DoY I: British Monarchy Mafia (Mini 1896) - Game Over :O

[nancy]

I wasn't trying to dismiss it, that was a guess, I asked you a question with it, you could have simply said "no that'd be stupid" and then given your thoughts, instead we're here, and you're still not explaining the read (believe me, I understand not being able to describe why I have a SR, it's nothing damning), that's all I'm trying to do, is understand

it was perhaps my mistake suggesting an explanation for you instead of just letting you explain, but, that was where my mind went, and so I shared it

This post feels appeasey as fuck.

-- Postie

Elaborate? It doesn't look particularly appease-y to me.

[Empking]

4 pages while I was asleep 0_0

I'm a miller

For reals?

Unvote
Vote: Dreal

- I have not been liking his posts.

[Tea and Biscuits]

Is there a link to the setup? I couldn't find it. =/

[Tea and Biscuits]

Lol it's a closed setup.

[Infinity 324]

I don't think we have bicycles yet, so

*hands postie a paddle* - you can go ahead and backpaddle

Do you think postie is scum? If so, vote?

[Infinity 324]

if anyone TRs anyone before page 10, I'm going to vote them!

Obvious town

[Tea and Biscuits]

I don't think we have bicycles yet, so

*hands postie a paddle* - you can go ahead and backpaddle

Do you think postie is scum? If so, vote?

I know Postie isn't scum.

=)

[Tea and Biscuits]

I tend to frown upon those whom RP.
As it tends to add a barrier too reading them.

[Prism]

Scum are Chara, nancy, and ???, my guess would be Penguin.

VOTE: Chara

Opening vote on Drealm+followup is bad.

VOTE: drealmerz
voted no one instead of picking a player. obvscum. ;>
~Chara

The ;> here is playful but completely negates any pressure they might have been trying to place. I question the intent behind even posting here.

ah, dreal. never change.
VOTE: The Wood Cutters
~Chara

The followup here lacks any sort of clarification as to the intent behind the original vote. The "never change" accompanied by a vote swap implies a town read via meta, but it lacks any kind of teeth. When the original post immediately negates its own pressure, I doubt the usefulness of the 3 posts as adequate to get a grasp on "same old town drealm"

why would i immediately give a reason when seeing what you come up with is more fun?
sharp scummers would figure it had something to do with drealmerz. ;>
~Chara

Skeptical of this claim. As mentioned previously, the interaction here with drealmerz is odd and appears to be settling for very little. Your statement implying that you were trying to fish for reactions or speculation seems to contradict the statement that you left enough for us to extrapolate that it was something about him. Are you testing people's alignments or how perceptive they are? At worst, I think your vote change was scummy in the sense that you

already full well know drealm is town

, at best you're testing something that correlates very little with alignment with no clear reason for doing so.

[Prism]

Scumreads on nancy and Penguin are weaker just from glancing at the opening posts. Rereading nancy it wasn't as bad as I thought but post #100 in particular sticks out to me as a question unlikely to lead anywhere but coming more for the sake of it.

This is irrelevant to the game but as a side note I've been out of action for what feels like too long due to real life circumstances. It's good to be back and devoting my full energy again after having it first diverted then outright stolen by outside circumstances. There are a lot of familiar names here and I'm excited to play with all of you once again. I will hold nothing back.

[Infinity 324]

I wasn't trying to dismiss it, that was a guess, I asked you a question with it, you could have simply said "no that'd be stupid" and then given your thoughts, instead we're here, and you're still not explaining the read (believe me, I understand not being able to describe why I have a SR, it's nothing damning), that's all I'm trying to do, is understand

it was perhaps my mistake suggesting an explanation for you instead of just letting you explain, but, that was where my mind went, and so I shared it

This post feels appeasey as fuck.

-- Postie

I disagree, I think you're confbiasing

[Infinity 324]

@MOD: V/LA until further notice. I am having issues with the hydra.

Is it ok if I post from this account until I get the issues fixed?

Absolutely!
I normally will not count any votes made out-of-hydra, but I can make an exception since it appears there is an ongoing issue with hydrae at the moment.

Please ensure that you quote all posts made by either head from the proper account at your earliest convenience.

What, you're not going to threaten him with force replace?

[Infinity 324]

VOTE: ThinkMomo

Sowing seeds of confusion already.

I don't like this ignore of everything that's happened so far

Wrt dreal: I've seen his SK game and town game and I can't really tell the difference, maybe his scumgame would be different though. Right now it seems like normal dreal.

[Infinity 324]

I'm on board with a VOTE: Drealmerz

What really pinged me was his last post where he goes 'if x is scum... but if x is town...'
I feel like that wishy-washyness is a very easy way for scum to still be free to create an opinion on T&B in order to appease everyone. Like, if people end up scumreading him then drealmerz can sway that way and hop on, but if he's going to be universally townread then he can appease town by agreeing with that read instead. I feel like the phrasing of his statement is rather iffy in itself too.

Why does he have to have a solid read this early?

[Prism]

I'll be honest in saying that I have no idea how to read drealm. I've gotten townreads on him before only to walk them back later but I have yet to see his scumgame. There are no glaringly obvious differences thus far between this game and camn's revenge where we were both town.

[Infinity 324]

4 pages while I was asleep 0_0

I'm a miller

For reals?

Unvote
Vote: Dreal

- I have not been liking his posts.

Yes

This wagon hop is bad

[Infinity 324]

I don't think we have bicycles yet, so

*hands postie a paddle* - you can go ahead and backpaddle

Do you think postie is scum? If so, vote?

I know Postie isn't scum.

=)

I was talking to dreal, silly

[Infinity 324]

@108: Why not question chara about this more? I think you're reading into it too much.

[Infinity 324]

VOTE: empking

"Helpful" question and naked wagon hop are probably the scummiest things of anything so far

[Prism]

@108: Why not question chara about this more? I think you're reading into it too much.

Does my vote and analysis themselves not invite more conversation on the topic? The implication is that I want a followup from Chara, and if it's not adequate then more votes. If I wasn't aiming for more discussion, I wouldn't have explained a thing.

[Infinity 324]

Maybe it's a playstyle thing, but it looks to me like it's written more like a case than an attempt to sort.

[Tea and Biscuits]

Question, I've not played a closed setup before.
Is there any certain setup restrictions or pasterns or whatnot they follow?
Because from what Prism has said there is three scum?
And neutrals are possible?

[Prism]

Maybe it's a playstyle thing, but it looks to me like it's written more like a case than an attempt to sort.

Based off of your reaction to that being more about the fact it's a case itself and less about what it contains, it's almost certainly a playstyle thing.

There are times when it's best to watch from the sides and scavenge when the battle's over, but keep in mind-someone had to kill before you could take the spoils. Simply talking gets you nowhere until it gains teeth.

Question, I've not played a closed setup before.
Is there any certain setup restrictions or pasterns or whatnot they follow?
Because from what Prism has said there is three scum?
And neutrals are possible?

Three mafia is the standard number for minis but this is

not

guaranteed. It is possible for there to be more or less than three mafia, or for third parties or even multiple mafia factions to exist. It is just generally more often the case than not that there are exactly three.

[Infinity 324]

That makes me feel like you are town for some reason. Maybe cause seeing 108 in that context, it's a good preliminary scumread.

[Tea and Biscuits]

So it's basically an assumption of the most probable scenario?
Hmmm. Alright. That's neat.
Someone claimed Miller, is this believable?