Real Folk Blues Rematch [GAME OVER]

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

For me, loud just seems bastard to give to scum. There are not many roles I can think of where it be worth the drawback. Silencer maybe?

I was a loud scum doctor in Gay mafia 3.

How did that work? How does that make sense? So whoever you protected was told? Well if you only protected scum, then wouldn't that be a pointless modifier? I'm not really seeing the point?

The point is that it exists for scum
If I remember correctly, scum used Titus to loud protect and then blocked Titus, the loud went through but not the protection

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

Did Dave say how he visited SQ?

[PeregrineV]

For me, loud just seems bastard to give to scum. There are not many roles I can think of where it be worth the drawback. Silencer maybe?

I was a loud scum doctor in Gay mafia 3.

How did that work? How does that make sense? So whoever you protected was told? Well if you only protected scum, then wouldn't that be a pointless modifier? I'm not really seeing the point?

There was a game with a loud scum Tracker. It was meant to weaken the scumteam by limiting fakeclaims.

[PeregrineV]

So five rolenames, who are "town" as long as they claim. But not five players, unless they want to claim those rolenames.



Got it.

this is awful :/

No, makes sense. I am just missing the part where I need to 100% believe it, then live it.

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

So five rolenames, who are "town" as long as they claim. But not five players, unless they want to claim those rolenames.



Got it.

this is awful :/

No, makes sense. I am just missing the part where I need to 100% believe it, then live it.

Game has broken flavor babe

[Cerberus v666]

Davesaz, you want to tell us what you were doing last night?

Also if someone got a guilty from SQ feel free to out that I guess.

I was obviously not killing. I'd prefer not to say until it's actually helpful, other than you now know my role has a loud modifier.

If anyone got a result from SQ it will not contain the identity of their target, so unless we can figure out who they would have targeted we're pretty much out of luck.

Loud modifier. So concecutive nights of that ability used make it probable that Dave didn't shoot SQ at least.
@Gork: was it the omission regarding my roles details, or something else in my post?

[Gorkington]

omission could very very easily be stalling and i really dislike you shitting on the weight of doggo's reads as the NK target when its really self-serving here.

[Insomniacs]

at the start of d1 titus claimed a list of 5 characters that were confirmed as town to her.

My bad, I missed that. Who are the five town?

If PV can't read the first page he is scum.
He should ya know quit scumclaiming.

--Math

He did the exact same thing in Elemental Trinity as scum.

--Math

Was going to let it go, but no.

Civilization Mafia.

Yes. You can find a game I was wrong in a lot. So? You didn't have reading comprehension fails that game you were just intentionally an antitown player.

--Math

[Insomniacs]

Did Dave say how he visited SQ?

Dave sends PM to mod.
Ascetic gets visits from loud players regardless their action.

I hate repeating myself.
Ask Frozen if you don't believe me then move on.

--Math

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

So Dave just goes, hey I'm going to shout at you?

[Titus]

For me, loud just seems bastard to give to scum. There are not many roles I can think of where it be worth the drawback. Silencer maybe?

I was a loud scum doctor in Gay mafia 3.

How did that work? How does that make sense? So whoever you protected was told? Well if you only protected scum, then wouldn't that be a pointless modifier? I'm not really seeing the point?

I protected town and used it to "confirm" myself when there was no kill.

[Titus]

at the start of d1 titus claimed a list of 5 characters that were confirmed as town to her.

My bad, I missed that. Who are the five town?

If PV can't read the first page he is scum.
He should ya know quit scumclaiming.

--Math

He did the exact same thing in Elemental Trinity as scum.

--Math

Was going to let it go, but no.

Civilization Mafia.

Yeah calling Math dumb isn't helping.

[Gamma Emerald]

So Dave just goes, hey I'm going to shout at you?

My veiw of the roles in play is:
Loud makes their presence known.
Ascetic is reclusive so no one is able to target them.
The loud guy still makes a shit ton of noise regardless.

[Cerberus v666]

omission could very very easily be stalling and i really dislike you shitting on the weight of doggo's reads as the NK target when its really self-serving here.

Lynch me. Seriously. I'd say the same fucking thing whether I was in the list or not, and did so because it's an observation that everyone needs to hear....or did you think that I somehow missed how bad that observation of mine makes me look? Or did you perhaps miss the fact that I very specifically didn't say any of them were probably town? I said they were almost certainly NOT on the team that killed them,which helps us sort out associatives to the different scum teams, but doesn't mean I think any of them should be considered cleared, including myself.

