Open 680.1 C9++ | Endgame

[Firebringer]

If you were to flip scum Firescreamer, I am considering Titus deadlock for town. Not because she wouldn't buss, but the way you interact with her makes it clear to me you two aren't scum buddies.

[Firebringer]

Gamma Emerald is my only strong townread right now.
The wagon on him is gross.

[FireScreamer]

Well your reasoning is flawed but I cannot explain how without you sharing it. Why doesn't my scum hunting feel genuine? How have I been manipulative? I don't want to dismiss your case I want to correct your case. There are town reasons for everything I've done and I know that because I did them. I also haven't sorted your slot yet and I want you to explain yourself so I have every oppertunity to gut you once my wagon dies should you deserve it.

[FireScreamer]

If you were to flip scum Firescreamer, I am considering Titus deadlock for town. Not because she wouldn't buss, but the way you interact with her makes it clear to me you two aren't scum buddies.

Agreed obviously.

Gamma Emerald is my only strong townread right now.
The wagon on him is gross.

Why do you townread him? Who should I be on instead?

[Firebringer]

Well your reasoning is flawed but I cannot explain how without you sharing it. Why doesn't my scum hunting feel genuine? How have I been manipulative? I don't want to dismiss your case I want to correct your case. There are town reasons for everything I've done and I know that because I did them. I also haven't sorted your slot yet and I want you to explain yourself so I have every oppertunity to gut you once my wagon dies should you deserve it.

I think some of your questions are leading questions, so thats kind of manipulative, subtle but you know.

The push on Umlaut for his reaction test was bad and not genuine scum hunting imo.
Your interactions with Titus are the most weird thing in this game for me.

I think you should go after me and we do this Fire vs Fire fight that everyone wants.
LET THE PEOPLE HAVE THEIR SHOW!!!!!

We will see soon enough if bringer trumps screamer.

[Firebringer]

Why do you townread him? Who should I be on instead?

Its completely based on gut, but his posts ping me as the most town out of anyone so far.

[FireScreamer]

Well your reasoning is flawed but I cannot explain how without you sharing it. Why doesn't my scum hunting feel genuine? How have I been manipulative? I don't want to dismiss your case I want to correct your case. There are town reasons for everything I've done and I know that because I did them. I also haven't sorted your slot yet and I want you to explain yourself so I have every oppertunity to gut you once my wagon dies should you deserve it.

I think some of your questions are leading questions, so thats kind of manipulative, subtle but you know.

The push on Umlaut for his reaction test was bad and not genuine scum hunting imo.
Your interactions with Titus are the most weird thing in this game for me.

I think you should go after me and we do this Fire vs Fire fight that everyone wants.
LET THE PEOPLE HAVE THEIR SHOW!!!!!

We will see soon enough if bringer trumps screamer.

Which questions are leading questions? How are the interactions weird?

I do regret the Umlaut thing once it was explained to me. Can't fault you there.

[Firebringer]

Get your deck out, we are about to have a DUEL!
As the kids say "Get your game on!"

[FireScreamer]

Yu go oh is trash though

[Firebringer]

VOTE: Firescreamer
VOTE: Firescreamer
VOTE: Firescreamer
VOTE: Firescreamer
VOTE: Firescreamer
VOTE: Firescreamer
VOTE: Firescreamer
VOTE: Firescreamer
VOTE: Firescreamer
VOTE: Firescreamer
VOTE: Firescreamer
VOTE: Firescreamer
VOTE: Firescreamer
VOTE: Firescreamer
VOTE: Firescreamer
VOTE: Firescreamer
VOTE: Firescreamer
VOTE: Firescreamer

[FireScreamer]

Can't we play Magic instead?

[Firebringer]

stares at Firescreamer in a surprised and disgusted manner

Who are you?

[FireScreamer]

You

[Firebringer]

Why are we cheating in this mafia game by playing in same game?

[FireScreamer]

It's not cheating if we are everyone

[Firebringer]

it might not be cheating, but is it even a real game if we are everyone?

[FireScreamer]

Despite what you may have heard in Sunday school playing with yourself is only healthy

[FireScreamer]

Well your reasoning is flawed but I cannot explain how without you sharing it. Why doesn't my scum hunting feel genuine? How have I been manipulative? I don't want to dismiss your case I want to correct your case. There are town reasons for everything I've done and I know that because I did them. I also haven't sorted your slot yet and I want you to explain yourself so I have every oppertunity to gut you once my wagon dies should you deserve it.

I think some of your questions are leading questions, so thats kind of manipulative, subtle but you know.

The push on Umlaut for his reaction test was bad and not genuine scum hunting imo.
Your interactions with Titus are the most weird thing in this game for me.

I think you should go after me and we do this Fire vs Fire fight that everyone wants.
LET THE PEOPLE HAVE THEIR SHOW!!!!!

We will see soon enough if bringer trumps screamer.

Which questions are leading questions? How are the interactions weird?

I do regret the Umlaut thing once it was explained to me. Can't fault you there.

[Firebringer]

I will get to that later, I am going to go do something in meat space.

[FireScreamer]

That's fine. Just making sure it wasn't lost in memes

[Gamma Emerald]

So I think FS has a substantial amount of cases.

With that in mind, explain to me the bold:

Yo CommKnight

Doesn't the lack of cases made suggest a passive attitude from FireScreamer?

Your post not only tilted my read of FS to the scum side, it made me find a reason.
VOTE: FireScreamer

Because here's how I interpret it. You appear to be asking Comm whether {the lack of cases <your observation>} leads to {a passive attitude <Comm's accusation>}. As in, you know there is a lack of cases, but are wanting confirmation that that means there is a passive attitude (and thus scum).

This interpretation of your 912 appears confirmed by the non-bolded part of the post where you admit that Comm's post "made <you> find a reason," suggesting that you went out and determined, independently of Comm's posts, that FS was scum (because of the aforementioned "lack of cases").

But now you are saying there was a substantial amount of cases. What gives?

I thought of a reason based on his case. FS refuted that. Your questioning made me find evidence that refutes CK's case.

[Gamma Emerald]

Gamma, who on your wagon do you think is scum?

UNVOTE: Gamma Emerald

Will reconsider this when I get back.

this is nasty
VOTE: Umlaut

[shannon]

While the undeniable benefit of not having two fire-persons in the game can't be understated, I'd prefer you to bus Alchemist please

Shannon this is gross.

Don't blame me if I get confused between you later in the game, then!

(That was a poorly phrased joke, I just got done with a game where I accidentally bussed my scum buddy to death D1 because their name was similar to another player's name, and both slots replaced and I got mixed up).

(Not that I'm claiming to be scum with either Screamy or Growlithe here, of course)

[shannon]

Gamma, who on your wagon do you think is scum?

UNVOTE: Gamma Emerald

Will reconsider this when I get back.

this is nasty
VOTE: Umlaut

What's nasty about it?

Also, who *did* you think was scum on your wagon?

[Titus]

Umlaut firescreamer alchemist scumteam

Davesaz sk

Final guess

While the undeniable benefit of not having two fire-persons in the game can't be understated, I'd prefer you to bus Alchemist please

I regret my last post already.