Okay.
Why would you EVER say this outloud? I'm not going to give you an answer, but what makes you think it is perfectly acceptable to ask this outloud. If a BP exist, a doc shouldn't be possible.
Post
Post #1765 (isolation #201) » Sun Apr 16, 2017 1:15 pm
Postby StealthyNoodle »
In post 1752, WhyMafia wrote:
Remind me -
Why are you so convinced that nancy is scum?
I'm pretty certain she's isn't. But all my earlier reads on her says differently. I don't see any reason to explain; if Alisae doesn't claim, nancy is town for sure.
Post
Post #1771 (isolation #203) » Sun Apr 16, 2017 1:23 pm
Postby StealthyNoodle »
In post 1764, nancy wrote:How in the fuck could you prefer a useless lurksack to Aslan, exactly?
Loopdan might've been a lurk, but he'd likely respond to my question in a regular way (and likely understand why I ask while we're at it) instead of going full nutsack armageddon in response.
He was about the only one suspicious of nancy, even after her BP claim. He also mentioned that he wouldn't claim doc even if it was to counterclaim.
By claiming BP nancy easily baited out a doc counterclaim. Most of us agreed that doc should cc if he was existent. If someone HAD claimed doc, scum would have both tracker and doc in their palm. It's a risk not worth taking in a newbie-game and it reads as scum.
Her doing a nokill now, was about the only move that could clear her of suspicion. Taking out anyone but the tracker would instantly reveal her as scum.
Post
Post #1815 (isolation #209) » Sun Apr 16, 2017 2:06 pm
Postby StealthyNoodle »
In post 1807, BlackVoid wrote:This is really frustrating. @nancy, after everything you said about wanting to teach newbies to play properly, fake-claiming a PR as a VT when you were widely suspected isn't something I can agree with.
Thank you. Feels like you're the only one who read my post.
In post 1807, BlackVoid wrote:If Alisae is fake-claiming doc as VT here, that's pretty suboptimal as well. You are not executing a brilliant plan to wifom scum. You are only adding noise and distractions to the game and making it more difficult to scumhunt. I just can't get behind someone replacing into a newbie game and fake-claiming their role which was why I said I missed Loopdan.
If Alisae was fake-claiming, she just gave away her chance of scum-victory. I also doubt it, considering Loopdan's doc softclaim.
Post
Post #1839 (isolation #214) » Sun Apr 16, 2017 2:38 pm
Postby StealthyNoodle »
^I agree with what BlackVoid said. Alisae, it doesn't feel like you read the thread at all.
You assume your strat is pushing town towards a win, while all it really does is add a lot of confusion to an already messy newbie-game.
I'll take your latest VT-claim as the real one, and assume nancy is what she says she is. UNVOTE: nancy
Post
Post #1860 (isolation #216) » Sun Apr 16, 2017 3:04 pm
Postby StealthyNoodle »
^@nancy There has been no real counterclaim, so I'm not tunneling you anymore. I spent hours trying to wrap my newbie-brain around that messy fake-claim, and if it's autowin, I don't really care anymore.
I'll pretty much go with whatever nancy and BV agrees upon.
Also, my townreads on WhyMafia are stronger than those on Srceenplay.
Post
Post #1869 (isolation #217) » Sun Apr 16, 2017 3:16 pm
Postby StealthyNoodle »
^@nancy I already suspected Loopdan to be doc. If he had counterclaimed, I'd see no reason not to lynch you;
You're too experienced to play a gambit that gives away both doc and tracker in a newbie-game, and you probably wouldn't take the risk of being counterclaimed as town.
In post 1385, StealthyNoodle wrote:footnote: I did enjoy that postmortem(pun not intended), last-gasp attempt to make the bus look real. Concidering it came arond after hammer went down, it pretty much cleared me more than it hurt me.
Oh sorry I didn't read this before. The point of calling you conf!scum btw was that if you /were/ scum then you'd be more likely to put in the kill for a tracker guilty today. Kind of a nancy play, don't try to make sense of it too much.
Oh my fault, I was referring to Drixx. I see now that I should've mentioned that.
In post 1871, Chronicle wrote:I just wanted to try to get him to play the game in a better way. The push was completely valid and he needed to see that the way he was playing needed to improve.
In post 676, nancy wrote:How have I always been the more suspicious one? What do you mean when you say I try to repel a lot of decent scumreads? What unstable reads are you referring to? I wasn't really defending anything, I was just correcting src's misconception.
You're simply
repeating my post, only with questionmarks
. Like you did back when we first started arguing. (Post 100). It's a
great method to make people less interested
to get involved.
@nancy Well in retrospect, for me this still holds true. A polyad of question is not dialogue in my eyes, and it killed every wish I had to engage with you any further.
In post 1871, Chronicle wrote:I just wanted to try to get him to play the game in a better way. The push was completely valid and he needed to see that the way he was playing needed to improve.
In post 676, nancy wrote:How have I always been the more suspicious one? What do you mean when you say I try to repel a lot of decent scumreads? What unstable reads are you referring to? I wasn't really defending anything, I was just correcting src's misconception.
You're simply
repeating my post, only with questionmarks
. Like you did back when we first started arguing. (Post 100). It's a
great method to make people less interested
to get involved.
@nancy Well in retrospect, for me this still holds true. A polyad of questions is not dialogue in my eyes, and it killed every wish I had to engage with you any further.
In post 1943, Alisae wrote:And Pine has a reputation for not bussing. So Noodle is probably town.
Even in his grave, Pine gets away with all the credit. So annoyed rn.
You and Drixx were pretty the only ones scumreading me(you claim to believe I was 98% town yourself).
Thus, I feel confident I've done my best to prove myself as town.
After Drixx's lynch, you keep giving me town credibility because of Pine's anti-bus views.
I'm "annoyed" that you use
Post
Post #2013 (isolation #235) » Sun Apr 16, 2017 5:58 pm
Postby StealthyNoodle »
In post 2009, nancy wrote:that is a kinda standard way to give your scumbud towncred, like, why would he be pushing a bus if he's on the chopping block
Again, with this nonsense reverse psychology. It's not gonna get you anywhere.
Post
Post #2175 (isolation #247) » Mon Apr 17, 2017 12:16 pm
Postby StealthyNoodle »
In post 2171, nancy wrote:Caring about getting perfect wins will just paralyze your play because you'll be so focused on results that you'll neglect the process
Post
Post #2188 (isolation #252) » Mon Apr 17, 2017 12:40 pm
Postby StealthyNoodle »
Achieving a perfect town-win, isn't really obtainable in any other game than a newbie one.
It's a great incentive for digging into all the small details.
Assuming autowin is risky and lazy. You can already see that there are several player's who don't believe win is secured.
Post
Post #2194 (isolation #253) » Mon Apr 17, 2017 12:56 pm
Postby StealthyNoodle »
^What @Blackvoid said. It's an obtainable achievement. And as opposed to certain sports, we don't make a sacrifice by trying to achieve a great result.
pedit: You believe we'll be too burned out to work towards a regular win, if we don't achieve a perfect one? Your arguments just keep getting weaker tbh.
In post 2196, StealthyNoodle wrote:I don't trust Chronicle. Several players don't acknowledge me as town. You gotta take other's views into consideration.
Why don't you trust Chronicle?
He reads more town than scum. I just don't see why he's locktown(if that's even the right term).