Micro 701: Defiance Mafia II - Game Over

[McMenno]

let's. wagon

VOTE: pp

[1 Shot Vanilla Town]

Jester isn't hitting me as scum yet.
PP or Wood seem like a reasonable lynch. I agree that if there is scum they claimed town and I believe both McMenno and Charloux as not scum (not known for char) regardless of if there is only 3rd party to lynch or not.
The reason that lynching 3rd party only sounds off to me is because Dreal is playing like a Jester.
I do think that either Char is going to be town or if scum/3rd then either McMenno or Char as a killing roles with 2 scum.
4 town 2 3rd 2 scum is my prediction

Obviously balance will lack but let's be realistic here.

[1 Shot Vanilla Town]

Is that L1?

[1 Shot Vanilla Town]

No its L1 1/2

[Ircher]

Day 1 VC #8

Drealmerz7 (0) -
McMenno (0) -
PenguinPower (3) (L-1 1/2) - Edosurist, Jester, McMenno
Edosurist (0) -
Woodboys2339 (1) - Charloux
1 Shot Vanilla Town (0) -
Charloux (0) -
The_Jester (0) -
_{Keyenpeydee (1) - Penguin
Ircher (0) -}
No Lynch (1) - Drealm
Not Voting (2) - Vanilla A, Vanilla B, Vanilla C, Vanilla D, Vanilla E, Vanilla F, Vanilla G, Vanilla H, Woodboys

Lynch Threshold

With 8 votes in play, it takes 4 1/2 votes to lynch!

Deadline

Day 1 ends on Tuesday, May 2, 2017 5:00 PM EDT or in (expired on 2017-05-02 17:00:00).

Moderator Notes

As a reminder, while this game may be bastard, it is still a game. Please treat it as such.

Vanilla V/LA on weekends.
The moderator thinks you could do a bit more than you are doing; dead games are boring games!

Spoiler: Current Voting History

Day 1

Drealm: No Lynch (120)
McMenno: No Lynch (181) --> Penguin (375)
Penguin: Drealm (122) --> No Lynch (140) --> (Null) (141) --> Keyen (212)
Edosurist: Penguin (363)
Woodboys: Drealm (234) --> (Null) (236)
Charloux: No Lynch (139) --> (Null) (278) --> Woodboys (333)
Jester: Penguin (179) --> Charloux (233) --> Woodboys (297) --> Penguin (371)

Spoiler: Previous Voting History

Dawn (Pre-Game)

Drealm: Ircher (61)
Edosurist: McMenno (4)

[Ircher]

Prodding Penguin (2d 7h). He has (expired on 2017-04-28 18:42:21) to respond.

[1 Shot Vanilla Town]

Hey, McMenno why is a PP a better option than no lynch now or is it to keep the game flowing?

[1 Shot Vanilla Town]

@Mod - going to be starting my weekend V/LA a day early. Visiting family out in the neck of the woods.

[Edosurist]

@Mod:

I will also be V/LA this weekend. 4/28-4/30

[Edosurist]

Hey 1-shot. You around? Wanna come talk about this game to me?

[1 Shot Vanilla Town]

Sure what about?
I think that town are half or less I'm the game as it stands.

[Edosurist]

I dunno. This game just needs more discussion.
I also didn't understand your second sentence there. Mind restating it?

Drealmerz7

- I feel like he's given up a bit now that he lost momentum for the no-lynch. Is that more indicative of an anti-town wincon than his actions alone?

McMenno

- Any reads on what he could possibly be? My best guess is honestly survivor. I do believe he truly is third party though.

PenguinPower

- If you think PP's a fine choice, why you no vote?

Edosurist

- Do you like my hair today? I think it's fabulous.

Woodboys2339

- I don't think there's really anything to glean from his lack of willingness to play out the game. Your thoughts? Should we wait for a replacement before carrying out a lynch?

1 Shot Vanilla Town

- Tell me something about yourself.

Charloux

- Do you think it's believable that his role PM doesn't specify an alignment? I worry because he basically claimed a cop-type role so no one would want to lynch him but he has wiggle room with his full claim later on. This is what I meant in 319. I just needed to confirm what his role was before I mentioned it.

The_Jester

- Is 286 a townie post? In retrospect, it could be a plot for an "eliminate all 3rd parties" wincon or something. If you think that's a possibility, what do you think that says about Char's role?

[Ircher]

Your friendly mod is here to suggest Occam's Razor.

[1 Shot Vanilla Town]

I mean that right now I highly doubt there being more than 4 town.

Dreal I agree fully with and I feel that the "I have something to say" is just a cheap tactic to waste time for a no lynch.

McMenno
Yeah I think he's a non direct killing role as Erdington party.
PP
I'll vote but I need to hammer if I want my powers active from my votes .

Edo - it's great! I can't help but feel you were avoiding the game like when we were Mafia but I think you were actually busy on that game?

Wood
Yeah just a replace slot of scum that got over whelmed

Me
I'm town, I like shrimp on the barbie and a cold beer

Char
I believe it to be real and I think that his alignment is determined by events or he's the role of someone he investigates
Hidden alignment is very acceptable in bastard games.

Jester
I'm going by pure meta on Jester to think he's town. Just his attitude as a whole and I think Jester is an easy spot as scum. On phone so I'll look at the post tomorrow

[Edosurist]

I don't understand what "Erdington party" is. I googled "erdington party mafiascum" and got some... interesting results.

I've been legit busy both when I was scum with you and at the start of this game. If you want to see my other couple games that have finish recently, I was town in one and scum in the other. I was fairly inactive in both but that was unfortunately just poor timing.

I'll trust you regarding Jester.

[1 Shot Vanilla Town]

I don't understand what "Erdington party" is. I googled "erdington party mafiascum" and got some... interesting results.

I've been legit busy both when I was scum with you and at the start of this game. If you want to see my other couple games that have finish recently, I was town in one and scum in the other. I was fairly inactive in both but that was unfortunately just poor timing.

I'll trust you regarding Jester.

Phone post I have no idea what sort of party that is.
In fairness the fact you are pushing for progression tells me a lot. It's only really in towns benefit to keep the game as active as possible right now.

[drealmerz7]

nah, I've just been kind of 'meh' on mafia lately and low-energy in general to give this game what it needs

not a stalling tactic or whatever else, as that is cheap and lame and not how I play mafia

most of you seem pretty bloodthirsty, and not even considering a chance for peace, it's disheartening

today was a long day and again focus is not here to do this game justice, I'm sure (hopefully) it'll come in the next couple, thanks for bearing with me

[Edosurist]

If you had to choose two people to be scum, barring the fact that you believe we win by lynching the mod, who would they be?

[Charloux]

*pu sekaW*
VOTE: PP
*peels ot kcab seoG*
*2/1-L eb dluow tahT :sklat peelS*

[drealmerz7]

edos, is that to me? because I don't think we win by lynching the mod

I think we win by no-lynching on D1

if we resort to violence of any sort the situation changes and then I am not sure how we win

[Edosurist]

Ok I was just recalling from memory. Regardless, who's most likely to be scum?

[The_Jester]

edos, is that to me? because I don't think we win by lynching the mod

I think we win by no-lynching on D1

if we resort to violence of any sort the situation changes and then I am not sure how we win

I think YOU win if we NL D1 which makes me think you're a 3rd party

I don't really recall playing with 1-shot (alt?)

[1 Shot Vanilla Town]

Hey, PP I'm giving you intent here.

[PenguinPower]

Ok. Go ahead.

[The_Jester]

Sounds like caught scum to me.
If you're town, try to give us some reads at least.