Mini 1891: Fat Boy Mafia [Over]

[Firebringer]

This game?
viewtopic.php?f=23&t=67718

[pieg]

Holy crap, Gin asks for a case where town faked a post restriction, and 6 minutes later you have an example from nine years ago? WTF? Looks like you had it waiting in case you needed it.

why would he have a case waiting for conf!scum? if he had a case waiting he would've used it yesterday?

[Persivul]

why would he have a case waiting for conf!scum?

Because he's scum too. Thought the implication was obvious.

if he had a case waiting he would've used it yesterday?

It wasn't needed yesterday. People bought the excuses made for Pine.

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

I think persivul saw pine was being useless partner.
Pressured him, then gave up because no one wanted to lynch him.
That isn't my main reason for scumreading him but I could see that happening.

What's the main reason then?

Read his ISO
The way he talks to people it's just kind of either pointing out obvious stuff, shitting on people, or subtly defending them.

Some areas he does look like he is scum hunting but most it doesn't and his interactions with me day one still left a bad taste in my mouth.

Show me examples of what you're seeing to see if I can relate to your view.

This doesn't go away btw

[pieg]

The obvious conclusion is that Pine was scum who didn't see mod's statement.

no mention of that being an obvious conclusion in your iso. didn't call him scum in 226, asked for opinions in 264, said you're "not crazy about" him in 425, said it's probably fake in 426, complained about no wagon in 432, considers whether he sucks at scum in 449, i don't see anything else. nowhere do you even seem convinced that he is scum, much less have the opinion that pine being scum was an obvious conclusion.

[pieg]

why would he have a case waiting for conf!scum?

Because he's scum too. Thought the implication was obvious.

if he had a case waiting he would've used it yesterday?

It wasn't needed yesterday. People bought the excuses made for Pine.

if he's scum it makes no sense to defend pine's actions as town after he's already flipped scum..?

[Persivul]

if he's scum it makes no sense to defend pine's actions as town after he's already flipped scum..?

People who defended Pine yesterday don't look very good today..?

[Desperado]

who are these people? why do you propose they felt the need to defend him?

[Persivul]

no mention of that being an obvious conclusion in your iso. didn't call him scum in 226,

Post restriction is bullshit. Mod said in the signup thread, "I guarantee no shenanigans etc."

VOTE: Pine

You don't see a vote after "Post restriction is bullshit" as an indicator that I think the conclusion is that the post restriction is scummy?

[Desperado]

you said the post restriction is bullshit

that didn't make pine scum

[pieg]

my dude

it makes no sense to call fire scum bc he seems to have a case waiting for pine

you're assuming that fire is scum and had a case waiting to show people about how pine could be town despite the restriction but didn't use it yesterday bc he was afraid that pine was going to get vigged n1, so he waited to use it after pine had already flipped.

pedit scummy, yes, you established that, but nowhere do you say the obvious conclusion is that he's scum. if you'd made that conclusion day 1 and are town i should that you would've pushed his wagon hard as fuck rather than just weakly pushing it and complaining about it not getting traction

[Desperado]

you're now saying there's no possible town motivation to faking a post restriction, but you're wrong

[pieg]

i am baffled that we are talking about how obvious it was or wasn't that pine was scum

[Desperado]

it's pretty important imo

[Firebringer]

my dude

it makes no sense to call fire scum bc he seems to have a case waiting for pine

you're assuming that fire is scum and had a case waiting to show people about how pine could be town despite the restriction but didn't use it yesterday bc he was afraid that pine was going to get vigged n1, so he waited to use it after pine had already flipped.

pedit scummy, yes, you established t

I am so confused

[pieg]

i don't see why

noting implosion wholly ignoring pine early d1 fwiw

why are you confused fire

[pieg]

i mean if you're saying that we compare ppl's stances to how obvious it was yes

but we're colored by conf!bias knowing that pine is scum

[Persivul]

i am baffled that we are talking about how obvious it was or wasn't that pine was scum

When someone flips red, looking at who pushed them, who defended them, who ignored them...that's pretty standard play.

[Firebringer]

This doesn't go away btw

I'm too lazy to make a case Rn, I kind of rather you leave your vote on me than try to explain why I think pers is scum.

I don't even honestly feel as confident he is Rn given his latest batch of posts
Kind of rather lynch momo.

VOTE: Momo

[Desperado]

i mean if you're saying that we compare ppl's stances to how obvious it was yes

but we're colored by conf!bias knowing that pine is scum

more that pers is overselling his d1 read there

[pieg]

gin does pine have a tendency to call tvts tvs?

pedit yea exactly

[pieg]

i am baffled that we are talking about how obvious it was or wasn't that pine was scum

When someone flips red, looking at who pushed them, who defended them, who ignored them...that's pretty standard play.

not rly what i was saying but dw

[Firebringer]

i mean if you're saying that we compare ppl's stances to how obvious it was yes

but we're colored by conf!bias knowing that pine is scum

more that pers is overselling his d1 read there

And I kind of think him doing that is townie

[Desperado]

I'm too lazy to make a case Rn, I kind of rather you leave your vote on me than try to explain why I think pers is scum.

I don't even honestly feel as confident he is Rn given his latest batch of posts
Kind of rather lynch momo.

you serious

he didn't even go read the game you posted first beyond the start date or he would have realized that none of the people you said were faking post restrictions were even in that game

and somehow jumped straight to "you've been keeping that 9 year old game in your pocket all game for just this scenario!"

and this makes him townier in your eyes??

[Firebringer]

I'm too lazy to make a case Rn, I kind of rather you leave your vote on me than try to explain why I think pers is scum.

I don't even honestly feel as confident he is Rn given his latest batch of posts
Kind of rather lynch momo.

you serious

he didn't even go read the game you posted first beyond the start date or he would have realized that none of the people you said were faking post restrictions were even in that game

and somehow jumped straight to "you've been keeping that 9 year old game in your pocket all game for just this scenario!"

and this makes him townier in your eyes??

I mean he did open it.
So there's that.

I don't see why he would care about post restriction shit as scum?
That's weak.

I don't know, I think he is just being stubborn Town.
Stubborn scum knows what battles to pick.
Stubborn town fights every battle.