I have things to say about this; quoting to remin myself later because I'm tired, but real quick I don't think we should even be considering momo today. most of your reasons sound ok on the surface but could also be explained by lack of experience, so, the reasonable doubt test fails there for me. the only thing that i think stands out from that argument is that it feels forced to you. that's kind of subjective and not something i can confirm beyond going "does he actually seemed forced to ME?" which he doesn't, really... just... new and bad. just saying i think a newbie lynch is not the best we could do today.In post 1165, Hawk wrote:Mmmm I think Momo has been playing pretty scummy. His play feels very forced and consistently just trying to snowball some kind of pressure. His counter pushes to pressure on himself is to OMGUS and or draw up misreps. Mail and myself (possible music) actually scumread him for reasons concerning his play but he doesn't engage with that instead presses us as policy lynching him. He misreps me saying that I'm following M&M when I was the first one to objectively scumread him. I don't think he's as new as he acts and it reflects in some of his statements meaning I think he recognizes what he's doing he's just choosing to ignore it for newbie shield.
M&M I think at least RC's head is very passionate and has displayed a very apt desire to be the center of attention and lead town. Confident to the point of being cocky I don't think even an experienced Hydra wants to draw that much attention as scum. I do find her stubbornness to refuse to give cases and only give one or two reasons at most with no follow up for her pushes to be annoying and kinda scummy so I can see how LQ and Uzi don't like it.
Mail on the other hand has been rather collected and calm. A nice compliment to RC but no less manipulative/cunning in their play.
Overall I think that slot is more likely town than scum but I don't think I could see reason to lynch there over Momo today. Not unless Momo's play really picks up and he stops playing so objectively terrible -_-;
i like mm (it sounds like you're saying you think they are scum?) i suppose if things were directed at me it would be different. i see good thought processes there and good motivation which tells me they are doing something beyond waiting for the day to end.
more with this post tomorrow.
