mini-normal 1892 - GAME END - Bodies, all over the floor

[Lil Uzi Vert]

I'm terrible with setup speculation but I think logically 3 protective PRs just seemed overkill. I tend to look to others who sound like they know what they're talking about in regards to that field.

[Desully]

If BJ is a serial killer his claim would almost certainly get him killed by scum is the other part of my reasoning

I didn't quite follow this. If BJ is a SK, how would claiming BG get him killed? Are you saying scum would be looking to kill the BG? If not, how would scum know a SK made that claim?

If you claim a pr scum will nk you

If the scum subcribe to the desully school of being scum


I worked this whole thing out earlier because tbh counterclaiming the first claim is a genius sk strategy on the face of it but it actually doesnt make sense to do imo

Which is upsetting bc sk is my fav role

[Desully]

LUV KEEP in ming mafia roleblocker is also a protective role

Which makes 4!!! Incredible!!!

[Desully]

Anyway role spec is worthless and we should lynch momo

[Ms Columbo]

Why does scum counterclaim here LQ?

Because its worth it for Scum to get rid of a good player or bcj thinks he can talk his way out of a lynch.

Skill is irrelevant here. Take a look at the game state.

There is zero motivation for scum to trade one of their own for a member of the town.

The scum team would have to so w
idely town read and/or under the radar as well extremely clever to come up with that counterclaim.

@LUV - how do you go from the above, to this:

VOTE: bjc0303

Got a perfect bracket?

No where close...but Rock Chalk Jayhawk!

ok I'm here and I'm drunk, catch me up? I was following up to page 20 but I stopped around there.

luv feels off this game

@JaeReed - I know this comment was early in your read. What is your impression of LUV now?

[Desully]

Incidentally .................. When i say BJ's claim would get him NKed this is in a conceptual universe where LQ was scum. My point is that he CC'd 4 minutes after LQ which means if it was fake it would have been premeditated.... And therefore IF HE WAS a SK he would have to have taken into account that SQ could be scum in which case the scum would have NKed him

That was my point and why I am pretty sure he's telling the truth

[Lil Uzi Vert]

Why does scum counterclaim here LQ?

Because its worth it for Scum to get rid of a good player or bcj thinks he can talk his way out of a lynch.

Skill is irrelevant here. Take a look at the game state.

There is zero motivation for scum to trade one of their own for a member of the town.

The scum team would have to so w
idely town read and/or under the radar as well extremely clever to come up with that counterclaim.

@LUV - how do you go from the above, to this:

VOTE: bjc0303

Got a perfect bracket?

No where close...but Rock Chalk Jayhawk!

ok I'm here and I'm drunk, catch me up? I was following up to page 20 but I stopped around there.

luv feels off this game

@JaeReed - I know this comment was early in your read. What is your impression of LUV now?

Check 1125.

[Desully]

Is Momo's vote on Frank DISGUSTING or what????? VOTE: momo

[FrankJaeger]

The time frank is taking to read is scummy. He is using reading as a way to avoid posting. SERIOUSLY!!!

Bad move here momo.
I dont see town doing that.

[FrankJaeger]

Meant to include vote quote

[FrankJaeger]

Ithink my vote would put momo at L 1 and i dont wanna do that right before i go to sleep

[Desully]

Smart

[Ms Columbo]

Ithink my vote would put momo at L 1 and i dont wanna do that right before i go to sleep

I'm reading through momo's ISO right now. So far, I'm comfortable voting momo as well. Still reading... I don't see a reason to rush this.

[FrankJaeger]

VOTE: bjc
Your behaviour was suspicious throughout but it turned bloodthirsty close to LQ's L-2. He is being ridiculous, but you shading him in the last few posts is not coming across as angry/frustrated but as opportunistic.

I don't think I really have anything to add other than desully is town for me now and BJ is conf town since I don't see scum ever counterclaiming like that...especially for a BG.

I have to take Alban's side in this matter. Even if LQ is scum (which he most probably is) bjc is still a scum read for me.

This is 2 birds with one stone.
Makes me think bj town
Also looks pretty bad on momos end

[Ms Columbo]

In regards to momo:
-Didn't like his D1 vote on bjc

-Didn't like his reason for voting LQ

In that post, I gave him a slight town point for his indecisive voting that followed. I can also see it from horrordude's perspective.

-momo indicates he'll vote for bjc on D2 regardless of LQ's flip

True to his word, he votes bjc out of the gate D2.

-appeals to Fart's dying wish that we lynch bjc

-Exaggerated AtE concerning the suspicion on him

-Vote on Frank seems fabricated (perhaps to divert attention from himself)

Yes, I am comfortable placing a vote here.

[bjc0303]

Momo or lil uzi altho momo is looking pretty obvious now lol

[momo]

I find myself unable to keep up with this game.

@mod replace out

Sorry all. I am just swamped right now. Hope town wins. Peace

[drealmerz7]

ThinkBig replaces momo

[drealmerz7]

REMINDER (read the rules, ppl)

2.

If you have

ANY QUESTIONS

for me during the course of the game, PM them to me. All questions posed to me in the thread will be ignored

.

if you must ask to be replaced please make the request via PM, not in the thread

please try not to go V/LA, but if you must, please notify me via PM, not in the thread

-

[Desully]

I hate it when this happens

[ThinkBig]

Hi all. I'll be on this after school.

[ThinkBig]

Also
UNVOTE:

[Nero Cain]

Its 7 pm CST. School has been out for awhile bro.

[Desully]

New York is EST which makes him twice as guilty imo

[Ms Columbo]

This is a happening place.

Welcome, ThinkBig.