Newbie 1770: Water Game Over

[TierShift]

I want to vote TS but he's the only one trying to work with me. Struggling to find the scum motivation behind stopping the fight between me and grey where if both me and grey are town, this is like candy for scum!TS.

I want to plant my vote on fykus/grey, maybe pep? but I want to see what moogin has to say first.

Finally you're seeing the light. Now would you lend me your vote and use it on jack please?

And RC needs to go down d2.

Not sure if I agree.

Anyway, jack is clearly the best lynch here. Absolutely preferable over RC, who did derail the wagon.

Fykus, lynching a townie is always preferable over the WIFOM that not lynching a townie creates. With power roles and other stuff, it simply is too dangerous to not lynch all the town you can. Do you understand that, fykus? Do you not see that rC would have simply let the lynch on jack gone through if he's scum and jack town?

[RadiantCowbells]

intent. claim

[TierShift]

Is jack at L-1?

[RadiantCowbells]

VOTE: JackChaos

He is now.

[-Grey-]

UNVOTE:

I want the hammer.

[-Grey-]

PR's

: Do not counter whatever JackChaos fakeclaims. I'm hammering him regardless, so keep your mouth shut and stay alive.

[RadiantCowbells]

If you do this and it flips a PR I am policy lynching you. I understand the value in such play but can't condone it in the newbie queue.

[-Grey-]

Don't get too mad at me short-circuiting your buddy's attempt to fish a PR on the way out the door.

[RadiantCowbells]

i have no way of deducing whether what you are currently doing is cheeky scum play or town feigned overconfidence. You are not required to play in such a way and I don't trust your slot.

[RadiantCowbells]

Which is another way of saying what I said before; you can pull certain shit but if you're wrong when you're pulling certain shit you are going to be PLed and that's a problem with you not knowing when to pull certain shit.
I have never mislynched a cop guilty that I have faked to fruition, but in years I have only made 5 of them. Tempted to do more, but only 5.
If you don't have the discipline to realize when you're actually 100% sure someone is scum and to know when you CAN actually be 100% sure someone is scum, you get PLed. Oh, and if you're scum it's just good to lynch you.

[-Grey-]

Apparently, the scum team expects a cop to be in this setup.

[nydushermain]

What's the VC?

[-Grey-]

What's the VC?

L-2

[JackChaos]

Christ sorry all. I'm here. let me catch up

[JackChaos]

Grey and RC are scumbuddies. Grey makes all of these if-then statements about RC's loyalties because he knows that Jack will flip town, thus "clearing" RC of being scum. Why not lynch RC and and if she turns out to be town then Jack is cleared, why does it have to be jack who gets the lynch?

^THIS. I keep telling you guys that those slots Grey and RC inherited were suspect for a reason. The reason Grey is pushing so hard to have my lynched is because I hit the nail on the head when I said he was trying to pull votes off of RC and scatter votes.

I'm actually not sure about RC anymore, maybe it's just because he's a better player than Toto seemed, but I'm damned sure Grey is pushing so hard to have a townie lynched because he's scum.

Go ahead and do it. Lynch me or RC. I'll take the hit if you want, but day 2 you better lynch Grey because he's orchestrated this whole thing.

[JackChaos]

I know my word means nothing on day 1 but believe me, I'm town and if you lynch me, day 2 you had better put that knife on Grey's throat because he is suspect as hell and if you thumb back through this entire post, all of his "Oh I'm sure," "absolutely" "scummy as hell," comments are all complete bs and unfounded. We had good reads on those slots in the beginning of the game for good reason.

[JackChaos]

phone

ya sorry about that. Caught bronchitis and spent all day sunday at the VA hospital. Since then I've just been draggin' ass.

[JackChaos]

If you do this and it flips a PR I am policy lynching you. I understand the value in such play but can't condone it in the newbie queue.

I hope so. His overconfidence is because he's completely full of it. Scroll back through the entire post and tell me where any of his accusations were true.

At one point I even said that I didn't know if mafia knew each other was mafia until nightfall (because that's how it is in the town of salem game.) He informed me that scum knows who scum are in the beginning of the game.

Sure an experienced player could be faking stuff like that but I've freely admitted that this is my first game of mafia scum and that I haven't played it much anywhere else but Town of Salem, and I've definitely been bumbling through this game so you tell me what is more feasible here:

-A new player is an epic scum player that faked that knowledge

-or that the guy, who inherited a suspect slot, is breeding all this contempt towards a new player to take eyes off himself?

[JackChaos]

Either way, if I get lynched on day 1, all of his absolutes and accusations of pure scum towards me, better be held against him on day 2.

[Formerfish]

Grey, what'd I do to get into top tier town for you?

[Formerfish]

And jack, intent has been made on you (in a way) which means you should claim in you next post thereabouts.

[Formerfish]

I'm glad to see that in a roundabout way we came back to RC being scum.

[Fykus]

Im with jack. VOTE: grey

[-Grey-]

Grey, what'd I do to get into top tier town for you?

You're more town than Nydus and Fykus.

[-Grey-]

Im with jack. VOTE: grey

I'm gonna laugh in your face for the test of the game when he flips red, noob.