Open 688: Diffusion of Power (Game Over)

[aronagrundy]

sheep

Kinda new.

Hm? I townread him because I could see the logic behind his posts, although I think his black and white approach to solving the game is misguided. Like in his opening post he scumreads you and me and I could see him scumreading me for the vt crumb and thinking you were scum by association

[aronagrundy]

VOTE: creature

i'm interested in seeing how this goes

[Hellfire Missile]

(I see why GE voted me)

Why? Why did GE vote you?

Also why you can see the reasons behind GE's vote but not those of Sesq or Comm?

GE voted me because he didn't like the fact that i basically repeated the other person (ajorn?)
Sesq i have no idea, he's just like, "i'm not sharing my reads with scum" (Which, he hasnt said jack shit to anyone now without prodding from me)
and comm was being sarcastic i think, take a look at his post when he voted me

[Hellfire Missile]

you can see why i'm not providing my case, right?

No.
The list of times when withholding a worthwhile case as town is a good move is very limited, and on Day 1 with no Night 0 is even more limited.
I'm pretty much left with the following options;
1. The case is super thin and it's boring/meaningless to explain 'gut'
2. You're convinced your tell is super amazing, and don't wish to reveal it to other scum so that you can catch them.

If it's #1 you're wasting everyone's time by acting like it's anything more than that.
If it's #2 then, I submit, the tell probably isn't as good as you think, and even if it is it's strongly worth explaining to lynch one scum, because I've never seen a secret tell work twice in the same game.
If it's some other option then I'm too dumb to think of it.

uh, what?

what the fuck is thissssssssssssssss

Sheep provides reasonable explanation as to why you should provide reads even if there's scum
"lolwut" goes Sesq
Lets say you don't want to reveal your reads because "scum is there"
you get NK'd maybe and no one knows what you were gonna say
Or you reveal to town
Maybe you get a scum lynched and then you get NK'd
It's either
You don't say anything and maybe get NK'd/Lynched, then no one knows what you were gonna say, therefore a waste
Or
You say something, maybe get a scum lynched, and get NK'd. You got a scum at the cost of your life, which would be worth it because there's only 3 scum and like 7 town or something like that
PLUS

WE HAVE DOCS HERE

THEY SAVE YOU FROM DEATH
I PROMISE

[Creature]

VOTE: creature

i'm interested in seeing how this goes

How to Waste Your Time

[Hellfire Missile]

There's literally no reason for you to not explain your reads

you could've gone gut earlier and i would've been like, "yeah, maybe"

but now you've like, dug a hole

you've refused to answer two/three people's requests for explanations

that's pretty suss

[Hellfire Missile]

VOTE: creature

i'm interested in seeing how this goes

How to Waste Your Time

why are you dying?
Is MS not as fun?
or are you actually dying in rl
bc that would be pretty spooky

(Note: nothing to do with the game i just wanted to know)

[Creature]

I feel like I'm in the slow process of leaving the site (like I did in one other forums).

[Sesq]

damn, hm. i was about to hop on creature but you just gave me another reason that you're scum.

[Sesq]

i want to try and vote for other people, but you're making it far too difficult not to.

[Sesq]

into the contest i dive

[Hellfire Missile]

damn, hm. i was about to hop on creature but you just gave me another reason that you're scum.

What

The

Fuck


Okay someone else do this

Maybe then he'll STOP FUCKING DODGING QUESTIONS
WHY DOES NO ONE ELSE FIND THIS SCUMMY

[Creature]

Because it's kind of expected from Sesq?

[Gamma Emerald]

Because it's kind of expected from Sesq?

This is his meta? YAY WE GOT A SHITTY PLAYER IN OUR TABLE HERE

[Sesq]

damn, hm. i was about to hop on creature but you just gave me another reason that you're scum.

What

The

Fuck


Okay someone else do this

Maybe then he'll STOP FUCKING DODGING QUESTIONS
WHY DOES NO ONE ELSE FIND THIS SCUMMY

HAHHHAAHHA

HAHHAHAHAHAHHAH

HOLY SHIT

I CANT BELIEVE THIS

HAHAHAHAHAHAH

Because it's kind of expected from Sesq?

This is his meta? YAY WE GOT A SHITTY PLAYER IN OUR TABLE HERE

still?

well, it shows how unobservant some of you are.

[Gamma Emerald]

That says contest
Did yo mean content?
Also, sorry. Your avvie makes me think ur a dude.

[Sesq]

no, it was in reference to site contest, which is the thread i thought i was on

[CommKnight]

Also, @Comm: why are you defending Sesq so much?

probably because hes familiar with my style

not with me personally, we haven't played before

Yep. Also the fact that the style is working. I'd also add NJAC to the list. So far I got: Hellfire Missile, Cooperative Sheep, NJAC and LunaeCinere. With preference in that order.

With 3 scum, obviously at least one of them are town. But I'll be happy to be right about 2/4 of them on D1.

Definitely think Hellfire or Sheep would be the best two to pick from today. Easy scum is easy.

[Gamma Emerald]

Comm ask Sesq why he scumreads HM

[CommKnight]

Comm ask Sesq why he scumreads HM

My guess is similar reasons as to why I and you scum read HM. Or are you now saying you voted HM without scum reading him?

[ShadedMelee]

another prod dodge. Still struggling here.

[alban]

Has anyone has experience of playing with hellfire? He is pinging me badly.

[Almost50]

VC 1.07

Hellfire Missile (3)

: Sesq, CommKnight, Gamma Emerald,

Sesq (3)

: Pyra, NotTheRealPaul, Hellfire Missile,

Creature (3)

: ShadedMelee, NJAC, aronagrundy,

Cooperative Sheep (1)

: Creature,

aronagrundy (1)

: Cooperative Sheep,

Gamma Emerald (1)

: LunaeCinere,

Not Voting

(2): alban,

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline

: (expired on 2017-06-02 18:30:00)

*Searching for Pyra replacement

[Cooperative Sheep]

you can see why i'm not providing my case, right?

No.
The list of times when withholding a worthwhile case as town is a good move is very limited, and on Day 1 with no Night 0 is even more limited.
I'm pretty much left with the following options;
1. The case is super thin and it's boring/meaningless to explain 'gut'
2. You're convinced your tell is super amazing, and don't wish to reveal it to other scum so that you can catch them.

If it's #1 you're wasting everyone's time by acting like it's anything more than that.
If it's #2 then, I submit, the tell probably isn't as good as you think, and even if it is it's strongly worth explaining to lynch one scum, because I've never seen a secret tell work twice in the same game.
If it's some other option then I'm too dumb to think of it.

uh, what?

What part confuses you? I think I answered your question very clearly.

Add Cooperative Sheep to the list of people I'd hang today.

The only people who fear gut reads are scum.
[snip]
Why don't you start by telling us who scum is Sheep.

1. When did I indicate that I "fear gut reads" in any way at all?
2. I have already presented a case on Argon - would you like to address my case?

[NJAC]

@Comm:

I'd be good with a Lunae lynch today as well

What exactly makes you think she's scum?