Open 688: Diffusion of Power (Game Over)

[MuttonChopMagic]

so why was he your strongest town read
that's the info we need

[Cooperative Sheep]

I can provide you the usual list of empty comments when asked about town reads, though I fail to see how they'll help, but here;

Looked like he was trying to game solve.
Didn't feel opportunistic.
Vibed town to me.
The points against him were few and those that existed sucked.
Yadda yadda.

I mean, there's absolutely nothing in my Day 1 that suggests I didn't town read him, as I only called him town and defended him, but even a semi-competent scum player would have the same. But all of this info is useless to you, so I guess blow me away with what you're doing with it (as you only ask me for it and no one else, which makes me question your motives).

[MuttonChopMagic]

yea sheep is just scum
powerlynch away buds

[Hellfire Missile]

yea sheep is just scum
powerlynch away buds

2/6 not rhymed


would not play again

[MuttonChopMagic]

yes, it's a slant rhyme
good luck next time

[NotTheRealPaul]

yea sheep is just scum
powerlynch away buds

I dont see it. I stared at his iso and the only thing I can see as coming off as kinda scum is his initial arona push, but that was such a stupid push that I dont think scum would try it and stick with it.

[MuttonChopMagic]

I can provide you the usual list of empty comments when asked about town reads, though I fail to see how they'll help, but here;

Looked like he was trying to game solve.
Didn't feel opportunistic.
Vibed town to me.
The points against him were few and those that existed sucked.
Yadda yadda.

I mean, there's absolutely nothing in my Day 1 that suggests I didn't town read him, as I only called him town and defended him, but even a semi-competent scum player would have the same. But all of this info is useless to you, so I guess blow me away with what you're doing with it (as you only ask me for it and no one else, which makes me question your motives).

okay let me explain why this post is horse shit
I asked BOTH Alban and sparkles why they chose who they thought would bite the bullet
so clearly that point is a lie
I don't only ask you, not even close my guy
I also asked you yesterday and you ignored the question
but anyways let's move on since you'll just claim to not be invested

"I can provide you the usual list of empty comments when asked about town reads, though I fail to see how they'll help"
there's 0 chance you're daft enough to not know how to explain a town read and well
even if you can't you're questioning the benefit which is fucked
I would wager people in rome know the benefit of convincing people someone is town bruh

"I mean, there's absolutely nothing in my Day 1 that suggests I didn't town read him, as I only called him town and defended him,

but even a semi-competent scum player would have the same

"
um, so theres two ways to interpret this and both from your end are still lame
so firstly, the bolded is you slipping that you're scum and any competent scum would defend gamma...
lol. the second and more realistic is you saying any competent scum could look the same level of town gamma did, drama
except for the small detail that gamma is your strongest town read
and you didn't even attempt to justify that, neat
now, let's look at the first line
you're basically bragging about your crime
okay... nothing suggests you didn't town read him... and somehow that makes it obvious he's your strongest town read and who you protected?
this is more bullshit than when Theresa May gets reelected
if hes your strongest town read you better have more justification than this
your case, your posting, your entire game is piss
I backed off you yesterday because comm was being a dork
but I regret it and am going to avenge him by impaling you with my pitchfork

[Cooperative Sheep]

Your rebuttal doesn't explain scum intent on my part even if I had been meaning the things you're saying I meant.. Here's my quick rebuttal to your rebuttal;

1. You only asked Sparkles (never Alban) and you never got an answer out of Sparkles - so, yeah, I don't think you were actually targeting either of them, or are at least faking.
1a. I don't recall you asking me to explain my townread yesterday, my bad if I missed it. Vaguely think I didn't though.

2. I agree I know how to explain a town read - I actually did it, so I don't get your whine here.

3. The bold is clearly describing myself - as saying that about Gamma makes no sense, but even if I *was* saying that about Gamma it wouldn't magically invalidate my other reasons even if I, for some reason, thought both.

What's your read on Hellfire?

[Cooperative Sheep]

Went back and looked, all I see from you yesterday is asking me to explain a scum read on Comm (which I did...apparently to the point of convincing you)
and you refusing to explain a town read (even though anyone can do it). So...nah, your case on me is derp.

Talk to me about Hellfire.

