Newbie 1769: Happy New Year! (Post-Game)

[-Grey-]

you're saying that though like a cassie wagon would have been a permanent vanity wagon

No I'm not. Wtf are you smoking?

I damned near push Cass into a nervous breakdown. No fucking way she leaves me alive as scum when she knows I can turn around and come after her like a rabid dog.

she'd still have to wait until N2

and if rc is her partner apparently they shoot creature no matter what

i assume you still townread me??

and schadd_ and cassielle as a team is... lol...

Eh, I forgot Rask claimed d1, so there is that.

[schadd_]

and schadd_ and cassielle as a team is... lol...

[stock photo of uncomfortable guy holding up both hands as if to say "no thanks"] + [tornado]

[cassielle]

schadd_ i was asking to try and get a better opinion of you, what reason do you have to not share your best answer at the present time ffs

how is schadd_ getting these hard townreads i do not understand thsi in the least

i dont see it, every argument boils down to... well, one about as good as my grey argument, but im not trying hard to sell anyone on that because i recognize its a crap argument. its just this "this feels town" and to me it looks NAI at best

[Raskolnikov]

can I get opinions on schadd

his shitposting bothers me and he seems to be kinda happy we're in mylo

[schadd_]

his shitposting bothers me and he seems to be kinda happy we're in mylo

it's less happy and more of the feeling of "well, now we know what needs to be sorted out" after you pee yourself

[gigabyteTroubadour]

can I get opinions on schadd

his shitposting bothers me and he seems to be kinda happy we're in mylo

?? i don't get this vibe at all?

i wanted a scumcase yesterday because his thought process reads really naturally here and like i Get it

dunno how to go more indepth than i did D2 w/o counterarguing someone

[gigabyteTroubadour]

his shitposting bothers me and he seems to be kinda happy we're in mylo

it's less happy and more of the feeling of "well, now we know what needs to be sorted out" after you pee yourself

this is the perfect description

[cassielle]

opinion: coasting scum since d1

the townreads are all gutreads only because his ISO is devoid of real content to build an opinion on

find me unambiguous scumhunting that isnt sheeping and i will change my mind right here right now

[Raskolnikov]

cass I really wish I knew more about you and what your acting ceiling was

[gigabyteTroubadour]

ooh!

2. i like the people at dominion forum but part of the fun of mafia is making character judgments about people you don't know
3. thus far, i have been mafia twice and town once. at this point, i was happy to get town just because of that, but i also like town more because knowing everything is boring
4. i like target-investigative roles, the example here being tracker

UNVOTE: gigabyteTroubador, VOTE: ThinkBig

_schadd, is your TB vote serious?

mine is

a bit. the questions were all things that i would either say or not say, if you catch my drift

_schadd, schadd_, sch_add are all fine. i'm usually schadd, i think it wanted a non-alphanumeric or something

extremely unambiguous

not sheeping at all (remember why i don't explain shit early D1?)

this is the vote of someone reading the game as town

[gigabyteTroubadour]

i seriously do not think those two posts are fakeable as scum

[Raskolnikov]

@MOD

did scum get extra nighttalk from the deadline delay?

[schadd_]

schadd_ i was asking to try and get a better opinion of you, what reason do you have to not share your best answer at the present time ffs

the first part is the most generic reason to ever ask a question in this game. the second part is uh, you and grey seems like way the most sensical scumteam (is that what you meant by best answer?). other than that i would say rc is a tad scummier than gbt. am currently rereading to get any sensible ranking of scumteams

[cassielle]

it looks extremely ambiguous to me gbT. find me one more, because i cant agree to that one, and if i cant agree to the second ill drop it for now because i really really hate moving the goalposts, always feel guilty about it

[cassielle]

EBWOP and besides if thats the only one thats REALLY not very scumhunty and should be outweighed by the size of his content-free ISO after that point

[gigabyteTroubadour]

it looks extremely ambiguous to me gbT. find me one more, because i cant agree to that one, and if i cant agree to the second ill drop it for now because i really really hate moving the goalposts, always feel guilty about it

not really

he literally stated his reasoning right after and it was an AI thing

does it read like he came up with the reasoning AFTER being asked?

