In post 1126, Firebringer wrote: In post 1124, jjh927 wrote:I'm october 8th.
And what, you're saying that I would defend town!TB for towncred? I assure you, I do not know TB's alignment but I take his breaking down to be sincere and personally believe that it would be worse on so many levels to break down like that as scum. I do not think he is a terrible person, as Frog seems to be implying. If you townread someone who is on the chopping block, you should always speak up.
No I am saying the way you went about defending or throwing questions in game was inherently scummy.
Nothing to do with TB alignment
ooh, it finally woke up. Thinking that JJ is White-knighting my slot. It might be the case. I do think at least one towny shouldve seen the inherent towny nature of the actual claim, since its just rediculous to think the claim could be a scum claimin that ability.
This may be true for the way he defended himself and replaced out.....but lets be honest here. The fact pretty much noone even thought things through with the actual claim is kind of sad as well.
In post 1129, Alisae wrote:So you weren't understanding what I was refering to when I was crumbing about chocolates and stuff.
Are chocolates in this context the same thing as cookies but slightly difference? Because if so, I have a real sweet tooth, and ill make you see the light yet - ive never failed in that regard yet, and you know it - so give me some time and an open mind.
In post 1143, Gorkington wrote:i just wanted to say
that as of right now
ive got a good feeling about this group of players.
like.
sometimes i play a game
and im like "oh my fuck if i die everything will fall apart".
but i think theres some good townies in this game.
and im kind of excited about it!
I think youre misreading at least 1 of them.
In post 1145, Gorkington wrote:like holy shit we've had two wagons in one day.
thats awesome sauce.
p-edit: I WASNT GOING TO SAY IT BUT I MEAN.
We had about 5 in civ mafia day1....didnt turn out so well
Transcend, im feeling ignored. Are you scum white-knighting my predecessor? Im getting weird vibed from you.
In post 1162, Fro99er wrote:JJ you can stop defending TB
We get it.
You think he's town.
How about scumhuting instead
And this post again I kind of like. I really hope my little voice is wrong and Frogger is actually town. That'd be nice. Id like the option of a 2nd try.
Gorkington, why so high on the continuous shitposting. Care to do some more goodposting again? And none of that evil Ate that you used to fool me last time.
In post 1221, Heartless wrote:
nononononononononooono
"why is he town?" is a perfectly good question
i mean... i GUESS you could possibly townread the replace-out outburst/s but that should've been shattered by the retraction
what is town about 4 half-assed townreads on the spammer friends?
Im getting some scum-pings from this slot as well. Just small ones for now. But now that I think about it.....this slot really hasnt done shit yet so far. Im gonna go ahead and place an early wager this one is carefully hiding scum.
In post 1236, Heartless wrote: In post 646, jjh927 wrote:PEdit: It would be town utility, wouldn't it? I guess I'm assuming things are predictable like that. Maybe I am wrong after all.
(quick aside about MS meta: any upick mod worth their salt will make scum roles that have conceivable town utility. it's also possible there's "scummy" dimensions to the role [like strongman or ninja or something] in addition to the "town" part. with a few exceptions [obvious confirmables like mason/IC; for the most part killing roles are town] role is null in upicks/role madness.)
Yuuuuuup, this slot is starting to ping me slightly harder for scum now. Im expecting a push from the slot to see if it can get TB lynched in the next few pages without actually being an obvious driving force behind it.
Im watching you potential buckets.
In post 1239, Heartless wrote:probably the best point for thinkbig being town now is transcend wking the wagon
oh. lol.
