Mini Normal 1862 - Town win.

[inspectorscout]

Your mod asked me to do a votecount since he can't be here now. You guys achieved a hammer, though. So I'll start the night already, and do the flip.

As I can't lock the thread, be an adult and refrain from posting.

Thanks!

[inspectorscout]

Official VC 1.FINAL

Ircher (1)(L-6) [TwoFace]
Naomi-tan (1)(L-6) [flubbernugget]
Grey (2)(L-5) [Rainbowdash, krylea]
Rainbowdash (7)(LYNCH) [Human Sequencer, Grey, Alisae, All Alone, Gamma Emerald, TheRealGin-N-Tonic, Ircher]
All Alone (1)(L-6) [Asphodel]

Not Voting (1) (Naomi-tan)

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.
_{Accurate to post 1340}

Mod Notes

I'm taking this votecount over since XnadrojX asked me. As I can't lock the thread, please refrain from posting.

[inspectorscout]

Rainbowdash was lynched. He was a

Spoiler:

Mafia Ascetic

Night 1 ends in (expired on 2016-12-26 04:05:47).

Please send your night actions to XnadrojX

[inspectorscout]

It was an interesting set up and a nice change.

@MOD: for your first time as a mod, you did well. I recommend getting a backup moderator who can provide VCs and flips when you're asleep.

That's a comod


Anyway; Gratz to the town!
And gratz to jordan for his first game!

[inspectorscout]

I thought non-normal roles needed a full rolecard flip in normal games, but I'm unsure. I don't think you can blame jordan for that.

About the balance of the game; the serial killer also hurts town by a large amount. A neighborizer is often seen as null power, and the cop - if claimed, can't get protected while getting results.
In total, this game didn't have much power on any side; that's not bad at all, since there were 2 anti-town 'factions'. I wasn't involved in the review process, but I would've passed this as well. His choices may have been bold, but definitely not unreasonable.

Town played really well. They had their ups and downs, but got back to their wincon every time: lynching scum.

[inspectorscout]

^incredible post
you should apply that methodological mind to your games!

I wish I could. This is numbers and theoretical power, thinking of possible scenarios and stuff. I can't think like that about humans, sadly. Also, my sense of balance is still mainly gut, just like my reads.

Anyway, this game isn't mine so I shouldn't clutter postgame discussion.
Cheers!

[inspectorscout]

Please, behave.
Your opinion on the role has been noted by the mod, and he'll surely think about it if he decides to include a traitor in one of his following games.
For now though: yes, you may disagree with the role, but it's his first game. You can say you dislike it, but stop there; there is no point in discussing it further. He knows it. Game is over, done.

The setup is pretty complicated yet well done for a first time mod, my first game was a lot more boring. I'm sure you can forgive him for the traitor, no?

[inspectorscout]

There is a point where I think discussion does not improve or progresses anything. Sharing your opinion is perfectly fine, but I don't see the use of hearing them 20 times. And it certainly isn't the best feeling as a mod if your players are 'angry' because of your choices, even if you can perfectly justify them.

There is a point where discussion becomes shitting on others. Don't go there.