Gay Mafia 3: Trumpocalypse Now D8

[Spiffeh]

Tell me these other reasons.

[Nachomamma8]

We're giving a pool of players that the doc/watcher/other protectives should be on

They are Tammy/Nacho/Desperado/Fedora

Make scum take a risk by targeting/killing any of them

Why would a different protective role protect Fedora?

[Nachomamma8]

Tell me these other reasons.

Why do you have such a strong townread on them?

[Spiffeh]

I was giving a pool of players that I thought were town and I wanted to live through the night

I wanted scum to be scared to risk killing any of those players

Why not?

[Spiffeh]

Because I think I was the nightkill Night 1 and that they saved me

Ali seems town to me

Titus seems town to me now

[Spiffeh]

Tell me these other reasons.

[Nachomamma8]

Why not?

A different protective role would be another possibility for a blocked kill. Assuming Fedora would be town if another protective role existed would be a pretty strange assumption.

[Brian Skies]

We healed Spiffeh. We're a loud doctor.

Layin' hands on Nacho. Curing him of anything because I'm such a muthafukkin BAUS

In my opinion, this game is either Multiball or Fedora is scum. Or both.

[Nachomamma8]

Tell me these other reasons.

If you put effort into your Fedora read, sure.
If all you say is "I think these players are town!", then I don't see why we need a more compelling reason than what we have.

[Spiffeh]

Because I think I was the nightkill Night 1

and that they saved me

[Spiffeh]

Nacho you're literally calling them confirmed scum

I am completely open to reconsidering if you give me a reason to

[Spiffeh]

And yes if it's multiball that reason would probably go out the window

I still think both heads seem town

Again, give me reasons why you don't think so

[Nachomamma8]

Because I think I was the nightkill Night 1

and that they saved me

You were protected Night 1. This doesn't mean you were the nightkill.

[Spiffeh]

And no I wasn't assuming we had another protective role

We might, we might not, I have no idea

I listed the people I wanted protected to scare scum from killing them

I've done similar things to save my town reads in the past, as I think you know?

[Ser Arthur Dayne]

Because I think I was the nightkill Night 1 and that they saved me

I lol'd.

[Spiffeh]

Now stop pretending like I have a chance in hell of being scum and explain why Fedora is ~confirmed scum~

[Nachomamma8]

I'm happy to talk about why I think Fedora is scum when I'm home.
I am not going to jump through hoops detailing my read on them if you won't give me reasons beyond "I think I was the nightkill".

[Brian Skies]

And yes if it's multiball that reason would probably go out the window

I still think both heads seem town

Again, give me reasons why you don't think so

It actually wouldn't change anything for me if it was multiball. It might make me consider them being town, but they've been incredibly scummy up until now that I would lynch them anyway.

Not to mention they've declined to give flavor and explain the mechanics of their role. What has been explained is incredibly sketchy. Their softclaiming is bad and scummy. And Titus going 'I can't be vocal or try to game solve because I'm a doctor' is complete horseshit since they've already been outed.

[Spiffeh]

I'm not asking you to

I said I think they're town and am waiting on you to tell me why you disagree

I am perfectly willing to reevaluate if something presented is compelling, or their play completely deteriorates

This is how mafia works I'm sure you're well aware

[Ser Arthur Dayne]

Btw my point before day 2 ended about the loud modifier can't mean 2 things in 1 game still stands.

[Ser Arthur Dayne]

Also would like to know if desp used any of the two abilites he claimed he still had.

[Spiffeh]

Because I think I was the nightkill Night 1 and that they saved me

I lol'd.

Who do you think scum would have nightkilled instead?

You're the fucking moron who helped push through the Formerfish wagon when I begged it to stop

You were town reading me hard

So why is this suddenly such an outrageous possibility for you now?

[Brian Skies]

Their play has already deteriorated. What are you waiting for? Their role PM to slap you in the face?

Most people want to lynch Fedora. They've explaiend why. All you've said is 'herpaderp I believe I was protected N1', which makes me believe you're either scum or so completely full of yourself that you can't consider the possibility that they're trying to pocket you here (in which case you're opinions on Fedora are no longer credible to me).

[Spiffeh]

I don't know why you feel the need to discredit me at every turn but it's not a good look so please knock it off

[Spiffeh]

^ That was at SAD