In post 1240, Transcend wrote:you guys have got to be kidding me if you think that his BEETHOVEN claim is fake and there's some scum counterclaim to that.
beethoven's not gonna be scumsided, the role he has doesn't sound scumsided at all
plus his iso is town as fuck what the fuck are you guys missing i don't even understand
thinkbig don't hardclaim in your third post for no reason next game lmfao
+
In post 1241, Eddiebyte wrote:i really dont want to wagon trans like
if i have to pull up meta i will but after botching my read on trans in pyp-with-cards i can pick up when trans doesnt give a shit about the game and becomes easy lynchbait :/
@trans what do you think of dunn here? im kind of sketched out by the fact he completely ignored the fact im pushing on him and you havent really weighed in on him when i'm trying to wagon him against your townread?
ftr i'm not going to vote tb until i can at least review the meta points and i wont have time until like after work so
pedit:
Transcend wrote:you guys have got to be kidding me if you think that his BEETHOVEN claim is fake and there's some scum counterclaim to that.
beethoven's not gonna be scumsided, the role he has doesn't sound scumsided at all
plus his iso is town as fuck what the fuck are you guys missing i don't even understand
thinkbig don't hardclaim in your third post for no reason next game lmfao
you know flavor's nai right :/
Quite some truth in these posts, and they make me feel slightly better about both slots. They both might be town yet.
In post 1244, Firebringer wrote: In post 1240, Transcend wrote:you guys have got to be kidding me if you think that his BEETHOVEN claim is fake and there's some scum counterclaim to that.
beethoven's not gonna be scumsided, the role he has doesn't sound scumsided at all
plus his iso is town as fuck what the fuck are you guys missing i don't even understand
thinkbig don't hardclaim in your third post for no reason next game lmfao
did you not read heartless statement about upicks the scum roles having SOME town utility?
you aren't new buddy.
BIG EEEEEEW-post. yuk. Scumpoints through - the - roof.
In post 1245, Transcend wrote: In post 1241, Eddiebyte wrote:@trans what do you think of dunn here? im kind of sketched out by the fact he completely ignored the fact im pushing on him and you havent really weighed in on him when i'm trying to wagon him against your townread?
i can't read him anymore
he used to be so fucking obvious town within about 5 posts of his game
but now he's hard to read
Shame Transcend didnt post stuff like this straight away. Im actually likin this group of posts quite a lot, and I felt the exact same way. To me, Dunn's entrance felt like a carbon copy of PYP. He has gone inactive, and I dont know his scumgame, but I felt pretty good about a slight TR on dunn for his early posting. Not a read on very certain on yet, but its a good starting point.
In post 1247, Firebringer wrote:i really think this excuse on TB role claim being town is silly.
if you want to argue TB doesn't claim his first post as scum, thats worthy of something.
Saying his role is inherently townie is stupid
It is not, at all. The role is inherantly towny.
Unless you really think its one of those games where I have a role pm with like 6 lines of abilities, with a ton of hidden scum potential that all need to mesh with the beethoven theme. Id rather say thinking along those lines is "stupid" as you put it though. And the Upick role design really doesnt get based on giving someone an OBVIOUS town role pm, and then just randomly adding some extra scum abilities that make no sense whatsoever flavourwise.
Lets just say my role is that of a frail old man. Its the role that balances the other town pr's with a higher power level. Thats what beethoven was after all. A musical genious with a nice trick, but very few other noteworthy traits (afaik).
This slot just keeps taking the occasional putshots at people, without really showing any hunting or original thought of its own.
This slot is quickly entering my scum top3
In post 1277, Gorkington wrote:{also i have to be honest fire, im a little scared of heartless :s dont tell them i said that though}
aaaah, someone else is noticing what im noticing eh? Good. We finally get to be town together gorkington, and youre having a nice activity level here. Bravo, it pleases me.
In post 1280, Firebringer wrote:i am hard to read. why are people town reading me?
if anyone should be nervous of someone, it should be you guys of me.
my scum game is pro now.
See: Kids Mafia
And these type of ego posts come from scum x times out of x [fill in your own imagined statistic, but its scum more often than not]
In post 1299, Firebringer wrote:My scum list right now:
Transcend, JJ, Titus, Alisae
Alisae is weakest scum read, because their case on TB felt a bit townie, but meh.
I am not letting that read go easily.
But then again.....I might be allergic to his posting style, but I can vibe with these reads pretty well. I think he's wrong about transcend at this point (but im not too sure yet), but I can all see these reads coming from a town analysis quite easily.
In post 1318, Bellaphant wrote:You've made 85 posts and had zero impact on the game? I can't see where your head is at at all.
- its on purpose though.....the question is....why?
Hydra of Eddie Cane and gigabyteTroubadour