Also, why do I need to stall a lie detector claim? Just pick stallomething a teammate said that's true or false and claim and result in it, done. Utilize whatever investigatives my team has to create the circumstances for the next detect to be performed on someone who isn't a member. Lie about picking a bad quote the next night. Blah blah. Changing my claim isn't necessary for scum!me to pull it off.

[Insomniacs]

So Dave just goes, hey I'm going to shout at you?

My veiw of the roles in play is:
Loud makes their presence known.
Ascetic is reclusive so no one is able to target them.
The loud guy still makes a shit ton of noise regardless.

They are targetable actions don't go through.
In other words trackers/watchers still get results.

Please stop saying things and just ask Frozen.

Thanks!
--Math

[Gorkington]

except ive seen plenty of scumteams kill people who suspect them on n1. it happens all the time. most people dont read back to check the reads of people who die, especially not earlygame and especially not when people are going to be focused on the flips, not the nightkills that go through.

its super weak that all youve come in to do so far is discredit a dead player who scumread you and admit that you were fakeclaiming on d1.
who is scum.
push something.

[Insomniacs]

except ive seen plenty of scumteams kill people who suspect them on n1. it happens all the time. most people dont read back to check the reads of people who die, especially not earlygame and especially not when people are going to be focused on the flips, not the nightkills that go through.

its super weak that all youve come in to do so far is discredit a dead player who scumread you and admit that you were fakeclaiming on d1.
who is scum.
push something.

RB is likely town. What do you think of PV?

--Math

[Cerberus v666]

Nope, I wasn't fake claiming. I didn't tell you the frequency with which I could use my ability. Very different. And sure, you can certainly disagree with my position about the NK. Maybe the scum team is stupid.

And no, I don't think so. I have neither the time nor inclination to actually connect with the game in a way that will allow analysis. There is a reason why I was chaining my vote to randoms.

[Insomniacs]

And a general PSA to town:

Quit fucking fakeclaiming already.

I have fake claimed ONCE in my entire scum career and it was believed. Seriously. It was a rare case fake claiming was good for Town.

Stop fucking fake claiming all the damn time. It makes your real claims meaningless when you do.

--Math

[PeregrineV]

at the start of d1 titus claimed a list of 5 characters that were confirmed as town to her.

My bad, I missed that. Who are the five town?

If PV can't read the first page he is scum.
He should ya know quit scumclaiming.

--Math

He did the exact same thing in Elemental Trinity as scum.

--Math

Was going to let it go, but no.

Civilization Mafia.

Yes. You can find a game I was wrong in a lot. So? You didn't have reading comprehension fails that game you were just intentionally an antitown player.

--Math

That was entirely your opinion.

You also posted your opinion loudly and continuously, to the ending of a full scum sweep of the game.

And every-time I tried to move it to looking for scum, you brought it back to arguing with anything I said, and whether I was a town treestump or not.

So, if you are determined to try something similar here in a 32 player game, I'll probably just end up ignoring what you have to say.

[Ramcius]

except ive seen plenty of scumteams kill people who suspect them on n1. it happens all the time. most people dont read back to check the reads of people who die, especially not earlygame and especially not when people are going to be focused on the flips, not the nightkills that go through.

its super weak that all youve come in to do so far is discredit a dead player who scumread you and admit that you were fakeclaiming on d1.
who is scum.
push something.

You can't be sure killer was from someone they suspected, it could be other scum team trying "frame" their suspects, or killing them for being widely townread, or any other reason, i. e. it's not general rule for scum behavior and you can't use it as general rule for scumhunting

[PeregrineV]

at the start of d1 titus claimed a list of 5 characters that were confirmed as town to her.

My bad, I missed that. Who are the five town?

If PV can't read the first page he is scum.
He should ya know quit scumclaiming.

--Math

He did the exact same thing in Elemental Trinity as scum.

--Math

Was going to let it go, but no.

Civilization Mafia.

Yeah calling Math dumb isn't helping.

I didn't say she was dumb.

I am saying that playing in a similar manner to that game will cause me either to ignore her, lynch her, or get into a shouting match.

I'd only prefer to lynch her if scum, and would not prefer to do the other 2.

[Tywin Lannister]

@caiterb: so I didn't know what a lie detector really does, so I looked it up real quick. Wiki says that role is rarely used because you could just have everyone say ' I'm town' and just clear everyone one by one until you found a lie.

If that's the case though, couldn't you just force that? Like why wouldn't you?

[Tywin Lannister]

Sigh. @cerb

Autocorrect

[Gamma Emerald]

It can't do that though in this incarnation