HEY IF YOU ALL COULD STOP POSTING FOR 5 SECONDS SO I CAN ACTUALLY GET CAUGHT UP THAT'D BE FUCKING GREAT.
I'll just be going through the thread, providing commentary and giving my thoughts on things I go. This usually resorts to walls of text, but you all just made me read 28 pages soooooo... not fucking sorry.
- SS opens up with a miller claim. Game's getting interesting already, but the claim itself is NAI. Claiming in your first post is how you're supposed to play it.
- I'm not thrilled with
31 by Boon. Something about emphasizing how much WIFOM comes into play seems disingenuous.
- TB's
48 is also problematic for me. Saying that there's no reason not to believe a Miller claim just because it was claimed in the first post (which is what you're supposed to do) is terrible. If a town Miller doesn't claim until after the investigation, it looks fake simply because they should have claimed it in the beginning and avoided the wasted investigation altogether. Looks like scum buddying up to town to me.
In post 48, ThinkBig wrote:23 - Votes ThinkBig instead for believing the claim
UNVOTE: aronagrundy
VOTE: rb
This is also a horrible reason to vote for someone, because rb clearly explained his vote in
26. OMGUS?
In post 55, TwoFace wrote:I'd rather pretend the claim never happened and judge him based how he actually plays. If he looks like scum, I'll lynch him. If he doesn't, I won't.
This is how you're supposed to play a Miller claim from town.
Huh? I've seen enough of Transcend's games to know he usually pulls shit like this. How is something like that AI?
In post 73, Darkshadow64540 wrote:For reference transcend has checked into the thread and posted THREE seperate times now and has posted nothing but unexplained votes, that is suspect as hell to me.
That's Transcend.
Okay, now I take it all back. Get your shit together.
This is crap, and you know it.
Transcend
claims while at L-2 because........ yeah, I've got nothing. You can claim confirmable all you want, but it doesn't mean anything until you're actually confirmed. I've seen games when someone claims confirmable to get out of a D1 lynch and then "zomgIwasblocked" D2.
Eager's
235 sucks because (backup) watcher =/= no miller. Hell, we could be looking at a troll setup... miller with no cops, backups without the primary role, etc. But setup speculation Day 1 kind of sucks, so let's not do it.
In post 299, rb wrote:TB "believed the claim" on page 1. This is before we knew anything about a "power rich environment"
Now in this post on page 12, he says the reason he believes the claim is that it looks like a "power rich environment".
If he was town, how did he know it was a power rich environment - LESS THAN 25 POSTS INTO THE GAME.
Lynch with extreme prejudice
This is a misrep. TB first said that he believed the claim on Page 1 because he didn't have any reason not to, which is terrible reasoning, but he said nothing about a power rich environment. We've had some more information show up about potential setup info, which means it's totally reasonable for someone who was already leaning towards believing the claim to now be more solidified in his read.
In post 324, rb wrote: In post 320, Boonskiies wrote:because I go into every game and try to outguess the mod before the game starts.
do you think Smart is scum trying to coast on a Day 1 miller claim? What would you have preferred he do as a miller?
but how do you know he's miller?
This is just bad. Boon is asking what he would do
as
a miller. He's already stated he believes the claim, but nobody is saying anything about knowing anything at this point.
In post 357, rb wrote:We have a backup watcher, which means there's probably a watcher. Then the other one is probably Transcend
In post 273, Transcend wrote:My role is not watcher, i just said that I'm confirmable. Watcher is NOT confirmable
Try again.
- Transcend in
466 declares himself King after declaring himself confirmable earlier in the day. Wow, I've
never
seen scum try to do those things before!
In post 506, Transcend wrote:actually if twoface doesn't cut his shit i'm just gonna replace out and let someone who can handle his insufferable-ness commandeer my slot
Ironic.
In post 529, hapahauli wrote:RB, EagerSnake, and TB are obv-town.
They're contributing, have their try-hard pants on, and are the driving force behind the game.
Transcend is also probably town
, since he's making a ton of sense so far and is pushing a lot of pro-town objectives.
What. The. Hell?
No. No. No. No. No. Transcend has made 0 sense all game, and leading town doesn't mean obvtown. Come on hap, you're better than this.
In post 538, hapahauli wrote:Who's more likely to be mafia? The two idiots screaming at each other in thread, or the guys in the background letting it happen?
This thread exploded overnight. There have been 18 pages since I replaced in on page 9 less than 24 hours ago. It would make total sense that scum bould be leading town here.
Ummmm.... The last game we were in, you were voting someone on D1 that claimed confirmable.
You have 2 votes on you?
In post 630, hapahauli wrote:Like in what world does a townie go "Player X is confirmed mafia, but let's lynch Player Y instead"?
+1 to this though
COOL I'M FINALLY FUCKING CAUGHT UP. I REALLY LIKE RB/TRANSCEND SCUM LIKE MANY OF Y'ALL (BEST TOWN PERFORMANCE SCUMMY ANYONE?), SO MY MAIN FOCUS AT THE MOMENT IS ON THE 3RD MEMBER. I ONLY REALLY FOCUS ON SCUMREADS, DON'T ASK ME TO OUT MY NULL/TOWNREADS BECAUSE I WON'T BECAUSE IT'S A FUCKING TERRIBLE IDEA.
Eddie - For someone with 57 posts in this game, you've got absolutely nothing to show for it. You FoS'd ThinkBig after
194, and then gave no reason for your suspicions... and current excuse for not voting is because you don't sheep cases. While that is admirable from a town perspective, from a scum perspective it looks like you don't want to actually commit to anything.
Arona - You've got even less content than Eddie, but I'm really hoping you're going to blow me out of the water with your next post considering 16 pages have passed since you were on last.
I Am Innocent - This game's moving at a fast pace, but it would be nice if you joined us for it.
VOTE: Transcend This is L-1.
You don't get to claim confirmable, post some BS reads list, and troll the rest of the game. I've seen scumhunting out of your other games, but I see absolutely none of it here.
The Clown is Town. The Clown also uses "they" pronouns. Don't be a dick about it?
I know it's weird given the username, but "horrorperson" just doesn't have the same ring to it.
