Mini Normal 1909: Girls ♥ Girls 1 ~ Endgame

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

Fire, Tammy, Nacho, Alisae, Frog, SAD, Ari

Titus, Implosion, Hikari, Prism, Keyser


VOTE: Titus

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

Really I'm thinking of a Titus, Keyser, Implosion team and I'm gonna check if it makes sense

[Tammy]

Hikari - I will answer you tomorrow. I want to address the reads I thought that on since you asked and I'm getting ready to go to sleep and I just remembered I promised my other half there was something I would make tonight and completely forgot.

[Ser Arthur Dayne]

Alright caught up while skimming some parts

Tier list

Tammy, Hikari
Firebringer, Titus, implosion
Nacho, Keyser, Gin
Frogger, Ari
Prism, Alisae

Notes/Thoughts from catchup:

Spoiler:

- Alisae still scum (why you get scum alisae ). Everything reads kinda hostile where it looks like he's more interested in defending himself rather than actually scumhunting, and when he does give reads they look very fake and it doesn't look like he actually believes in them rather than just pushing something with ~FORCE~ to look town.
- Rb obnxious posts, but through and under those obnoxiousness are very contrived opinions and fake attempts at looking town. His imitating of nacho just didn't read as a town who's frustrated with being left out rather than him using it to try and look obvtown and buddy in the process.
- Nacho is making me paranoid in some places like the helping out hikari catch up it's a lot similar to what he did to Tammy in laundry where he tried to appease her. I feel like he's not doing it to Tammy because she's gonna notice it after a recent game but he's trying to buddy another. Though tbh he has those NACHOHUNTING bursts that he does more as town I think because he just gets lazy af from what I've seen of his scum game.
- Titus I was townreading early for her calling out the tammy nacho implosion because while I didn't really agree with it I felt it was super genuine. But then Ari attacked that post which felt super weak and Titus called him out on it so + points.
- Firebringer's alisae read is reading organic and the progession looks genuine.
- Frogger is lacking the vigor and drive from laundry. Like holy Frogger's 673 is just a word salad and super wishy wash. And it just feels so scum theater with Alisae.
- Ugh Gin's posts with him getting angry read fake but then his post earlier looked like he was genuinely pushing from a town scumhunting angle.
- Keyser's posts are annoying me why are they in a larger font, and she doesn't look like she was trying to game solve with her catch up posts rather than just responding to random things. Though that's not scummy (and I feel like a scum would at least try to look like they're gamesolving rather than random responses?), that's just being near-useless.
- I'm actually liking the Gin interaction with rb where rb is just trolling and dodging.
- Ari vs Hikari catchup/reaction to large amounts of posts is exactly how scum vs town react. Whereas Hikari's reaction felt genuine and then she attempted to read up (and her response to nacho about not feeling comfortable leaving so many pages unread), Ari's posts just feel like him getting unmotivated by so many pages similar to how unmotivated I was by the amount of pages when I was scum in Masquerade ball.
- Alisae's Keyser felt low hanging. Rb actually called him out on it so I'll give him that, even though I can see it as scum on scum even though ik people will prob call me out on confirmation bias.
- Ari's posts are so bad. Rb and implosion calling him out on it is good.
- I legit think that Keyser read list (961) is random.orged. Only think I agree with is the scumread on Alisae and townread on Boonskiies.
- This was one of the reasons Tammy was obvtowning in the beginning/middle but she's doing it a bit again but the defending/try to explain how nacho plays/works is extremely town-motivated from her.
- Holy moly those Ari posts. Can't tell if too scummy to be scum or he's just doing that on purpose, but they just lack actual ~content~.
- Really dislike Prism's Boonskiies vote.
- Wow super good Hikari 1102. I don't agree with the Firebringer and Titus scumreads. The former is likely 100% because she has no experience with Firebringer because everything she described is just regular firebringer. I also don't agree with the townreads on alisae/frogger obv but I skipped the explanation for why she townread them because it was too long.
- Skimmed past the boonskiies/firebringer argument b/c I'm not about that life
- I don't understand the Titus wagon and tbh her 1494 is p much the OMGUS I expect from townTitus.
- Pages 62-63 frogger posting is all over the place and the vote hopping doesn't read like natural progression.
- Alisae 1598 titus vote opportunistic this Titus wagon has like no real reasoning behind it...
- Prism with that 0 content and the request to "if someone wants to help me out to interact so I can get in this game" always just feels scummy because if someone really wanted to gamesolve then there's a lot of content they can read throughand try to get a feel for.
- Ohhh I think I forgot this earlier but I was townreading implosion from while I was still spectating b/c of his early interaction with Tammy. It was ~weird~ but it really didn't feel ~scum-motivated~.

[Ser Arthur Dayne]

Someone please explain wtf is this Titus wagon there's literally no competing wagons either LOL it just feels "day has been going on for too long let's just end day" which almost always ends in a shitty lynch.

Unvote
Vote: Prism

I WILL REVITALIZE EVERYONE ONTO A SCUM WAGON

[Ser Arthur Dayne]

Tbh in an ideal world I would like to see a prism and alisae competing wagons. Ik there's currently a small alisae wagon but it's being overpowered by the Titus wagon for ?????? reasons.

