Mini 1904: Rad Idea Mafia! (Endgame!)

[Gamma Emerald]

BTW there are 7 VT cards
For possible claim checks

[Gamma Emerald]

Spoiler: 3 of 4

KilltheStory
Deimos (flaked)
Clemency (flaked)
Cerberus666
Drixx
Alpacax2 (inactive)
Klingoncelt
Culted (flaked)
Drone (flaked)
Ser Arthur Dayne
Kagami (inactive)
Parama (inactive)
mhsmith0
Mewtaph (inactive)
Synik (flaked)
Comparing Realities (inactive)
Basic (inactive)
Giovani iP (inactive)
Zakk (banned)
Maxous (inactive)
Shiro (doubt it by activity)
No one from Newbie 1764, last Newbie BTW, after that game I decided not to do newbies until I could dedicate myself to it
Barely played in Star Wars
Lowell (doubt it)
Qubixes (flaked)
Nmego12345
Thor665
Aelin (inactive)
Suzune (period of inactivity)
DeathbyWobuffet (prob not)
HowardRoark (inactive)
ArcAngel9 (flaked)
Ms Columbo, excepting activity here since we play on another site, please don't ask which one or I will has much sads.
Dunhallym (inactive)
ZZZX
Prohawk
PsychoticDave (flaked)
pirate mollie (inactive)
knightmare (inactive)
Penguin_alien (rarely active)
Lapsa (inactive)
Elbirn
ConManMick
Fro99er (prob not)
Empking
shadonra (inactive)
Spade_Ace (doubt it)
Bangthemafia (same as spade)
Burger King (inactive but if it was I'd lol since that guy is a jackass too)
sad1942 (inactive)
tojam2 (inactive)
BK201 (flaked)
Eric Rasputin (no effing way)
chilledtea
aronagrundy (doubt it)
Formerfish
Akarin (WHO? Prob not)
Hawk (newer)
Inocentvillager (inactive)
Celtic (inactive)
TheSoldier (inactive)
Bork Bork (no)
Darkly (doubt it)
Crash (doubt it)
Thefuzzylogic
momo (doubt it)
Vecna
WhyMafia (u fokin wot m8? No way)
Green Crayons (prob not)
Brian Skies (prob not)

I think 3 is actually enough

[1 Shot Vanilla Town]

My view on TP is the same with you calling me scum lol
I think Snarky is town since his claims make sense

In response tot his and 724.

I'm not saying that just calling you scum. But do you think that either me or TIP are scum, do you think we both are? I want to understand your thought process here.

Okay, so you believe the PGO claim. That's great. What makes you think that town would take PGO over scum?
And why does it make sense to reveal a unique role over a generic role?
By what you have said, it is better to have the role VT hidden to help scum claim this, over Graverobber which could be called out later game?

And can you explain to me what is fun about IC (With the assumtion of it not being boring, I came to fun)? I suspect that you found my case against TIP, took a snippet and misunderstood what I was saying.
By no means is IC fun (or non boring). The argument I was saying was, taking BP over IC for the fact that IC isn't fun, when BP has basically the same effect doesn't match up.

How is it though, you understand the reason for taking BP from your past body, and yet TIP taking BP is something that you dislike? Surely if you were town, you would be more open minded to TIP taking BP over everyone else.

[1 Shot Vanilla Town]

BTW there are 7 VT cards
For possible claim checks

You are correct... And there are align cards that we do not know of.
Could all be try, could be false, just because the possibility is there does not have an effect on what the truth is.
But it does go back to my comment, why give Scum information on what not to claim, when you can give a generic throw away and give scum that little bit less information?

[Gamma Emerald]

IC is fun because you can get people to listen to you
BP doesn't have that same effect, in fact it's somewhat distrusted since it is viewed as an excuse for not being nightkilled
You do realize gravedigger is NOT graverobber right

[1 Shot Vanilla Town]

IC is fun because you can get people to listen to you
BP doesn't have that same effect, in fact it's somewhat distrusted since it is viewed as an excuse for not being nightkilled
You do realize gravedigger is NOT graverobber right

I disagree. IC people always get lazy, put less effort in and end up getting killed. To me that doesn't sound like a boat ride around Oz.
Yes, I do realise what role we are talking about.
Did you understand what I said? I said it gives less information to scum. Gravedigger is a unique role. Why give a unique role for scum to cross of their "to claim" list when you can give VT?

[Gamma Emerald]

Why would mafia claim Gravedigger

[1 Shot Vanilla Town]

Why would mafia claim Gravedigger

Because it's a town alignment card.
You do understand how this game works, right?

[Gamma Emerald]

Yes
I've played this type of setup several times so I'm rather well versed in judging discards

[1 Shot Vanilla Town]

Yes
I've played this type of setup several times so I'm rather well versed in judging discards

Yet you can't grasp the concept that scum with less information is better for town...

[Gamma Emerald]

I feel that decision wasn't made with information in mind

[1 Shot Vanilla Town]

I feel that decision wasn't made with information in mind

Regardless to what you feel. It was a bad choice.
Your comment was "Snarky makes complete sense and anyone who disagree is wrong." 724.
I am disagreeing. Tell me why I'm wrong.

[Gamma Emerald]

I'd discard NU in a heart beat.

[Gamma Emerald]

Is Javajoe24 your main?

[Gamma Emerald]

I have a very small main pool at this point
I eliminated people based on profile info (gender preference, age, etc.)

[1 Shot Vanilla Town]

@Mod - normal weekend V/LA - due to the situation I will try to be involved, otherwise Lynch Gamma.

[Rautherdir]

I kind of wish you had not claimed gamma, but oh well that won't happen now.
I personally am banking on the fact that either that was an alien kill or a PGO kill, as that limits the number of kills we can have in the future.
I am completely okay with a TiphaineDeath lynch.
Also, hello Gamma.

[JerryArr]

@Mod - normal weekend V/LA - due to the situation I will try to be involved, otherwise Lynch Gamma.

V/LA acknowledged.

[Gamma Emerald]

Hey Rautherdir

[Rautherdir]

Guess we're waiting on Snarky and Riley to get back now...

[1 Shot Vanilla Town]

Yeah waiting on Riley, Snarky and TIP to vote Gamma.

[Gamma Emerald]

I doubt Riley will vote me
at least I hope they don't or I will ;;;;~;;;;

[1 Shot Vanilla Town]

We'll see.
You're scum here and I'm certain over it.

[JerryArr]

SnarkySnowman has been prodded for the second time. If a replacement is needed, the Day timer will be paused and extended. If not, it might be extended anyway.

[Gamma Emerald]

Tbh I think there might be >2 scum and that's why the thread is so dead