if not just trust me it's town

will look for better examples

(btw i think town isos are more likely to dwindle as the day/game goes on unless scum are losing hard but even then town can get apathetic)

[gigabyteTroubadour]

@GBT, rask: how many games have you played?

i feel in a bit of a weird position. GBT can apparently confidently townread half the cast, and neither of rask and creature has really called them out on it. so, uh, we're golden i guess?

i'm gonna evaluate lynches, pretending that we haven't won the game. which is a possibility

TB is uh a vt if he's town, so that's a fine lynch. to me, he seems totally fake, but sometimes i hear people talking IRL and i'm like, you're scum, buddy, and TB gives me the same impression as those people. also, the fact that he colored "vanilla townie" green makes me wanna puke. esp. since it's the mod color, as i mentioned. he still has some posting to do.

rakkar is an uninformative lynch i think. he has posted twice and been talked about.

shade is active and tryna scumhunt, so, a bad lynch. creature is on him, though, and he's town. as far as my read goes, uh, the questions seem hard to fake but there seems to be a bit of a non-linear character progression. i will either explain that later or never.

another option: if GBT is actually

that

good at reading people, we can just lynch them and then know they're not fudging things up. which is a nagging concern that i have, albeit a small one

gonna stay on TB for now. there is more to be learned and we already know a lot, it looks like

bits on me are scumhunting imo

he's saying something controversial and asking a question to build upon that thought process

[gigabyteTroubadour]

also wait cassie gtfo with this stuff about early game content

u read my last newbie where i basically solved the game in D1 RVS

emphasis on basically penguinpower was just really scummy and sugarnips was a nulllurker so

[gigabyteTroubadour]

VOTE: Nobita

sheep me

Or not.

VOTE: Fredrick E Campbell

Selynee's RVS vote and Schadd_'s are obvtown for basically the same reason

[Aeronaut]

@MOD

did scum get extra nighttalk from the deadline delay?

Yes, but no posts were made in the time between when the game was supposed to open, and the beginning of D3.

[RadiantCowbells]

#570 i can practically hear "target locked." thats a bit of hindsight but jfc

See this is just bullshit shade throwing that falls apart when you actually follow the link you're referring to, and that's why I wanted those posts linked.

VOTE: Casserole

Rask thought I was likely scum with two different people. If was a genuine read, Why would he want to push either of those two over me when lynching me is objectively more likely to hit scum?

It didn't make sense, and this right here just shows that you're throwing shit against the wall and hoping people don't actually pay attention.

ehh

[gigabyteTroubadour]

@MOD

did scum get extra nighttalk from the deadline delay?

Yes, but no posts were made in the time between when the game was supposed to open, and the beginning of D3.

is this information we're allowed to know :////

i feel like it's not lol

[cassielle]

that game also had a lot more scummy behavior on all sides. this game has long stretches of "EVERYBODY IS TOWN" and then someone goes insane and gets lynched (i.e., tb lurking eternally, mbg jumping off the deep end personality-wise)

so either everyone here is awful at scumhunting or scum are hiding in your townblock, like they have been all game, and either way that means that your d1 reads in this game arent worth anything, no matter how good they are in other games

you literally picked me and TB for the only scum possibles d1 and i had to break that up myself, and tb flipped green anyway. your d1 reads were crap, QED, no matter how confident you are in your scumfinding abilities they were objectively bad

[Raskolnikov]

Uhhh

So that leaves cass/Grey.

yeah that's my first pick atm

Lol, you guys are saying 772 was theatre? That was probably the first scumteam I ruled out and I'm not making the same mistake as I did with matt again.

Hmmmmm I hope both of you have a really good explanation for exactly why it's fake.

Or I guess you might have overlooked it to string a team together? Mmm that makes sense too, we don't all have the same wincon after all

[cassielle]

like in the (unthinkable) case i flipped red your d1 reads would still be wrong as a matter of actual logic so i dont see why your d1 reads being good in another game are defensible here