[Game Over] Newbie 1784 - Escape Room

[Srceenplay]

Reads list
Tes - Not certain, apart from suggesting Bp strat, he hasn't done much. Could be a gamble as he looks Town by suggesting it, but it's becoming fairly common (from what I can tell by what others said), so if he was scum, he might as well look as best as possible.
Chronicle - Neutral. Similar to Tes he defended the bp strat quite vigorously as well as the inactive. He hasn't really done anything that screams "TOWN", but seems to be trying to help find scum (pressuring others into participating with the strat that usually finds scum).
Loop - Town, didn't work against the strat and also helped pressure others. This is more of a vibe I guess
Nancy - Scum lean. Starts out with going out for an aggressive counter to the strat. Proceeds to say it won't help new players learn. However most of the new players seem to not mind using this strategy. If there's a cop, look into her please.

Pine - Not enough posts to judge with, but made a valid point

Screenplay - Neutral, slightly miffed he's pushing me, but it's my fault for missing loopdens post. I want his reads before saying anything conclusive. Idk how it's considered lurking, we all have outside lives. If I wanted to lurk, I wouldn't have replied "a few hours" in the first place. Seems to be aggressive against the new player, some of it deserved, but I don't trust him fully. Maybe I'm just biased.
Stealthy - Scum lean - I'm having trouble with quotes, so I'll refer to post numbers
79/89 - Says that he agrees with Nancy that the strat isn't good for new players, but proceeds to say by not supporting it, she has a higher possibility of scum. It seems to me that she's braver than you and posted her opinion while you just want to look good to town. You're a hypocrite. Stating that you agree with what she said, but those words make her a scum read to you makes no sense. Even tho she didn't cooperate, you should've stuck to what you believed in lol. While I don't necessarily consider her as pro town, you make her seem so much better. You could be bussing her idk.
94 - Again, you agree with her ... what makes you vs her different? That she took a more direct stance? If the majority of the players said that this strat was bad and she was the only who argued it was good, I think you wouldn't have gone along with this strategy xd

I hope what I just said made sense, it probably didn't knowing me. Anyways, go analyze this now

Pine hasn't said anything but I like what he said.

@nancy


Why are you so sure pine is town? He made only a few posts and they were simply to defend you. I'm just interested in hearing your reasoning

Throws shade at nancy for town reading pine.

I personally think pine is worth looking into -
He begins by heavily defending Nancy and proceeds to leave

In addition, I would have to say Nancy has a higher chance of scum than stealthy atm. She repeatedly appeals to my emotions, making me want to trust her. My other reasoning in on my reads list from page 8. I don't feel like repeating all of it. Just go check. That being said, I do appreciate what you said Nancy xd.

Says pine is worth looking into.

Why are you so sure pine is town? He made only a few posts and they were simply to defend you. I'm just interested in hearing your reasoning

Pine and I are friends, and I like to think I can get a pretty good read on him early on. Combination of gut and recognizing patterns.

But he only made nine posts. What patterns did you see in his posts that made you TR him?

He made four game related posts. I also fail to see how one could tell if it's a town read after so little info, even if prior friends

Again.

Not tracker

I'm kind of confused why there is a push for the lynch of pine. While it's bad to lose an active town, chances are they are vanilla townie and we can base future Lynchs off the reactions/comments of others. A pine lynch without him defending himself could cause us to lose an important town role. Not only that, we gain far less info from a pine lynch

Defensive towards pine.

[Srceenplay]

VOTE: Drixx
One down

Your vote was already on Drixx ... why were you trying to hammer?

For future reference, you should not interfere when someone is running a gambit. When someone who is already voting a wagon pretends to hammer, it is usually to check for a reaction. You pointing it out immediately took away any chance of Srceenplay getting a reaction from me in a situation where I may have believed I was lynched.

Drixx only reference to WhyMafia is a coach!?

[Alisae]

Yeah, I'm fine with getting tracked or whatever.
VOTE: Srceen
And of course you would be fine with the counterwagon since you know your lifespan isn't long.

[Alisae]

Like fuck, your WhyMafia Vote just screams "I am trying to survive"

[StealthyNoodle]

@WhyMafia, I think my townreads on you are pretty fine, but you've been doing a lot of shady stuff as well.

What's notable here is when he was accused of defending Pine, he jumps to say that he was defended another slot as well.

I like this observation as well. Here's some further investigation.

Deerstalker On

Actually, I did take note of post 176 (which is his only defense of Cog, as mentioned in 463). And something was off about it: I remember being a bit annoyed because he pretty much spewed out the same non-sense as Chronicle:

Your vote is

wasted on a slot

that hasn't even

logged in since the game started

, and you voting him will not pop him an email telling him to check in on this game and post his thoughts.

And when he does finally catch up, he will post his thoughts accordingly. Your one vote doesn't do anything. It will not spur any sort of reaction, it does not give him any sort of incentive to pay more attention to this game, because he is not ignoring this game. Because he hasn't even logged in yet.

Your vote does not do anything. His inactivity thus far is not alignment indicative.

