Mini Normal 1897: Chocolate Mafia - Game Over

[Boonskiies]

Eddie, what makes you feel he isn't a Miller? That's a pretty bold move to do. I was a Miller once, and I claimed late day 1, and I got torn to shreds for not claiming in my first post. If he's not a Miller, he's screwed later anyways.

Dumb question, why would transcend even get cc'd? This isn't an open setup...

this. Any investigative role out there would be dumb to counter claim this right now.

[eagerSnake]

Moving boon into my town pile

[Eddie Cane]

boon w all due respect I was just testing to see how all the people calling you town were going to react, particularly tb. since tomorrow is lylo it is in fact good to mass claim though!

[eagerSnake]

OK here's where I'm at rn

Eddie is town
ThinkBig leaning town but IGMEOY
hapa leaning town but IGMEOY
IGMEO rb

update:

aronagrundy leaning town

Update:

Boonskiies town and darkshadow town

[Eddie Cane]

hey boon

popcorn it to someone

and give me a town!dark casw

[Eddie Cane]

if boon is town then Miller is 90% legit too

[eagerSnake]

So town consists of: self, eddie, tb, hapa, arona, boon, da

But then I think the miller may be town so I must be wrong on one of those reads

[Eddie Cane]

that leaves 3 scum in think, dark, hapa, rb, horror, arona, eager

[eagerSnake]

The one Im wrong about is probably in {arona, hapa, tb}

[Eddie Cane]

also boon ooc why exactly are you claiming with 0 voted on you with tons of ate?

[rb]

Like holy fuck. How the hell do you not see that in my ISO?

I remember when I was 5 and thought the world revolved around me too

[Eddie Cane]

wait I realized you said odd nigjt. so you checked dark. mb

[rb]

also boon ooc why exactly are you claiming with 0 voted on you with tons of ate?

noobs gonna noob

[eagerSnake]

I mean his bluntness with "dark is town" early d2 should've been an obvious crumb

[Boonskiies]

@Rb - there's basically been a confirmed 3 investigative roles in this game, and I'm pretty sure there are more. are you even reading the thread?

Look right here, I basically claimed with this post.

[Eddie Cane]

UNVOTE:

I am going to go on a limb here and say I highly doubt scum!boon would town clear scum!dark. so, I'll put dark above boon

[Boonskiies]

So I'm just gonna quote some things...not even going that deep...

Spoiler:

I'm a backup watcher.

wtf is this game.

@eager - I think it's an investigate heavy game.

man, this game is janky.

I love it.

Like I said, I'm positive this is an investigation heavy setup. At this point, I'm pretty sure there are investigation roles on both sides. I was in a game that had scum and town gunsmiths alongside backup gunsmiths for both sides.

I mean it's definitely investigate heavy; scum probably has some kind of thing.

I've seen mafia watchers before, Eager.

Town

investigate role
back up watcher
miller
possibly one or two other pr depending on mafia power
---------------------

Scum

investigative role (gonna assume watcher)
some role to cause WIFOM within all that jazz.
goon or other pr depending on how many PR town has.



Yeah, this is a good base for me to think about...

VOTE: Transcend

I'm back here. If he claims Watcher I'm pretty confident in it being scum aligned.

holy crap, the setups.

Ah....as a mod myself who's main route is to push the limits of normal games, I salute you, BV.

I'm pretty sure he's actually a miller.

[Eddie Cane]

that leaves 3 scum in think, dark, hapa, rb, horror, arona, eager

think hapa horror arona eager rb*

eager claimed backup watcher. rest are unclaimed.


again, boon, popcorn the claim to someone. literally no downside to mass claiming now.

[eagerSnake]

The neighborizer is probably the "scum role to cause WIFOM in all this" you think?

[Boonskiies]

Miller is anti-town utility, which is completely unrelated to Watcher (it gives nothing to a Watcher) - so if we know there's a Watcher, and then you think Transcend is scum utility - there's still no investigative role that hints at being relevant to there being a Miller. Essentially you're trusting that such a thing would exist, or perhaps that the existence of a Miller is a 'fuck you' to the players to go looking for a cop and make them setup spec a lot. But the information and reasoning you're giving about why you believe the claim, isn't saying any of those things. Why?

FoS: rb

blatant role phishing. We were speculating. You are phishing.

Now, I had confbias from that post, which i was in tunnel mode for. I don't necessarily see it as phishing now, and I'm not entirely sure who i think is scum at this point. I have a few strong town reads, but I don't think I'm going to say that just yet.

[Boonskiies]

The neighborizer is probably the "scum role to cause WIFOM in all this" you think?

See, I would think this, but the things posted in it before I got in there makes me thing otherwise. I should have been dead had that been the case.

[Boonskiies]

Alright. Eddie, claim. then deal with the popcorn, haha.

[eagerSnake]

Makes sense

[Boonskiies]

Ugh...can anyone else see a potential rb/eager/darkshadow scum team...? Man...I'm thinking way too much right now.

Shows that I was weary of darkshadow here too. Plus, he was the most null to me AND on the transcend wagon, if anyone questions why i chose dark.

[Boonskiies]

I need to stop doing associative tells right now. Transcend is scum. Not going to over analyze. If eager is town and actually backup watcher, whatever watcher is out there is mafia aligned.

Meh. I don't really agree with that the watcher is mafia aligned. Can you explain?

i think it should be fairly obvious why I think that. More on it later.