Mini 1851 : Order of the Stick Mafia - Epilogue

[Wisdom]

Think scum!Nacho, afraid that I'll flavorcop him and disprove his claim, would've tried to shoot me, hoping that my BP was a bluff?

that could be the case actually

it was all over if you caught him, and you were supposed to flavorcop him after all, so maybe he took the risk

Pretty sure this was the answer after all but Panther being town with a scum flavor distracted me

[Wisdom]

1. Infinity 324 - Oracle - 2-shot Neopolitan
2. Leonshade - Roy - BP/Vig/Flavorcop/Lyncher
3. PeregrineV - Durkon - Rolestopper
4. Tammy - O-chul - Vig/Neighbor
5. Nachomamma8 - Vaarsuvius - VT
6. Kagami - Mr. Scruffy - VT
7. Wisdom - Belkar - 1-shot Dayvig

Updated claimlist if anyone needs them

[Kagami]

VOTE: Wisdom

[Nachomamma8]

1. Infinity 324 - Oracle - 2-shot Neopolitan
2. Leonshade - Roy - BP/Vig/Flavorcop/Lyncher
3. PeregrineV - Durkon - Rolestopper
4. Tammy - O-chul - Vig/Neighbor
5. Nachomamma8 - Vaarsuvius - VT
6. Kagami - Mr. Scruffy - VT
7. Wisdom - Belkar - 1-shot Dayvig

Updated claimlist if anyone needs them

Vote: Leonshade

[Kagami]

^ that's fine too.

[Kagami]

VOTE: Leon

I keep forgetting about the xykon thing.

[Nachomamma8]

Pretty sure this was the answer after all but Panther being town with a scum flavor distracted me

There were 9 alive that day; it would be silly to lose a mislynch pursuing a hail mary when a very likely failure would mean I needed to mislynch four people in this game state instead of 3.

[Wisdom]

no, nacho, you literally had no other choice but hope he is not bulletproof
he was supposed to flavor cop you, and if he did it was game over for your team

[Leonshade]

VOTE: Nacho

[Leonshade]

VOTE: Wisdom

^ that's fine too.

Kagami, why not Nacho?

[Wisdom]

it is the only way the second nokill makes sense

[Nachomamma8]

If I flavorcopped you and the result was Vaarsuvius, we would've had no new info, besides confirmation of your claim.

And you didn't think that confirming me as town would have been useful?

[Wisdom]

kagami if you disagree with my logic, can you point me to where I am not thinking right instead of throwing votes at me?

[Infinity 324]

Yeah nacho what do you think about the second nokill? Pere doesn't make sense as scum so for me you doing the Hail Mary play makes the most sense

[Leonshade]

If I flavorcopped you and the result was Vaarsuvius, we would've had no new info, besides confirmation of your claim.

And you didn't think that confirming me as town would have been useful?

I wanted to catch/clear the farside slot since I was still scumreading that slot, and I started second-guessing my read on you after Cakez flipped scum.

[Kagami]

kagami if you disagree with my logic, can you point me to where I am not thinking right instead of throwing votes at me?

There was no justification for lynching panther before leon.

[Kagami]

Other than to enable a route to a scum win that otherwise was non existent

[Wisdom]

that doesnt make any sense

Game would end if Panther was scum, assuming Leon isn't a "threat to town"

same now for Nacho

why would you want to lynch a 3p first?

[Wisdom]

and you're still not explaining where I am wrong in my thoughts about the second nightkill

[Leonshade]

There's no explanation for the lack of an NK N2 if Wisdom is scum, or really anyone other than Nacho or Infinity. And Infinity isn't scum, so Nacho is.

Panther not reading the thread was a plausible third explanation, but that's gone now.

[Leonshade]

Actually Infinity might make the least sense, why try to shoot Nacho, have it fail then claim to have targeted him? And why would anyone try to shoot Nacho in the first place?

[Wisdom]

the only one who I would believe shot Nacho is Peregrine, but Peregrine is the one who stopped the kill so that's impossible

everyone else makes absolutely no sense shooting Nacho

Meaning the only explanation for the nokill is Nacho shooting Leon

[Tammy]

I would like to yell bout that stupid wick ass lynch yesterday, but I've had a couple and am in a good mood right now, so consider this a slap on the wrist and a bad boy!

Also, I have my gun now.

[Tammy]

When I'm at my computer I'll give more of my thoughts.

[Tammy]

visit

I picked up in this day two, which indicated that infinity was roled. Night two I expected either infinity or Kraska to die. I can't imagine anyone actually reading and paying attention to the game in full shooting nacho, a claimed vt who was widely scum read over Kraska, who was the most active pusher of cake (yes, wisdom I know you pushed it too but Kraska was passionate about it) or infinity who was obviously roled.