In post 359, rb wrote:So how would a town miller be more likely to be true based on Transcend being a scum investigative role?
Going to cap this off because it's very relevant.
At this point someone who thinks Transcend is scum, wouldn't necessarily believe we are in a TOWN investigative rich setup, which is the thing that would make sense. I doubt Boon or TB thought this far but here's the thing:
Miller is anti-town utility, so it makes a lot of sense in a setup with lots of TOWN investigative utility. It has no bearing on scum investigatives at all, so someone who actually believes Transcend is scum wouldn't bother with this line of thinking. If Boon thinks there's going to be a lot of town PR's who are investigative, this would make more sense.
Eagersnake also makes less sense if he thinks Transcend is town - because if Transcend is town (and not watcher) then that IS a pretty heavy investigative setup for town, making miller make sense. Miller can be used as a false flag as well, so it could also...mean not much.
This is the only reasonable conclusion any town player should be making pre any kind of flip at all - which is why I've been wanting to know why people were taking a strong stance on either believing OR disbelieving it (either one is still possible, and we can't give SS either a coasting or to waste D1 lynch on him - imo late day1 and early-mid day2 are the best parts of the game to re-read, and very often when games are grinding to a halt, these areas of the game are super informative and will find you the last scum.
I don't want SS near lylo just in case, and I don't want to lynch him straight away on policy because it cuts out important parts of the game.
Ergo we policy lynch D2. This might change if we find a better scum target but for now, this is better.
Also, if TB is scum or town rn, Boon seems like either a buddy candidate or chainsaw defence.
