Large Normal 204: BooneyToonz III - Calling All Cryptids!END

[FourTrouble]

I don't see it in Crush. I don't understand where the votes are coming from and my early gut read on him says town.

What about him says town?

[Lapsa]

@penguin could you tell in your own words what you see in that quote?

[Ginngie]

Transcend sounds like a righteous wagon

Why?

I feel it in my bones

[FourTrouble]

I feel it in my bones

Why?

[PenguinPower]

@penguin could you tell in your own words what you see in that quote?

the entirety. it's unnecessary (the Transcend wagon is small); he regurgitates WhyMafia's reasoning for the votes (even though no reasoning for the votes has been stated); AND, it's

uncomely

.

[PenguinPower]

Transcend sounds like a righteous wagon

Why?

I feel it in my bones

does it feel electric, wavy when you turn it on?

[Egg]

Lapsa, crush's attitude towards transcend seems like someone who is thinking critically. He seems to genuinely be trying to determine transcend's alignment. And his conclusion doesn't seem like one that scum would push the way he is.

Preview edit: do you see any other reasoning against transcend than that?

[WhyMafia]

Catching up

Fourtrouble, why should we lynch transcend?

Voting mod-confirmed town is scummy. It's similar to self-voting but much worse, much more pro-scum, because while a self-vote might lead to a meaningful wagon on yourself, voting mod-confirmed town leads to nothing, because mod-confirmed town isn't ever getting lynched. There's no possibility of deriving anything meaningful from Transcend's vote and that itself is scummy, it obscures his motives.

this is gross
Lynching transcend is like the easiest wagon
In addition, it's probably a joke vote? I think any player would realize voting a mod confirmed town is completely pointless. Considering it was RVS and the first post in the game, I don't think anything a player posts at that point in the game would have a motive
FoS

[WhyMafia]

Roses are red,
Violets are blue.
Four is town
Egg is too.

Roses are red,
Violets are blue.
Gamma isn't.
That's the vote I shall do.

VOTE: Gamma Emerald

Reasoning?

[WhyMafia]

How so?

waste of tempo explaining that

?

[Lapsa]

@penguin could you tell in your own words what you see in that quote?

the entirety. it's unnecessary (the Transcend wagon is small); he regurgitates WhyMafia's reasoning for the votes (even though no reasoning for the votes has been stated); AND, it's

uncomely

.

I don't understand your thought process but I appreciate the effort

[WhyMafia]

I don't know what that means but I'm just gonna assume no

Voting who the IC said he'd policy lynch when there's other decent votes on the table looks kinda shitty.

Agree with this

[WhyMafia]

Its less than 12 hours into the game, even if there are other "decent" votes on the table, i haven't seen enough of them to have much opinion. Especially with gamma being on V/LA till the 1st.

As far as things that look shitty, so does voting for the IC as your RVS vote but we all do shitty things sometimes.

For the record, i didnt vote mutton because the IC said they would policy lynch them. I voted them because i think their only 2 posts were annoying and it doesnt matter at this point in the game anyway other than info gathering. Its not like im a hammer.

Fair enough I suppose

[WhyMafia]

VOTE: whymafia

VOTE: whymafia

?
Are you trying to get a wagon on me to deflect off your scum bud?

[Lapsa]

Lapsa, crush's attitude towards transcend seems like someone who is thinking critically. He seems to genuinely be trying to determine transcend's alignment. And his conclusion doesn't seem like one that scum would push the way he is.

err... yeah. got weak townread on Crush at the moment

[WhyMafia]

Its less than 12 hours into the game, even if there are other "decent" votes on the table, i haven't seen enough of them to have much opinion. Especially with gamma being on V/LA till the 1st.

As far as things that look shitty, so does voting for the IC as your RVS vote but we all do shitty things sometimes.

For the record, i didnt vote mutton because the IC said they would policy lynch them. I voted them because i think their only 2 posts were annoying and it doesnt matter at this point in the game anyway other than info gathering. Its not like im a hammer.

ego is annoying to you?
saying that is pretty poo
in fact, your other two posts are just about me too
overexplaining, sheeping ic, forcing a case, cool
trying to get an easy mislynch as scum
I'm not some homeless bum drunk on rum smelling like cum
I'm just your average townie being lynched by a fool
you flipping red will make me drool
if you had more posts perhaps they'd be fuel
for a case, but no, you're just a tool
me though? I'M not a tool, I rule
I am done derailing, but fr your team is failing

VOTE: lore

Oh god poetry

Do like his explanation though

[Egg]

@penguin could you tell in your own words what you see in that quote?

the entirety. it's unnecessary (the Transcend wagon is small); he regurgitates WhyMafia's reasoning for the votes (even though no reasoning for the votes has been stated); AND, it's

uncomely

.