[MuttonChopMagic]

{NJAC, Lunae}
{Gamma Emerald, alban, NotTheRealPaul}
{Cooperative Sheep, aronagrundy, MuttonChopMagic} <---Null/undecided
{}
{Creature, Hellfire Missile}
{Sesq, CommKnight}

why did you tr njac that strongly

maybe, but I wouldn't go that far
that play wouldn't really be a star
I scumread sheep separately and gamma was not a viable kill
no clue why hed be docced in the first place still
sheep will probably come up with some b.s. though
he wouldn't have faked with gamma if he couldn't bro

[MuttonChopMagic]

"2. I agree I know how to explain a town read - I actually did it, so I don't get your whine here."

no. you buzzworded. try again peer.

[MuttonChopMagic]

"1. You only asked Sparkles (never Alban) and you never got an answer out of Sparkles - so, yeah, I don't think you were actually targeting either of them, or are at least faking.
1a. I don't recall you asking me to explain my townread yesterday, my bad if I missed it. Vaguely think I didn't though."

has sparkles come back to the thread yet? no

[MuttonChopMagic]

just checked, didnt I guess I didn't ask Alban after all
however, creature is lock town + one of you and sparkles has to be scum for alban to be so play ball

[MuttonChopMagic]

"3. The bold is clearly describing myself - as saying that about Gamma makes no sense, but even if I *was* saying that about Gamma it wouldn't magically invalidate my other reasons even if I, for some reason, thought both."

so it's describing yourself. you scum slipped. nice bro.

[MuttonChopMagic]

town!hellfire
that read is higher

[LunaeCinere]

Guys
Alban is very clearly trying to avoid the 3 doc claim situation. This suggests he has a very large stake in making sure he or another in the pool isn't lynched. I'd rather vote him since it's very clear he is scum no matter whether one of the other claimed docs is.

Why do you believe Alban has to be scum? Sure, he's not trying to "sort" in N1 docs; I mean, it's possible all three of them are town, right? Sure, he may have doubted it, but that's no reason to prioritise it in particular. You're considering one thing about Alban, but you're not really considering the whole picture here. For example; what is Alban's scum motivation to claim doc here? Sure, maybe he has a buddy in Co-op Sheep and Agent, but why would he claim in order to try to save either of them?

Guys
Alban is very clearly trying to avoid the 3 doc claim situation. This suggests he has a very large stake in making sure he or another in the pool isn't lynched. I'd rather vote him since it's very clear he is scum no matter whether one of the other claimed docs is.

So you're saying that because he's not currently voting in the Doc pool, that makes him scum? How?
VOTE: Gamma Emerald
This is subject to changing but I'm happy to vote here for now.

[Hellfire Missile]

I'd love to know how much time mutton spends trying to make his posts rhyme

[MuttonChopMagic]

this may surprise you but I actually spend relatively little
I ghostwrite professionally, my rhymes on ms are often low effort shitholes

[Hellfire Missile]

this may surprise you but I actually spend relatively little
I ghostwrite professionally, my rhymes on ms are often low effort shitholes

this makes me sad.

[Almost50]

VC 2.02

Gamma Emerald

(3): Creature, alban, LunaeCinere,

Cooperative Sheep

(2): MuttonChopMagic, aronagrundy,

alban

(2): Sesq, Gamma Emerald,

Creature

(1): Agent Sparkles,

Hellfire Missile

(1): Cooperative Sheep,

Not Voting

(3): NotTheRealPaul, Hellfire Missile, NJAC,
With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline

: (expired on 2017-06-18 18:00:00)
*Comm V/LA till June, 10th

[Cooperative Sheep]

"2. I agree I know how to explain a town read - I actually did it, so I don't get your whine here."

no. you buzzworded. try again peer.

I did, but I actually think that's how townreads tend to always look when described.
Tell you what, you do one for Hellfire in the style you'd like to see me use, and then I'll do one for Gamma in that style.

"1. You only asked Sparkles (never Alban) and you never got an answer out of Sparkles - so, yeah, I don't think you were actually targeting either of them, or are at least faking.
1a. I don't recall you asking me to explain my townread yesterday, my bad if I missed it. Vaguely think I didn't though."

has sparkles come back to the thread yet? no

Okay...he actually did come back after you asked the question, and you didn't re-ask the question, but maybe you were waiting for him to come back yet again - my bad.

just checked, didnt I guess I didn't ask Alban after all
however, creature is lock town + one of you and sparkles has to be scum for alban to be so play ball

Yeah, I know - but you made such a big deal out of me being a liar...so...does this change your read on me at all?
Or are you just working an angle here and not scumhunting?

