Mini 1910: Railgun Mafia [Game Over]

[Fro99er]

I like how he was willing to explain why he suspected Gerry, so I'm willing to put him as a slight Town-lean.

why does explaining oneself earn a town-lean?

fun fact

scum can explain themselves too

[DanelerH]

I like how he was willing to explain why he suspected Gerry, so I'm willing to put him as a slight Town-lean.

why does explaining oneself earn a town-lean?

fun fact

scum can explain themselves too

In my mind, they would be more reluctant to, but I can see what you mean.

[Fro99er]

That doesn't make sense.

Some scum love explaining to "appear townie"

what do you make of cabd's push on Gerry, not just for explaning, but from the actual points made?

[DanelerH]

That doesn't make sense.

Some scum love explaining to "appear townie"

what do you make of cabd's push on Gerry, not just for explaning, but from the actual points made?

The main issue Cabd seems to have with Gerry is 86, specifically the use of the word "honestly". I don't see much else behind the push, so I think he's just tunneled. Whether it's from Town or Scum, I can't say for sure (especially after the point you made), but it feels more like Town to me.

[Alisae]

VOTE COUNT 1 . 9

• Gamma Emerald
  - 3 ( Accountant, Aeronaut, Edosurist )
  L- 4
  
  
  Carnelian
  ----- 2 ( Titus, Fro99er )
  L- 5
  
  
  keyenpeydee
  --- 1 ( Torque )
  L- 6
  
  
  Garrybote
  ----- 1 ( Cabd )
  L- 6
  
  
  Edosurist
  ----- 1 ( Gamma Emerald )
  L- 6
  
  
  DanelerH
  ------ 1 ( XnadrojX )
  L- 6
  
  
  
  Not Voting
  ---- 4 ( DanelerH, Carnelian, Garrybote, keyenpeydee )

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to Lynch
Deadline is in (expired on 2017-05-19 09:48:00)

[Fro99er]

Alright, that's fair.

The "honestly" point IS dumb, which is why I made fun of it, and a player of cabd's caliber can do better than using that as a point. That's literally Gerry's playstyle is to say "honestly" as either alignment.

The rest of the Gerry case is trying to read something into it that's not there. Also, the mindset cabd starts with is scum!gerry rather than town!gerry, so it may just be confbias

Nothing I've seen so far is a compelling reason for me to think it WASN'T scum motivated.

In other words, cabd needs evidence to show why Gerry is town rather than evidence to show why he's scum. Whether that's cabd's normal playstyle, I don't know. I played with scum cabd once, and he threw out a bunch of townreads early before eventually replacing out.

[Gamma Emerald]

TBH I feel tunneled and need to reanalyze
My current reads are likely to change now that I'm trying to read unbiased

[gerryoat]

@gerryoat, what do you think of Cabd's push on you? Do you have any suspicions?

I think it's NAI, I can see him doing that as either alignment.

[gerryoat]

actually

VOTE: Carn

this is NOT a town approach to the game

how so?

[gerryoat]

That doesn't make sense.

Some scum love explaining to "appear townie"

what do you make of cabd's push on Gerry, not just for explaning, but from the actual points made?

The main issue Cabd seems to have with Gerry is 86, specifically the use of the word "honestly". I don't see much else behind the push, so I think he's just tunneled. Whether it's from Town or Scum, I can't say for sure (especially after the point you made), but it feels more like Town to me.

How is that a TR tho? I have seen people do that to me in the past so i was curious if that was really his issue.

[XnadrojX]

Sorry, "If Gamma is scum, I'm likely to be scum" because I pulled my vote off him? So believing your former scumread when they give a genuine sounding explanation is a crime now?
Besides, I never said I townread him, not did I say he gets my free pass today. If he convinces me he's scum, I would vote him. I don't know from which dimension you're pulling that association from.

Honestly

, I think DanelerH 253 was bad

[Fro99er]

actually

VOTE: Carn

this is NOT a town approach to the game

how so?

come on Gerry

we're 3.5 days into the game phase and he's troll posting/prod dodging. But not in the way you troll post. His troll posts are literally nothing

this is scum lurking

[Gamma Emerald]

Carnelian is a Yume alt
This is her normal play style.

[Fro99er]

Eh, if it's a yume alt then that's even more concerning. She was scum the only time I played with her and she did nothing other than scumread me for no reason the whole game, and troll posted.

[Gamma Emerald]

She's also a lurker as town

[Fro99er]

show me a town game of hers

[Gamma Emerald]

viewtopic.php?f=56&t=68775

[Fro99er]

looks like she at least posted content there when she posted.

this isn't content here.

[Gamma Emerald]

I don't see much content there

[Fro99er]

she's talking about the mechanics of the game there, and about picking something and discussing what her other options are

[Gamma Emerald]

That's not very deep content though

[Fro99er]

it's light years deeper than here because there's literally NO content here. NONE

her scum game she didn't start with content either

[Accountant]

Hey everyone, just popping in to point out that 256 is incredibly LAMIST.

[Gamma Emerald]

How is that LAMIST?
I'm just saying I'm re analyzing the game.

[Alisae]