Mini 1836: Space Mafia (Game Over)

[Toto]

If it is a commuter massive had more reason to commute than xk. Although both of them were potential vigi targets.

@mod can a mafia commuter kill and commute on the same night?

[Something_Smart]

If it is a commuter massive had more reason to commute than xk. Although both of them were potential vigi targets.

@mod can a mafia commuter kill and commute on the same night?

16. Mafia members may kill and use a personal action in the same night.

[Toto]

@mod to be perfectly clear in hypothetical sandbox scenario mafia commuter commutes and targets player1 for a kill. Assuming there is no protection or any other mechanic affecting player1 or the mafia player, would player1 die?

[Something_Smart]

@mod to be perfectly clear in hypothetical sandbox scenario mafia commuter commutes and targets player1 for a kill. Assuming there is no protection or any other mechanic affecting player1 or the mafia player, would player1 die?

Yes.

[Toto]

VOTE: zach

[grapes]

Toto explain to me how you derived zachscum from what you just learned from that.

[grapes]

I'm not interested in lynching Xk. Feels like a mislynch.

Can we expect some gamesolving soon?

[Toto]

Toto explain to me how you derived zachscum from what you just learned from that.

Dunn jk zach why him and not any PR or his buddies?

I thought that no kill meant commuter. And dunn jk zach who could just commute away didnt make sense.

[grapes]

Why does a commuter make it make sense why there wasn't a scumkill?

Why does a scumteam with a jailkeeper need a commuter?

[Toto]

Why does a commuter make it make sense why there wasn't a scumkill?

Why does a scumteam with a jailkeeper need a commuter?

1) I thought it did make sense because I expected the answer to my question to the mod to be "no". Intuitively it made sense because the guy is leaving town so how the hell is he going to kill anyone at night.

2) It makes sense to me with all the other roles we have. We have 5 PRs, mafia probably has two.

[Zachstralkita]

Your basis falls apart when u realize I'm not scum

[TwoFace]

Only way we can suspect if a commuter role exsist is to find out if the vig had shots left and used one and a no kill happened. Don't really think it's s good time for the vig to claim yet cause we have numbers on our side. It's a very small chance scum wins this but not impossible.

[Toto]

If vig had shots left and used them and nobody died I expect a claim. It makes it a 1v1 in that situation and we can secure the win.

So my guess is that he didn't have shots left, didn't fire, or he hasn't reported yet.

[TwoFace]

If he didn't have shots we aren't dealing with a scum commuter.

So what I want to talk about is dunn's jk that 2nd night. He didn't block claimed body guard. He didn't block me.

So what do you think he was trying to do?

[Toto]

Yeah I understand commuter is less likely now given mod clarification.

Zach was at l-1. Vig killed maria n1 who was also at l-1. Dunn was trying to save zach.

[TwoFace]

Good point. But Dunn had to know he was getting shot as that was what the plan was.

[Toto]

Yeah I see that point as a counter argument. How was Dunn the public plan though? I was actually glad and surprised that was what happened

[Toto]

From my point of view vig was going to shoot dunn or zach most likely. Why not jk naomi and kill you or gerry? They really traded off a lot to save zach.

[grapes]

Yeah I understand commuter is less likely now given mod clarification.

Zach was at l-1. Vig killed maria n1 who was also at l-1. Dunn was trying to save zach.

Scum knew that twoface had a role that would, in the event of dunn's death, tell us exactly who he targeted.
And it sounds weird but the way things were going zach was a good vig shot, why not try and frame him and also possibly get the vig to out after shooting zach and him not dying if he did indeed predict a shot there

keeps a distraction alive or at the very least makes zach look bad if he gets shot

i mean yea if zach's scum then that's who dunn tries to save as well but it's also not a bad place to block in the dark either if he's town is what im saying

i really think it's either just xk/massive

you guys look like you're overthinking things a lot here

[Zachstralkita]

U guys are reaching..

[TwoFace]

Yeah I see that point as a counter argument. How was Dunn the public plan though? I was actually glad and surprised that was what happened

It was discussed during the day phase. That was how we were going to prove he was neighbor

[TwoFace]

From my point of view vig was going to shoot dunn or zach most likely. Why not jk naomi and kill you or gerry? They really traded off a lot to save zach.

Yeah that's the part I don't get

[Toto]

Gerry was not supposed to die. They wanted to blame zach being alive to vig getting rbed maybe.

[Toto]

Nah that doesnt make sense

[TwoFace]

Gerry was not supposed to die. They wanted to blame zach being alive to vig getting rbed maybe.

Gerry died because he blocked scum