was blocked and killed.

Who do you think killed pip? Mafia or vig?

If Mafia that means Gerry being mafia makes little sense

It makes sense if he is mafia with Dunn or Grapes. Or if mafia has another role altering role.

Rbing and killing itlepip makes sense in case itlepip got protection he wouldnt be able to use his role.

Rbing itlepip as town doesn't seem like the right play.

I agree with you toto, so don't listen to people calling this dumb. If I wasn't sure where I was on twoface I'd call his line here a scum narrative trying to power away from a Gerry lynch. But I think he's town. Which means he's not thinking well. Or is not nearly skeptical enough of all the information that's been presented