Mini Normal 1897: Chocolate Mafia - Game Over

[ThinkBig]

Mine

[BlackVoid]

Vote Count 2.07

Darkshadow64540 (1):

hapahauli (1009)

aronagrundy (1):

rb (1093)

rb (1):

ThinkBig (1171)

Not Voting (7):

Boonskiies, Darkshadow64540, Something_Smart, horrordude0215, aronagrundy, eagerSnake (1010), Eddie Cane (1215)

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

D2 deadline is Monday, April 14th 2017, 7:00PM PST or in (expired on 2017-04-14 19:00:00).

[/area][/size]

[Eddie Cane]

i meant wtf is this dumbass popcorn game

popcorn is smarter than u will ever be

[Darkshadow64540]

I don't have the time for a detailed post right now but I am town but I refuse to claim exactly what, thank you boon for the confirmation.

[Darkshadow64540]

On a side note every single game I played so far has had me seen as scum, what the fuck am I doing to cause this?

[eagerSnake]

I can answer that

[eagerSnake]

You are a seemingly easy target for scum due to the 'goon' title (meaning lesser experienced) and also lack of content in posts makes you seem like a weaker target. Also townies will want to pressure you because of the goon title to see how you react and get reads based off that

Basically just seen as juicy lynch bait to scum

[eagerSnake]

So yeah, if a townie decides to put some pressure on you I would expect scum to start drooling over that and want to tip the momentum in that direction

Or they may just do it on their own volition because seemingly easy target etc etc

[ThinkBig]

You are a seemingly easy target for scum due to the 'goon' title (meaning lesser experienced) and also lack of content in posts makes you seem like a weaker target. Also townies will want to pressure you because of the goon title to see how you react and get reads based off that

Basically just seen as juicy lynch bait to scum

The part about the goon title makes no fucking sense. I don't even pay attention to titles as they are totally meaningless.

[eagerSnake]

Sometimes, it does have an influence.

[ThinkBig]

In like newbie games where they don't know what the title means...

[eagerSnake]

I look at titles, personally. Quick way to judge site experience without going into profiles and looking at post counts

[Eddie Cane]

I don't have the time for a detailed post right now but I am town but I refuse to claim exactly what, thank you boon for the confirmation.

you will claim exactly what because there's already a vig and a cop to nk and adding some other role isn't going to hurt.

[Eddie Cane]

you can claim after the rest though since you are prob town

[ThinkBig]

you will claim exactly what because there's already a vig and a cop to nk and adding some other role isn't going to hurt.

Unless he is a protective role of some kind?

[ThinkBig]

I look at titles, personally. Quick way to judge site experience without going into profiles and looking at post counts

Doesn't really tell us that. If a person is active in GD but not in mafia, it may inflate their post count. Similarly, if someone is a secret alt, it wouldn't tell us anything about the experience of that user.

[eagerSnake]

Yeah it's a first, superficial point of info

But people take superficial points and turn them into mountains all day on here so yeah

[ThinkBig]

Boonskiies

Darkshadow64540

Eddie Cane

hapahauli

Something_Smart

eagerSnake

horrordude0215
rb
aronagrundy

By PoE, the team has to be {horrordude, rb, arnonagrundy}. I may be wrong about {Something_smart, hapahauli}, but I am fairly confident that the ones I have stiked out are town.

[eagerSnake]

Yeah that's where I'm at

[ThinkBig]

VOTE: aronagrundy

ch00-ch00

Is it just me, or does this vote feel like an attempt to bus?

[ThinkBig]

@MOD: Can you please prod aronagrundy?

[BlackVoid]

aronagrundy is V/LA through Sunday.

[ThinkBig]

aronagrundy is V/LA through Sunday.

Didn't see that. Though it is now Sunday night, hopefully he will post soon.

[Eddie Cane]

you will claim exactly what because there's already a vig and a cop to nk and adding some other role isn't going to hurt.

Unless he is a protective role of some kind?

then he should claim vt

[Something_Smart]

as opposed to that very not-real post

Yes, smartass. I hadn't read the last 10 pages when I posted that. Now I have. Hence, real post.

So the claims right now are:
ThinkBig - VT
Eddie Cane - 1-shot vig
Boonskiies - odd-night cop (also claimed the existence of a neighborizer)
Darkshadow64540 - ???
hapahauli - ???
Something_Smart - miller
eagerSnake - backup watcher
horrordude0215 - ???
rb - VT
aronagrundy - ???

agree that this should be finished as soon as possible. however, disagree that protectives should claim vt. It's massclaim, and if we're intending to do setup spec (which we really need to be given the claims thus far), we need to know all the claims to get an idea of the full setup. otherwise what we'll end up doing is terrible setup spec and that never works out well for town, period.

anyway, I'm surprisingly starting to lean more town on rb. (this is surprising myself because I figured after day 1 that he'd be the type of person I'd scumread regardless of alignment.)
and TB is still town, and not touching Eddie and Boon, and Dark is town by Boon's report. (not even going to think about the scenario where scum-boon inno's his buddy.) So my lynchpool is something like:
<hapahauli, aronagrundy, eagerSnake, horrordude0215> in preference order.

because I'm amazed hapa hasn't gotten more attention than he has, given that he has now made two pushes on players proven to be town (not counting transcend which doesn't exactly help his case but I won't hold it against him). I already explained why I didn't like the Eddie push, and I would hate his Darkshadow push even if Darkshadow weren't conftown.
He attacked Darkshadow for having the worst D1 vote (a vote which was basically RVS that he just happened to keep), also considering that hapa himself voted Transcend to L-1 after Transcend claimed friendly neighbor.
And then this post:

I wanna lynch arona tbh

Eh. I understand why she looks bad, but I think Darkshadow looks worse. Aarona doesn't look like she's trying to blend in, and there's some stuff that reads genuine in her filter. I also really don't like Darkshadow's push on that slot.

is weak and forced and IMO points to a hapa/arona team.

not gonna vote until claims are done, but this is where I would be voting. there's more to it than what I posted, but it's just gut I hate some of his posts too, and hard to explain.

also, pretty much all of the meta that was used in the last 10 pages (if not all the meta used all game) has been trash.

also also, this post made me laugh:

A man came to my door knocking.. he wanted me to share my wisdom

I didn't feel like sharing yet and told him so

But yet, he continued to knock on my door. And went around the town spreading rumors of me because I would not share my wisdom. Every few hours he would come back and knock on my door.

So of course, I got tired of the knocking and the rumors and answered the door

even though it didn't really explain what eager was doing that much, and it certainly didn't explain how it had town motivation.

also also also,

@BlackVoid I thought your dark chocolate troll was really clever, and I'm sorry everyone just ignored it if I had been around, I would have commented on it