[Game Over] Newbie 1784 - Escape Room

[nancy]

If you read into Loopdan's posts for most of the game, it's pretty apparent he was barely reading thread beyond the first few pages or so. I don't think it's entirely likely he'd have put much thought into my claim or a NK.

[BlackVoid]

WhyMafia doesn't have any completed games on site. I asked him for links to his homesite but he hasn't been online since. Agree with his interactions being a bit too blatant. Not really sure what to make of it.

I did see you fake-claim VT. Loopdan's 922 seems to suggest that he believed your 1-shot BP claim though. He wouldn't have called it sub-optimal if he thought you were the doc because that would be optimal.

Also, something I forgot to mention earlier in my read of TesXX: here's his ISO in a recent scumgame. Part of the reason I was townreading him is the difference in tone. Here, even when he was talking about the setup, he came across as aggressive and confident. In his scumgame, he seemed really limp and hesitant. That's one reason I started townreading him and kept it up throughout. Wanted to make a note of it. Curious if you agree with my assessment.

So, current reads are something like this: StealthyNoodle -> TesXX -> Srceenplay -> Aristophanes -> WhyMafia -> Alisae.

Need to hear most from Aristo, and I need Src and WM to answer my questions. If I can solidly reads on all three, that would help me move forward.

[nancy]

Yeah I've read Tes' meta already. I think I read everyone's meta here pretty thoroughly

[BlackVoid]

These are really weird posts though:

Are you trying to say Pine is not Mafia?

So, WhyMafia, you don't think Pine is scum?

Why would he be randomly asking people whether they don't think Pine is mafia? Seems like an informed read where he already know Pine is mafia.

[Aristophanes]

I spilled milk on my keyboard this morning and now my ↑ key is broken

Don't get too Down about it! It may be a Up key battle, but I'm sure you can find away around it! Maybe in an ancient Scroll?

[nancy]

Part of the reason I was townreading him is the difference in tone. Here, even when he was talking about the setup, he came across as aggressive and confident. In his scumgame, he seemed really limp and hesitant. That's one reason I started townreading him and kept it up throughout. Wanted to make a note of it. Curious if you agree with my assessment.

Tentatively agree, yes. I also think that he hasn't really been pressured all game so I don't know how accurate that is. The only time he's really been pressured was by me early game he kinda flailed hard.

[nancy]

Why would he be randomly asking people whether they don't think Pine is mafia? Seems like an informed read where he already know Pine is mafia.

1133

[nancy]

Don't get too Down about it! It may be a Up key battle, but I'm sure you can find away around it! Maybe in an ancient Scroll?

[TesXX]

Would could lynch TesXX. The way he suggested nancy to be a doc while she was fakeclaiming 1-shot bp before the roleswap stuff happened doesn't exactly look the best?

Wouldn't he shoot nancy N1 if he thought that? That actually points against him being scum not towards.

I was pretty sure nancy was the doctor when she claimed bulletproof. But it

is

possible that scum would get scared by the possibility of doc!nancy and nokill, which is why chronicle going nowhere last night does

not

clear his slot.
I have to leave soon, will read the thread when I'm back.

[nancy]

I was pretty sure nancy was the doctor when she claimed bulletproof.

Please link to posts indicating that you did indeed think this at the time.

[BlackVoid]

@Void

TRing TesXX for very incorrect reasons (obsession with setup rather than reads is scummy, not Towny).

Ftr Src's early game feels Town-motivated as fuck but this post makes me really side-eye him. If he doesn't have a TR on Tes here then this comment looks exactly like the kind of comment you make in dead threads where you're spoiled and talking about people's reads.

That was actually a quote from Pine's wall that src was responding to, not a post that src made himself.

[nancy]

My point was that saying that someone is TRing another person for incorrect reasons is not something that you say when you don't know their alignment.

[BlackVoid]

Src didn't actually say that though. He was quoting Pine without using the quote tag. Here's the original:

TRing TesXX for very incorrect reasons (obsession with setup rather than reads is scummy, not Towny).

[nancy]

Ohhhhhhhhh. He didn't use quote tags.

Fuck yeah. Tes is locktown.

[nancy]

TES IS MOTHERFUCKING LOCKTOWN PEOPLE.

[nancy]

Void we did it.

[nancy]

Ari what are your thoughts on Noodle?

[nancy]

Src didn't actually say that though. He was quoting Pine without using the quote tag. Here's the original:

TRing TesXX for very incorrect reasons (obsession with setup rather than reads is scummy, not Towny).

I actually had Tes as locktown at one point for this and obviously completely forgot about it. God, I really ought to keep notes.

[nancy]

Void how much longer do you have?

[BlackVoid]

I can be around for a while. I have a weird sleep/work schedule right now. What's up?

[nancy]

I'd like to summarize my issues with each slot and have you do yours and we go over as much as we can while we have this uninterrupted time together.

[nancy]

You agree that Tes is locktown?

[nancy]

Pine forcing that slot into his scumreads while perspective slipping knowledge of alignment, feels conclusive to me.

[nancy]

I need to revisit that exchange with Srceenplay....

[nancy]

Seeing as Drixx hasn't been hammered makes me feel more comfortable being scum.

Pedit
I'm not in a dead thread.

Thoughts on this post Void?