Mini Normal 1862 - Town win.

[Flubbernugget]

AA's hammer is towny as fuck unless he as scum figured out that Krylea is SK, which isn't unlikely but requires a whole lot of assumptions I don't want to make. AA is town until some of those assumptions become reality.

Krylea was an easy wagon for scum to drop a mishammer on as any alignment

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

To give credit where credit is due, AA's hammer wasn't full of really much anything.

[Flubbernugget]

AA's hammer is towny as fuck unless he as scum figured out that Krylea is SK, which isn't unlikely but requires a whole lot of assumptions I don't want to make. AA is town until some of those assumptions become reality.

His hammer was lucky as fuck.

What do you mean to imply by this?
1. If he's town, he logically deduced that Krylea was probably an anti-town role (scum) and lynched her.
2. If he's scum, he either
A. logically deduced that Krylea was sk and lynched her.
B. lolhammered what he thought was town for the mislynch and luckily happened upon serial killer

Do you mean to imply that 2B is the only possible outcome? I think that's incredibly unlikely.

I think it was the most likely of the options

[Flubbernugget]

She scum slipped.
Mafia tried to deny it happened.

Aside from that her play is different than what I've see from town.

As in, Rainbowdash tried to play off the slip?

[Flubbernugget]

A poor child trying to stay relevant.
Use the night to catch-up next time.

Get.
A.
Fucking.
Life.

Or at least make a good push at least ONCE pls

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

Rainbowdash said Naomi's thing wasn't a slip and Naomi thought Rainbowdash was the smartest pony alive.

Now this might just be me, but buddying up so close an early without much interaction is only town!possible with a mason pair.

[Flubbernugget]

1.Gamma Emerald
2.Naomi-Tan
3.Asphodel
4.Flubbernugget
5.TwoFace
6.The RealGin-N-Tonic
7.All Alone
8.Human Sequencer
9.Alisae

Posting cuz the OP isn't updated and I need this

I honestly thought Gamma died during one of the days Ive seen so little from them

[Flubbernugget]

Rainbowdash said Naomi's thing wasn't a slip and Naomi thought Rainbowdash was the smartest pony alive.

Now this might just be me, but buddying up so close an early without much interaction is only town!possible with a mason pair.

After the insanity that was rainbowdash's play I wouldn't leave a scum interaction like this off the table

[Flubbernugget]

But I honestly believe it's a slip. That's not a scumtell. Maybe a stupid tell but not a scumtell

you're pushing dumbtells

Oh hi Gamma

Sorry I forgot you

[Flubbernugget]

VOTE: Naomi

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

Rainbowdash said Naomi's thing wasn't a slip and Naomi thought Rainbowdash was the smartest pony alive.

Now this might just be me, but buddying up so close an early without much interaction is only town!possible with a mason pair.

After the insanity that was rainbowdash's play I wouldn't leave a scum interaction like this off the table

Well considering Rainbow flipped scum, I'm basically calling Naomi out on it lmao

Guess that wasn't clear

[Flubbernugget]

Nah I'm looking back and I misread it

[TwoFace]

What was the case with the enabler role?

I personally don't know how far I'll dabble into that area because this is my first game with ascetics and enablers

if it were a player who's never heard of or encounterd an enabler role before, I could get somebody saying definitely that scum don't have day talk.

Enabler allows scum to have daytalk

Somebody who is familiar with that role imo should never assume that scum don't have daytalk. If she said probably or something that would be different. She said it like it was fact.

I think she's scum for it. I think she's scum for other things also which I sort of explained so it's not just the slip

[TwoFace]

She scum slipped.
Mafia tried to deny it happened.

Aside from that her play is different than what I've see from town.

As in, Rainbowdash tried to play off the slip?

She straight up said it wasn't a slip.

[Alisae]

Actually, why didn't Krylea claim?
And who did she try to kill N1? Grey?

It might be worth awhile to go back to her ISO or something to see if she crumbed or something or if she somehow softed or some shit to scum. It could have been very likely that she SK told to one of the scum and that's why there was a push on her.

While we're at it.
VOTE: All Alone

Actually, ya know what. I really don't like you.

Challenge: All Alone

So yeah there's no reason to town read a sk hammer but what exactly is your problem here?

And I just noticed that no one bought my attmept to fake gladiate. Aww rip ;~;
Yeah, I still think that their vote on me is still scummy as fuck.
Like legit I don't see why town would compare my play to my first ever game of mafia ever.

[Gamma Emerald]

What was the case with the enabler role?

I personally don't know how far I'll dabble into that area because this is my first game with ascetics and enablers

if it were a player who's never heard of or encounterd an enabler role before, I could get somebody saying definitely that scum don't have day talk.

Enabler allows scum to have daytalk

Somebody who is familiar with that role imo should never assume that scum don't have daytalk. If she said probably or something that would be different. She said it like it was fact.

I think she's scum for it. I think she's scum for other things also which I sort of explained so it's not just the slip

Read what you just wrote. ENCRYPTOR gives scum daytalk.

[TwoFace]

Ok typos my bad. Replace enabler with encryptor

[Alisae]

Why do you want to run down Naomi?

Both days she didn't really have any votes (except by the end of day 2 where she voted Gamma) because I got on her case about it. Also buddying the weakest player has it's risk reward. If she could pull it off (which she did at the time), then she gets towncred from me. If she couldn't she gets lynched. At the time I saw no reason why scum would go out of their way to buddy me when I could have turned into a lynch so that's mostly why I gave her towncredit, but I think Naomi buddied me so that I'd give her towncredit. Also her not voting implies that she's fencesitting.

[TwoFace]

y'all can call me stupid idgaf but Naomi is aware of an enabler role. Anyone who is familiar with that should know that's a possibility. It could just be different mindset of whatever but I just don't Buy she didn't consider encryptor a possibility

Fixed my original post.

[TwoFace]

Well sort of lol

[TwoFace]

Why do you want to run down Naomi?

Both days she didn't really have any votes (except by the end of day 2 where she voted Gamma) because I got on her case about it. Also buddying the weakest player has it's risk reward. If she could pull it off (which she did at the time), then she gets towncred from me. If she couldn't she gets lynched. At the time I saw no reason why scum would go out of their way to buddy me when I could have turned into a lynch so that's mostly why I gave her towncredit, but I think Naomi buddied me so that I'd give her towncredit. Also her not voting implies that she's fencesitting.

Idk if this statement is true but if it is, that's not the Naomi I'm used to.

I'll read more pages on my phone tomorrow

[Alisae]

I mean that she didn't have any votes by the end of the day. But TF what about that statement stands out for you?

[TwoFace]

I just don't remember her being shy with her votes.

[Alisae]

OH. Well she had no vote by the end of day 1. This is what she responded when I asked for her scumreads:

During the start of D1 I thought I had the game solved with; Gin and Gamma and Ircher being the red team
Then Interactions happened making -Grey-, Alisae, TwoFace and Human Sequencer Green
Then Gamma Claims and I'm like wut?
Then RD comes out and is like Here is good stuff while -Grey- is red and I'm like; Hmm yeah thats well thought out.. but then turns out there red.. with so much effort too and I'm just confused..
and then this flip I guess Gamma Gin could be the last two remaining red members but I just can't bring myself to trust my gamma read after that claim.. Urgh.. everything is going wrong!

Think that explains it.

[Alisae]

Also Naomi still voted Gamma by the end of day 2.