Star Wars Rogue One [GAME OVER]

[The Thinker]

Cheetory's Disney Upick as Hobgoblin
We fucking sucked, despite my partner, Tommahawk, being a great player! I did fuck all.

Kuroi's Princess Bride Mafia as Sword of Damocles
I like, logged on maybe 3 times the whole game? I couldn't do it. I don't know why, but I couldn't.
Got caught for it and boom, dead.

[The Thinker]

I know it's not a foolproof meta defense, but I feel it should be considered if nothing else. Especially since you're wrong.

[Infinity 324]

Got caught for it and boom, dead.

You...you survived to endgame there and won in a draw.

[Pine-A-Tonics]

Town is fucked the day Ari decides to actually post as scum. Therefore, no meta defense saying "I don't do this as scum," IMO is ever valid. It's great to start looking into suspicions but to base a complete read on it, is highly fallible.

/Gin

[The Thinker]

Got caught for it and boom, dead.

You...you survived to endgame there and won in a draw.

Did we actually!?

See, I logged on so infrequently I thought we were dead...

I wish I could make this up. I honestly thought we got lynched on account of me!

[The Thinker]

I had three posts that whole game btw

[Infinity 324]

Ok we get it you're self-metaing

[The Thinker]

Town is fucked the day Ari decides to actually post as scum. Therefore, no meta defense saying "I don't do this as scum," IMO is ever valid. It's great to start looking into suspicions but to base a complete read on it, is highly fallible.

/Gin

Agreed. I had one game I can recall where I carried a torch RC set up and won from actual activity and scum play.

Cheetory's Mafia Café
I was so excited I played well that game it's ridiculous!

So rare, but you can see and compare it to me here if you like.
I'd get a more recent meta, but I don't think I have one...

[The Thinker]

Ok we get it you're self-metaing

I'm just trying to help!

- Ari

[Pine-A-Tonics]

Ari, stop working against yourself. Just analyze the game and give us your opinions. Whether you are town or not will come solely off of being able to tell what your true intentions are.

We don't need you to figure out who you are, that's our job, now you do the same and try to figure out everyone else, ya feel me?

/Gin

[Infinity 324]

Ok but you're going a bit too far defending yourself and not focusing on trying to find scum, which is scumplay. I wanna know who you think is scum and who isn't and why.

[Infinity 324]

Ninja'ed basically saying the same thing

[Titus]

Ok, this game is next on my catchup list tomorrow.

[The Thinker]

Ari, stop working against yourself. Just analyze the game and give us your opinions. Whether you are town or not will come solely off of being able to tell what your true intentions are.

We don't need you to figure out who you are, that's our job, now you do the same and try to figure out everyone else, ya feel me?

/Gin

Understood!
Sorry if I got a little carried away with myself there! I blame Mastina

I'll work on this though. Tuesdays and Wednesdays are my busiest days (I work in 5 hours and took time out of sleeping to be here). I'll see what I can sort after this.

[BBmolla]

infinity are you just scum reading me cause you're mad I don't you rebel leader

like you can admit it if so it's ok

[BBmolla]

Nulltown: piper,

alban, AJ

honeslty what lmfao

[The Thinker]

Who is scum BB?

Does Infinity scumreading you ping you as driven be either alignment?

[BBmolla]

Who is scum BB?

Does Infinity scumreading you ping you as driven be either alignment?

their reads seem garbage as fuck so I tend to give people the benefit of the doubt and just assuem they're scum

[BBmolla]

mastin always misreads me though, so that doesn't apply to her. she actually probably "townreads" me more as scum than as town.

[BBmolla]

AJ is scum

[Infinity 324]

infinity are you just scum reading me cause you're mad I don't you rebel leader

like you can admit it if so it's ok

Nope

Who is scum BB?

Does Infinity scumreading you ping you as driven be either alignment?

their reads seem garbage as fuck so I tend to give people the benefit of the doubt and just assuem they're scum

[BBmolla]

you have aj as town above like 70% of the playerlist don't roll your eyes at me bro

[Infinity 324]

Bad =/= scum

[SirCakez]

Thinker who is scum?

Apparently I am by virtue of Thinker most definitely surely actually truly being town. Clearly.

What?

Thinker's posting continues to underwhelm. That meta defense was awful.
Infinity what makes AJ town? He might be bad but he's bad scum.

[Infinity 324]

I get the feeling he's posting his original thoughts instead of trying to think about how it would look to others. Especially the part about motive hunting, it just seems like not the best approach to appeal to the group.