I don't understand your thought process but I appreciate the effort

He sees my attack on the reasoning as a soft defense that could come from a buddy. It's actually kind of fair for someone who scum reads transcend and doesn't know my alignment.

[FourTrouble]

Lynching transcend is like the easiest wagon
In addition, it's probably a joke vote? I think any player would realize voting a mod confirmed town is completely pointless. Considering it was RVS and the first post in the game, I don't think anything a player posts at that point in the game would have a motive

The ease of a wagon has little to do with whether someone is scum. But the fact that you'd focus on a wagon's ease as opposed to the player's alignment, that's concerning.

Everyone has a motive for their posts, including RVS posts. Townies typically want to get out of RVS as quickly as they can, while scum don't really care how long RVS lasts, since they're just trying to avoid getting caught.

[Lapsa]

He sees my attack on the reasoning as a soft defense that could come from a buddy. It's actually kind of fair for someone who scum reads transcend and doesn't know my alignment.

got kinda similar results - hence the appreciation

for me it's easier - I remember very well us playing in same scum team

[FourTrouble]

Lapsa, crush's attitude towards transcend seems like someone who is thinking critically. He seems to genuinely be trying to determine transcend's alignment. And his conclusion doesn't seem like one that scum would push the way he is.

Where do you see him thinking critically about Transcend? The way I read it, Crush's posts assume Transcend is town and work from there.

[WhyMafia]

Reading through, and oh my goodness, Gamma really seems scummy this game.

I think it's the exclamation point.

Really an exclamation point makes you scumread me? How would you prefer I wrote it? The exclamation point adds a specific tone I was aiming for.

A case of overreaction. This post felt really unnecessary, as most of us likely know what you were trying to get across to begin with. Maybe it just felt "a little forced". More on that after the next quote.

Lame entrance. Feels a bit forced.
VOTE: platinum

This was kinda just more so rude than anything. A post just saying hello is just a post saying hello. I know this is Mafia and all, but this early in the game, we barely know each other. It's almost as if you're just looking for a reason to try and lynch someone to save your behind for a night.

I don't like either pmyst's or gamma's reaction to lapsa being confirmed town. Pmyst commenting on it being "quick" feels like he wasn't happy about it. Gamma is the exact opposite, seeming to exaggarate his happiness. It's weird how both initially took pisskop's "always town" comment so seriously too. Both players have made a post I liked though (26 and 33).

Fourtrouble, why should we lynch transcend?

And why does pmyst feel town?

(I see you retracted that)

Not a fan of pisskop buddying to ABR.

Tchill, why the naked vote on transcend?

Whymafia is coming off nervous, but also noticed a couple of the same things I did.

Gamma, what is forced about saying hi?

Theta, care to elaborate on your "reasons"?

Texcat, why don't you seem happy with a confirmed town?

Vote Gamma

Why are you asking me what's forced about it? Fifth Amendment bitch!
I was happy to start what seemed like an exciting game.

Well, this seems like another case of an overreaction. Plus, pleading Fifth Amendment in a game of Mafia really doesn't work.

I'm no expert at Mafia, but overreacting to people voting you or asking you questions of this type really does not scream town at all. That, and the completely jerkish move against someone who just wanted to say "hi" really doesn't help favors.

My vote against you was originally an RV, but now I'm sticking to my guns and saying that you are most definitely scum. My vote on you stays, unless you can convince me otherwise. So, please do tell, what reason do you have on a simple "hi" being so forced?

Really like this post
Reasoning that I could follow and understand. It also makes sense to me

[WhyMafia]

VOTE: transcend

on board

Yet you also thought gamma was scum? Nice chainsaw defense

[Lapsa]

The ease of a wagon has little to do with whether someone is scum. But the fact that you'd focus on a wagon's ease as opposed to the player's alignment, that's concerning.

good thing is that he's discrediting himself. if he is a scum - won't be capable of steering town into oblivion

[Lexa]

Transcend isn't spammy enough to be town

but his vote also wasn't a cause to scum read him

Unvote

VOTE: Gamma Emerald

this looks like fun

[Lapsa]

Really like this post
Reasoning that I could follow and understand. It also makes sense to me

PMysterious's timing sucks on that one