[Game Over] Newbie 1784 - Escape Room

[nancy]

Atm I don't have much respect for my Srceenplay TR and I'm basically giving him the benefit of the doubt on every count in order to see the Town in him. I may be looking too hard for town!Src there, I don't know.
I have a decent amount of respect for my Tes TR.
I feel wishy-washy about my WM townlean and I think I may /want/ him too much to not be scum derp-clearing for my read there to be something to go by.
I feel hesitant about my scumlean on Noodle but he's literally given me nothing to reconsider the read so I don't feel comfortable putting him anywhere else. The active lurking is gross.
I have a good amount of respect for my SR on Chronicle.
I also want to respect your TR on Loopdan so I'm willing to not actively pursue my Loopdan SR in the short term. I'm far from convinced on that count, though.
No clue whether Drixx flips scum here or not. It feels like scum on a gut level but I feel like most of the points against it are circumstantial.

[nancy]

Anyway, really glad you replaced in when you did Void. Gave me some sanity for Day 1. Going to miss you tomorrow.

[nancy]

54 pages is a really good Day 1 fwiw.

[nancy]

Like, I know some people might say that's too long, but considering the circumstances I'm pretty fucking satisfied with what we've gotten out of everyone today.

[nancy]

Well, excepting Loopdan, naturally.

[Drixx]

Really? You agreed earlier that there was evidence by induction that I'm not scum and you hammer me? How does that make ANY sense?

There was something bugging me about Drixx. I finally found what I was looking for. A recently completed game I spectated. Here is a Drixx post:

So what you're saying is that only your pride matters. You realize that we've been mislynched ONCE EVER, and that's featured in our signature.

Individually, we also both pride ourselves on not being mislynched.

The slot was scum so he may have been lying but I don't know why scum would lie about something like this. Assuming that's the truth, Drixx's play here doesn't come across like the play of someone who's almost mislynched and (seemingly) takes pride in that.

I don't know anyone who counts newbie games on their stats. Given that I am always experimenting with my game in newbie games, I draw suspicion fairly frequently, and if I can't shake it and I'm worried scum could use me for the clinching mislynch, I will often advocate that I be lynched before M/LYLO.

When it comes to my hydra with Cerberus ... I believe he has NEVER been mislynched playing by himself, and I think we have been only once in hydra, which is where the quote in the hydra's signature comes from.

If that's true he's exactly like me. I've never been mislynched outside of newbies, largely because I devour wagons on me whole.

This. Except I've not gotten good enough to just make myself blatantly obvious town. I think the whole fact that the day would have ended days ago with a self hammer since I have been the designated lynch since before I replaced in should have been a pretty good argument in my favor.

In any case, my thoughts:

Noodle is scum. Just ... no ifs ands or buts. Certain things only come from a scum mindset and setting someone up to be lynched if a certain condition is met, and that condition can easily be met by the scum team making a choice ... that just doesn't come from town.

Presuming scum!Noodle, I think Loopdan makes the most sense to be his partner.

I don't like some of the posts by Srceenplay but I can't say whether it's scummy or just I don't like the posts, lol.

[nancy]

Really? You agreed earlier that there was evidence by induction that I'm not scum and you hammer me? How does that make ANY sense?

No other lynch was happening. Hammering you when I did was pro-town because it gives you the chance to come in and tell us your alignment. Also, there was the possibility that scum!you didn't self-hammer due to Loopdan's L-1 being somewhat sketchy.

[nancy]

Anyway, sorry Drixx.

[nancy]

Fwiw I think this a Town win.

[nancy]

Associatives from Pine were really significant. Hopefully Void gets in here soon to see this.

If you could elaborate on scum!Loopdan that would be really helpful because I'm climbing a mountain getting anyone to see him being scum here.

You don't think Chronicle has any chance of being scum, Drixx?

[Drixx]

I think noodle would have gone. In fact ... the amount of resistance to that and ease of a wagon on me is kind of an indication all by itself.

It is what it is though.

A chance? Sure. Likely? I didn't see anything that made me question mindset.

[nancy]

Meh, I really wanted the perfect win. Oh well. People were so lasered in on you. I tried at least.

[nancy]

I think noodle would have gone. In fact ... the amount of resistance to that and ease of a wagon on me is kind of an indication all by itself.

I know, and I argued that.

[BlackVoid]

Sorry Drixx. I'm getting dinner right now but I'll look over the game in a bit. Agree that StealthyNoodle is most likely scum.

[nancy]

Meh Void I wish you were going to be here tomorrow gdit. Hope and pray for the 0.000000001% chance that scum decide to shoot in VTs for some bizarre reason.. or just forget to put in the NK

[nancy]

I could see Noodle/WM. Or Noodle/Chronicle. I don't know how to reconcile the tonal shift from Chronicle and I feel like combined with being vindicated by the tonal shift from Noodle (presuming that's scum) that's not a read I want to give up.

[nancy]

On the other hand I think Loopdan snidely parroting Src's comment wrt conf!towns on the Drixx wagon comes from scum!Loopdan far more than town!Loopdan.

[nancy]

Still disliking Src's insistence on following the Tracker.

[nancy]

Wish people would just play more pro-town.

[nancy]

I personally think scum team includes Noodle. Not only for all the reasons you guys listed, but also for his interactions with me. He repeatedly hard defends me from every push against me. Not saying I don't appreciate it, but it's fishy. If he's scum, he would know I am town. However, the way things were going sometimes, I could be perceived as someone who might get lynched. That way, once I'm lynched, it seems like he's town because he repeatedly attempted to defend me. Adding on to that, if he gets lynched as scum, it'll create associations that Noodle seemed to defend me from a lynch. Therefore, I have a higher possibility of being his scum buddy. Hope his makes sense
Sorry if you're town Noodle :/
VOTE: StealthyNoodle

I think noodle is smarter than he is trying to show. By appearing as new, he could garner sympathy and use his new player status as excuse for poor plays (then again, inshouldnt be talking as I use the same excuse)

Unsure = Stealthy

Talk to me about why this read changed, WM?

This was never answered ftr.

[StealthyNoodle]

Morn

quote="In post 1302, nancy"]Why the fuck did you just hammer.

Mini is asleep right now thank goodness.[/quote]
This act is terrible. I want to lynch nancy so bad.

Also starting to suspect Drixx nancy as scumteam. You've soley been acting as his lawyer, making sure it looks like you didn't want him out for forced reasons.

[StealthyNoodle]

Morn

Why the fuck did you just hammer.

Mini is asleep right now thank goodness.

This act is terrible. I want to lynch nancy so bad.

Also starting to suspect Drixx nancy as scumteam. You've soley been acting as his lawyer, making sure it looks like you didn't want him out for forced reasons.

*Edit

[nancy]

Smh.

[nancy]

Like, why do I always assume that people scumreading me and tunneling on me for garbage reasons are just really bad Towns.

[nancy]

OK so since Noodle is now conf!scum with that flaccid attempt to pretend he doesn't know Drixx is flipping Town, the partner is MOST likely in {Chronicle, Loopdan, WM}. Outside shot of Src.