It doesn't seem like you're reading my posts at all. So let me rephrase:
If bjc0303 is lurking, he sees this. If there's more pressure and he's still lurking, there'll probably be a response as well. To explain further:

He doesn't have to be online to lurk.

I don't get why you keep pushing such an invalid argument.

Why are we debating his alignment when he's not even lurking - he hasn't

logged on since the game started

. This is

wasting time to find scum

, unless we're using this to gauge reactions.

But idk I'm bad at mafia

And that goes for you as well.

I've included WhyMafia's whole post 176 in this quote. Had to alter it in order to get my point across.

This was his

only defense

of bjc(the one Cog replaced), and it's pretty much Chron's words, rearranged.

Care to explain why your post is so similar to Chronicle's?

[StealthyNoodle]

@WhyMafia, I think my townreads on you are pretty fine, but you've been doing a lot of shady stuff as well.

What's notable here is when he was accused of defending Pine, he jumps to say that he was defended another slot as well.

I like this observation as well. Here's some further investigation.

Deerstalker On

Actually, I did take note of post 176 (which is his only defense of Cog, as mentioned in 463). And something was off about it: I remember being a bit annoyed because he pretty much spewed out the same non-sense as Chronicle:

Your vote is

wasted on a slot

that hasn't even

logged in since the game started

, and you voting him will not pop him an email telling him to check in on this game and post his thoughts.

And when he does finally catch up, he will post his thoughts accordingly. Your one vote doesn't do anything. It will not spur any sort of reaction, it does not give him any sort of incentive to pay more attention to this game, because he is not ignoring this game. Because he hasn't even logged in yet.

Your vote does not do anything. His inactivity thus far is not

alignment

indicative.

It doesn't seem like you're reading my posts at all. So let me rephrase:
If bjc0303 is lurking, he sees this. If there's more pressure and he's still lurking, there'll probably be a response as well. To explain further:

He doesn't have to be online to lurk.

I don't get why you keep pushing such an invalid argument.

Why are we debating his

alignment

when he's not even lurking - he hasn't

logged on since the game started

. This is

wasting time to find scum

, unless we're using this to gauge reactions.

But idk I'm bad at mafia

And that goes for you as well.

I've included WhyMafia's whole post 176 in this quote. Had to alter it in order to get my point across.

This was his

only defense

of bjc(the one Cog replaced), and it's pretty much Chron's words, rearranged.

Care to explain why your post is so similar to Chronicle's?

*Edit

[Srceenplay]

I would rather be lynched and have you cleared as town. It would be better for us if you are cleared.
My lynch right now is not good.
Vote WhyMafia.

If there is a nokill again no lynch until tracker gets a result.

[Srceenplay]

Like fuck, your WhyMafia Vote just screams "I am trying to survive"

Does my laziness scream try to survive?

[Alisae]

Srceen it's your WhyMafia vote.
Like, do you think your lazziness is supposed to make you town?

[Srceenplay]

Nope

[Srceenplay]

I also don't think I've done anything scumy

[Alisae]

OH COME ON
2135 IS CAUGHT SCUM FOR THE WRONG REASONS.
FUCKING CRIST.

[StealthyNoodle]

^@Srceen I mostly agree

[StealthyNoodle]

Srceenplay were you scum?

Nope

Did you know that there was no hammer, when you responded to this?

[Srceenplay]

No. I was just catching up.
It doesn't matter. It's nothing that can't be easily lied about.

[WhyMafia]

Dude!
I looked at Srceen's ISO, I saw scum, and I am currently pushing that.
Plus I have like,
the worst reading comprehension on MS.

That's me

[Srceenplay]

Of course

[WhyMafia]

Ok caught up completely. I'm completely disturbed by Srceen. He has literally sheeped town leaders

THE WHOLE GAME

????
VOTE: SrceenPlay
Nancy changed her vote, and Alisae voted him, so that makes it L-1

I'm fine with a lynch on me if it means we win. Go ahead.

[Srceenplay]

A hammer on me still isn't game so....
Try again.

[Srceenplay]

I would rather be lynched and have you cleared as town. It would be better for us if you are cleared.
My lynch right now is not good.
Vote WhyMafia.

If there is a nokill again no lynch until tracker gets a result.

[BlackVoid]

That was a lot to catch up on. I want to look into StealthyNoodle more before putting down a vote. I'm not convinced srceenplay is scum so would prefer not to hammer. Haven't decided where I want my vote actually. In case we're wrong, my track choice will be a surprise so probably best not to assume anything just yet.

[nancy]

Srceenplay the world in which you flip Town is so distant I'd need a Hubble to see it.

Waiting for BlackVoid and TesXX to post.

Void, confirm you will track Aslan please.

If scum other than Srceenplay refuses to claim scum then we go about this long and stupid way.

[nancy]

BlackVoid this is autowin can you just stop.

[nancy]

Like fuck if scum is so fucking intent on slowrolling this shit then let's just all unvote and wait until deadline if that's what they fucking want so much.

[nancy]

THE GAME IS FUCKING OVER

YOU ARE WASTING EVERYONE'S TIME