I will prob jump there if people don't sheep me on prism sorry alisae :/

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

I'm double voting with SAd until I feel motivated

VOTE: Prism

[Ser Arthur Dayne]

Titus you're really just using your vote badly.

[Ser Arthur Dayne]

!!! Gin

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

[Alisae]

- Alisae 1598 titus vote opportunistic this Titus wagon has like no real reasoning behind it...

Yeah...It's opportunstic because I want the day to end and I don't townread the slot. That's all the real justification I'm giving to that vote.

[Ser Arthur Dayne]

- Alisae 1598 titus vote opportunistic this Titus wagon has like no real reasoning behind it...

Yeah...It's opportunstic because I want the day to end and I don't townread the slot. That's all the real justification I'm giving to that vote.

Your vote tipped the wagons from ~competing~ to titus ahead of the curve in lone first.

Now if you were to do that because you really felt they were scum I wouldn't mind it.

But it was a weak reasoned vote that tipped the scale and felt manipulative b/c it helped to grow and nourish the town apathy and unmotivation and make people see a juicy wagon and go "okay I just wanna end the day I'm gonna get on that".

[Ser Arthur Dayne]

Who are your scumreads and why aren't you on them.

[Prism]

Largely expected. What do you not believe about my statements re: parsing?

[Prism]

Directed at Dayne

[Ser Arthur Dayne]

Gin friendo what is this?

Spoiler:

VOTE: Titus
It's because the game is 64 pages and it's a mini. Thanks Boon and Gin and rb
pedit: ILY too Frog <3

Can you not fucking shade when you're the 4th highest poster?

No seriously?

Why even fucking say that?

You had to go to activity and sort the posts and see you were the 4th highest so what was the purpose of that besides throwing shade excluding yourself?

Fire, Tammy, Nacho, Alisae, Frog, SAD, Ari

Titus, Implosion, Hikari, Prism, Keyser


VOTE: Titus

[Prism]

Poor phrasing on my end so my apologies-do you not believe my statements re: parsing is the starting question, my assumption is he don't.

[Prism]

"He don't" Someone kill me.

[Ser Arthur Dayne]

Largely expected. What do you not believe about my statements re: parsing?

The fact it's so easy to make and looks like you're really just not interested in figuring out the game.

Here I'll show you an example between what town fallen behind and scum fallen behind look like:

Thanks. I am really uncomfortable leaving 12 pages unread, so I'll probably go back and read them at some point, on the off chance I can actually get some information. I'll Try to catch up from 24 for now and post tonight. I have class right now and a fairly easy paper to write by midnight, but once all of that is done, I promise I'll catch up and become a contributing member of this game.

I'm having a really hard time parsing this and get my best reads via personal interactions with others so again, if anyone wants to give me their quick salient points, that would really help.

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

Spoiler:

Gin friendo what is this?

VOTE: Titus
It's because the game is 64 pages and it's a mini. Thanks Boon and Gin and rb
pedit: ILY too Frog <3

Can you not fucking shade when you're the 4th highest poster?

No seriously?

Why even fucking say that?

You had to go to activity and sort the posts and see you were the 4th highest so what was the purpose of that besides throwing shade excluding yourself?

Fire, Tammy, Nacho, Alisae, Frog, SAD, Ari

Titus, Implosion, Hikari, Prism, Keyser


VOTE: Titus

Alisae pissed me off by what I took as a personal insult and the bottom of the list is a my reads if I threw out concentrating on thought into a fuck-it bucket and wrote down the names as I felt about them on the spot.

[Ser Arthur Dayne]

Ari's reaction to the pages are the same way.

It's the same thing I pull off when I'm scum, I'm really just not interested in reading a lot of pages so it's easier for me to just complain about the amount of pages or how dense the game is and then ask people to interact with me. It's easier to hide in interaction than it is to go through a bunch of posts and commit to hard reads as scum, whereas a townie is delighted to have that much game content to sit down and go through to figure out the scum.

It's not even about the AMOUNT there is. You can sit down and read 10 pages. Or 20. Or however much you have time for. But the point is there's JUICY CONTENT there. Scum just don't care to read it whatsoever.

Pedit: Yeah but it looked like you were frustrated with Alisae's reasoning for voting Titus but then you jumped on the wagon?

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

that had nothing to do with the vote? It was purely on Alisae commenting on activity

[Ser Arthur Dayne]

But do you like the Titus wagon.

Or was it an apathy vote.

If the former why.

[Ser Arthur Dayne]

I think I'm having trouble figuring out who on the Titus wagon is actually scumreading her and who is apathetic/wants day to end/just voting her because "not townreading her".

[Alisae]

Who are your scumreads and why aren't you on them.

I sr Keyser. No one wants to do them with me for some reason.
Titus is a slot I just don't care for.

Like, as long as {SAD, Boon, Nacho, Tammy, Fire} go untouched (going off of the top of my mind) then we're good because those are the reads I'm more confident in and those are my townreads :p