Open 657: JK9++ (Game over)

[MiniDeathStar]

I make it look genuine.

Reality check:

MiniDeathStar's play is too Team Leader. The way she was sheeped is too.

Fountain throws Spade's name in for a split second, then sheeps Mini.

Because reasons.

I can't say too much at this point in time, but what I saw is becoming site meta.

These are your super genuine reads. Vague interpretations ("too team leader") and naked facts ("throws Spade's name, then sheeps") that are only scummy "because reasons". And of course you can't talk about it.

Totally not forced reads.

You're even wrong about the site meta's relevance. Trascend/Fountain is an EM player, alban and Spade are WhatsApp players and I'm a previously retired forum mafia player from a site that's now defunct. My last game was in 2011. If there is a site meta "due to influx of new players from another site", which there very well may be, you're misapplying it right now.

Also I'm not scum. So when I eventually die and reveal as town, get over that self-assurance and arrogance of yours and stop thinking you're a godlike scumhunter and so much better than everyone. You're not. Your reputation exists for a reason. Too bad you can't see it.

[Tiger moth]

you keep trying to draw my attention back to you while at the same time complaining that I'm looking at you.

'Nuff said. I've given my thoughts on you and I'm drawing a line under this right here. I'm not even going to comment on your 349.

[MiniDeathStar]

*sigh*

Tiger moth

still looks scummy but I don't think I want to vote her anymore. Less confident in that read now.

Fountain

lynch I can probably agree with, but I'm a little apprehensive to sheep these people in particular.

Charloux

isn't town anymore. That bizarro sentence made me super uncomfortable.

I've too few scumreads this game and lots of null reads. I keep getting dragged in useless arguments. I really should take a step back.

P. Edit: Yeah, okay. Fair. Sorry.

[MiniDeathStar]

Yup, Tiger's probably not scum.

VOTE: Fountain of Dreams. If this is scum, Klingon takes 0 credit for it.

[Fountain of Dreams]

TENSHII IS V/LA

AND IM DRUNK

DONT LYNCH US

I CANT DEFEND MYSLEF SUPER WELL RIGHT NOW IM SORRY

[Fountain of Dreams]

I THINK IM L-1

SOMEONE UNVOTE HOLY SHIT

[MiniDeathStar]

You're at L-2. Lane, Gamma, Tiger moth, Klingon, Me. 5/7.

[MiniDeathStar]

But yeah, I haven't heard from alban and Kop in days. Let's not lynch prematurely on Day 1.

UNVOTE: Fountain of Dreams.

[Fountain of Dreams]

ok.......................................................

[Gamma Emerald]

MDS is solid town.

[Tiger moth]

Waiting for alban to reply to Klingon's case. Got my own thought about it but that can wait until alban has replied.

Waiting for Fountain to reply to me.

Waiting for Charloux to explain his comment on Gamma.

Waiting for Kop to catch up. He seems to be over explaining stuff but otherwise has decent comments.

Creature seems to be working his way through the field.

[alban]

Sorry. Lot to catch up. Will start replying.

[lane0168]

TENSHII IS V/LA

AND IM DRUNK

DONT LYNCH US

I CANT DEFEND MYSLEF SUPER WELL RIGHT NOW IM SORRY

You can't defend yourself when you're sober. You don't even answer simple questions when asked several times by several people.

@mini, are you concerned scum will quick hammer? X2?

[alban]

Waiting for alban to reply to Klingon's case. Got my own thought about it but that can wait until alban has replied.

I have already said all that I had to. There's nothing more. Klingon has no case. If you do, ask me specific q's. If your q is the same as his, I am going to ignore you. I am sorry but this is turning out to be exactly like my last game in which I requested to be replaced out. I made a stray comment on the 1st page, which was taken out of proportion, everyone hounded me for days regarding explanation for that. If you are going to harp about what I said on the 1st page, even after 15 pages, that's your weight to carry. So, on my part, I am replying you for one last time on this and going to ignore all your and everyone else's subsequent q's on this. On your end, if you feel confident enough in your reads, I suggest you to vote for me and be done with that. Both of us will save time.

[Gamma Emerald]

I don't think that was necessary

[alban]

But yeah, I haven't heard from alban and Kop in days. Let's not lynch prematurely on Day 1.

UNVOTE: Fountain of Dreams.

Glad. The wagon against Fountain is disturbing. I haven't read the reasons ppl on his wagon have given for voting him, but going by the list of voters, appears like they are all going to be flimsy reasons.

[Gamma Emerald]

excuse me

[alban]

Does anyone have any q's for me that have gone unanswered?

[alban]

About Creature, his playing style doesn't seem to have changed from before. A lot of lightweight one-liners.

[alban]

About Bang, he is playing just as he plays. Aggressive, questioning and analytical. Spade, what do you think?

About Spade, he is not playing as he plays. He is usually very questioning and analytical, but he is not as active in this game. Maybe it's a lot to take in as his first game. Bang, what do you think?

[Gamma Emerald]

About Bang, he is playing just as he plays. Aggressive, questioning and analytical. Spade, what do you think?

About Spade, he is not playing as he plays. He is usually very questioning and analytical, but he is not as active in this game. Maybe it's a lot to take in as his first game. Bang, what do you think?

As which alignment

[Tiger moth]

Alban, I don't have any question for you and I don't suspect you. In fact, I have a town read on you. All I was saying in 360 was I was giving you first right of reply to Klingon's 275 and 276 before commenting on them myself. So why the attack on me for that?

[alban]

Charloux is being very odd and inconsistent, but also this is how I remember him playing. One game that I played with him, he got lynched for being weird and turned out to be the doc. So, I dunno.

For everyone else, I need to dig deeper in your posts. Will post that soon.

[alban]

About Bang, he is playing just as he plays. Aggressive, questioning and analytical. Spade, what do you think?

About Spade, he is not playing as he plays. He is usually very questioning and analytical, but he is not as active in this game. Maybe it's a lot to take in as his first game. Bang, what do you think?

As which alignment

That's tricky. Coz both of them make good mafias in that their mafia game doesn't vary much from their town game. Or at least I am not able to differentiate.
Both of them rely heavily on logic. So the only way to find their roles is to keep questioning them, in the hope that eventually they will be inconsistent. That's the only way to catch them.

[alban]

Alban, I don't have any question for you and I don't suspect you. In fact, I have a town read on you. All I was saying in 360 was I was giving you first right of reply to Klingon's 275 and 276 before commenting on them myself. So why the attack on me for that?

Since he asked people to vote for me, I assumed that you are supporting his version and expecting me to answer before deciding to vote for me. Sorry if you felt I was rude and attacked you. What I meant was this: even if you supported his version and voted for me, that's fine. Just that a conjecture can never be satisfactorily answered. So I wanted to convey that whoever felt that my comment on Spade's lack of an avatar was scummy, should vote for me and not wait for me to answer further, coz there's nothing more or new than what I have already said twice or thrice.