Open 668 - Diffusion of Power [Game Over]

[ssbm_Kyouko]

Hello everybody, new player here. I hope we have a fun game.

VOTE: chilledtea
I prefer Icetea

This post is not alignment indicative and the only post in necta's iso. I refuse to believe this gives you a scum lean.

I thought necta was 3rd to vote chilled actually which is why I was thinking a scum lean was fine when that's all there is to go off of. It's easy to move that weak of a read to town after the slot starts posting more anyways, so why is it so hard to believe chilled could get a scumlean off of this?

I want to say something about the 3 votes on me, but really I can't say anything. I mean it is obv rvs wagon don't know what reaction I am supposed to give.

If you're town, and it's "obv rvs," there's no reason to react.

VOTE: chilledtea

What chilled did is pretty much exactly what I'd do in his situation, there's not really anything to say when you're getting wagoned for no reason in RVS

[ssbm_Kyouko]

(In fact, I'm getting irritated by people who replace in and then charge that early pushes are on weak evidence -

NSS

.)

What is NSS?

27 wasn't rvs btw

Did anyone even ask chilled for reasoning about why Pep's RVS vote was obviously fake? What did you mean by 25 chilled?

Oh nice, an ISO analysis.

Hand of Suspicion

This made me giggle. Not just a finger of suspicion, but an entire hand.

KT certainly seems to be trying hard with that long wall, but I don't think it's ringing true to me.
VOTE: KT

It reads like newb town. After reading it I looked at his join date expecting it to be recent, but it isn't. That's problematic.

What reads like newb town? KT? I think he's said he's basically new, back from a long break because his first game on site went really badly. I laughed pretty hard when I read that story actually, it was kind of embarrassing since I was walking home at the time

I spend 30 minutes doing an ISO analysis giving my thoughts on a player and i get called a newb and scum


I'mhonestly done

Just keep trying

[Transcend]

tr kt

no longer tr texcat

unsure about chilled

VOTE: pepchoninga

[Transcend]

actually sure run this up

VOTE: blawb

[Transcend]

ok nvm tex can still be town

i just don't think he understands the motivation behind kt's posts. his assessment of me looks genuine imo.

[chilledtea]

(In fact, I'm getting irritated by people who replace in and then charge that early pushes are on weak evidence -

NSS

.)

What is NSS?

27 wasn't rvs btw

Did anyone even ask chilled for reasoning about why Pep's RVS vote was obviously fake? What did you mean by 25 chilled?

I was joking. I thought that's what you do in rvs, joke around to get a reaction. Majority of my games I've replaced in, and the ones I participated from the beginning I tend to lurk the initial phase out.

[Transcend]

i guess

im not that good at reading rvs

what do you think of kt/blawb/texcat

[chilledtea]

kt - town
texcat - cautious because she is very common lynchbait.
blawb - scumread him for his entry post. His town read on me is unlike kyouko's, feels a little off.

[chilledtea]

There was a very memorable "sharing is caring" game that I played with her, where she was the cop, she was almost ran up to get lynched on day 1, she cleared my slot, dropped hints like a pro, and we won, partly because of that.

[Transcend]

kt - town
texcat - cautious because she is very common lynchbait.
blawb - scumread him for his entry post. His town read on me is unlike kyouko's, feels a little off.

i agree with all of this

[Transcend]

im gonna have trouble sorting pep this game because i read people fairly often based on their voting patterns

[Persivul]

What chilled did is pretty much exactly what I'd do in his situation, there's not really anything to say when you're getting wagoned for no reason in RVS

If there's nothing to say, you would presumably say nothing. Chilled didn't say nothing. He talked about not knowing what to say in the situation. That's very different.

[Persivul]

What is NSS?

No Shit, Sherlock. IOW,

your observation was exceedingly obvious

.

[Creature]

idk how much townreads and scumreads I have.

[Persivul]

What reads like newb town? KT? I think he's said he's basically new, back from a long break because his first game on site went really badly.

Yes, that post reads to me like typical analysis from a newbie town player. But, I checked KT's topics list and it looks like he's played 8 or 9 games. Even being over a couple of years, I'd think that would move him past the newbie stage.

[Persivul]

im not that good at reading rvs

If you recognize that, why were you making reads during rvs?

[Creature]

Pepchoninga - Nah, lurking = probscum!Pepcho
Blawb - Looks like the scum!Blawb I know
Transcend - Not worried about rn
Persivul - hmm
aronagrundy - hmmmmmm
ssbm_Kyouko - Okay, town for now
chilledtea - Not townreading
notscience DiamondSentinel - Null
Necta - Town
texcat - Town
Subutai - Only RVSed
Creature - Town!me
KTthecreeper - Town

[Transcend]

notscience as null?

[Creature]

What noticeable thing he has done?

[KTthecreeper]

im not that good at reading rvs

If you recognize that, why were you making reads during rvs?

I'm in no means a newb I have no idea why I give you newb vibes...

[Subutai]

I'll be catching up this evening.

UNVOTE: Creature

No need to keep RVS vote.

[Not Chara]

VC 1.4

- Day 1 -

Blawb [4]

: ssbm_Kyouko, Creature, chilledtea, Transcend

Transcend [2]

: Pepchoninga, KTthecreeper

KTthecreeper [2]

: texcat, Blawb

Pepchoninga [1]

: aronagrundy

Persivul [1]

: Necta

chilledtea [1]

: Persivul

Subutai [1]

: notscience

Not Voting [1]

: Subutai

13 players alive, 7 votes to lynch.
Day 1 ends in (expired on 2017-02-02 22:57:38).

[chilledtea]

What chilled did is pretty much exactly what I'd do in his situation, there's not really anything to say when you're getting wagoned for no reason in RVS

If there's nothing to say, you would presumably say nothing. Chilled didn't say nothing. He talked about not knowing what to say in the situation. That's very different.

This is basically punishing me for not lurking. Or not ignoring.
I felt something was expected out of me, so I said what I said.

[Persivul]

im not that good at reading rvs

If you recognize that, why were you making reads during rvs?

I'm in no means a newb I have no idea why I give you newb vibes...

First...was the quote a mistake, because I don't see the relevance.

Second, thought this was clear, but if not - that post of yours seemed like it could be town to me if from a newbie. If from an experienced player, it's scummy.

[Persivul]

This is basically punishing me for not lurking. Or not ignoring.
I felt something was expected out of me, so I said what I said.

Punishing? It's not punishing, it's analyzing and sorting.

I feel for you, as I went through the same thing. I replaced in a lot, and so I didn't know what to do in rvs until I had some practice.

On the one hand, I sometimes got pressured as town for that. OTOH, there was a time I was scum and got caught by it.