Why does one of the Docs *have* to be scum? We could all be town last I checked - what do you know that I don't about that?

"3. The bold is clearly describing myself - as saying that about Gamma makes no sense, but even if I *was* saying that about Gamma it wouldn't magically invalidate my other reasons even if I, for some reason, thought both."

so it's describing yourself. you scum slipped. nice bro.

I don't see the slip, please describe it?

town!hellfire
that read is higher

Is this how town reads are described?

[MuttonChopMagic]

"2. I agree I know how to explain a town read - I actually did it, so I don't get your whine here."

no. you buzzworded. try again peer.

I did, but I actually think that's how townreads tend to always look when described.
Tell you what, you do one for Hellfire in the style you'd like to see me use, and then I'll do one for Gamma in that style.

"1. You only asked Sparkles (never Alban) and you never got an answer out of Sparkles - so, yeah, I don't think you were actually targeting either of them, or are at least faking.
1a. I don't recall you asking me to explain my townread yesterday, my bad if I missed it. Vaguely think I didn't though."

has sparkles come back to the thread yet? no

Okay...he actually did come back after you asked the question, and you didn't re-ask the question, but maybe you were waiting for him to come back yet again - my bad.

just checked, didnt I guess I didn't ask Alban after all
however, creature is lock town + one of you and sparkles has to be scum for alban to be so play ball

Yeah, I know - but you made such a big deal out of me being a liar...so...does this change your read on me at all?
Or are you just working an angle here and not scumhunting?

Why does one of the Docs *have* to be scum? We could all be town last I checked - what do you know that I don't about that?

"3. The bold is clearly describing myself - as saying that about Gamma makes no sense, but even if I *was* saying that about Gamma it wouldn't magically invalidate my other reasons even if I, for some reason, thought both."

so it's describing yourself. you scum slipped. nice bro.

I don't see the slip, please describe it?

town!hellfire
that read is higher

Is this how town reads are described?

I don't want to describe my townread on hellfire
I'm not the one who claimed to protect someone who'd never be killed, my situation isn't dire
gamma was your strongest town read, you should have specific things that made you think that
otherwise, the read is shat
no, sparkles didn't come back other than a prodge
stop trying to dodge
I appreciate you constantly shading me in your replies though
discrediting at the source is a strong scum tell bro
all of the docs could be town, yes
but you aren't, so bless

[MuttonChopMagic]

I can provide you the usual list of empty comments when asked about town reads, though I fail to see how they'll help, but here;

Looked like he was trying to game solve.
Didn't feel opportunistic.
Vibed town to me.
The points against him were few and those that existed sucked.
Yadda yadda.

I mean, there's absolutely nothing in my Day 1 that suggests I didn't town read him, as I only called him town and defended him, but even a semi-competent

scum

player would have the same. But all of this info is useless to you, so I guess blow me away with what you're doing with it (as you only ask me for it and no one else, which makes me question your motives).

[Hellfire Missile]

I can provide you the usual list of empty comments when asked about town reads, though I fail to see how they'll help, but here;

Looked like he was trying to game solve.
Didn't feel opportunistic.
Vibed town to me.
The points against him were few and those that existed sucked.
Yadda yadda.

I mean, there's absolutely nothing in my Day 1 that suggests I didn't town read him, as I only called him town and defended him, but even a semi-competent

scum

player would have the same. But all of this info is useless to you, so I guess blow me away with what you're doing with it (as you only ask me for it and no one else, which makes me question your motives).

can you enlarge it? I can't see it.

[Cooperative Sheep]

I don't want to describe my townread on hellfire
I'm not the one who claimed to protect someone who'd never be killed, my situation isn't dire
gamma was your strongest town read, you should have specific things that made you think that
otherwise, the read is shat
no, sparkles didn't come back other than a prodge
stop trying to dodge
I appreciate you constantly shading me in your replies though
discrediting at the source is a strong scum tell bro
all of the docs could be town, yes
but you aren't, so bless

How about you quote me from another one of your games, or even any random player in ANY game - their description of a town read so I know what you're saying you want/need?
Since you are being obstinate and scummy.

I'll agree I'm throwing shade on you, but it's super valid shade that you could easily counter if you were town and being honest...so, why aren't you?

I'll agree that if we ignore when Sparkles came back that he hasn't come back.
You ducked my question about you calling me a liar and then me pointing out that I wasn't.

The slip - you failed to explain that too.