Mini Normal 1917: :X Mafia (Game over!)

[Gamma Emerald]

I just feel your posts have a scummy tone for some reason

[MuttonChopMagic]

considering I'm you're strongest read that's a little weak no?
where does my tone look scummy? I'd still expect more for your strongest scum read though

[Gamma Emerald]

None of my scumread are strong rn
I'm p much in the same boat as Grendel with reads

[Hiraki]

oh i thought there were three gamma posts

that's cool

MCM - how do you feel about DRK's postings? mostly asking you this since you're probably here

[Hiraki]

THANK YOU GAMMA

[Gamma Emerald]

I only changed my avatar because I wanted to join the Chikorita avatar cult

[MuttonChopMagic]

oh i thought there were three gamma posts

that's cool

MCM - how do you feel about DRK's postings? mostly asking you this since you're probably here

gonna wait for him to catch up completely first, try not to forget
but he seems to have the exact same reads as me, not sure how to read into that yet

[CCC]

Paul is probably a PR SW

He softed that right?

I still SR him, but he's not a lynch for today.

I am in complete agreement with this stance.

[CCC]

I'm giving up on you

What are your current reads?

[CCC]

CCC :

Oh Im trying something new this game

It wasnt speocifically for you. Maybe I screwed up the wording and you thought that. It was an open question to everyone.

At the end of a post full of replies to me? I didn't particularly anyone else answering your question, maybe everyone thought as I did?

Do you find it sus that waffles' SRs are "safe" SRs? Theyre both SR by others, and waffles even agrees on lynchpool. Curious because of your SR on GE for similar reasons.

Not really, no.

Gamma Emerald strikes me as suspicious on two fronts - firstly, the top and bottom of his readslist looks almost exactly like my previously posted one, with just a few names muddled in the middle. Secondly, he couldn't explain his townread on Cheetory when asked.

Waffle's reads, on the other hand, are

vastly

different to mine. I'm Townreading Backhand, I know I'm Town, I'm scumreading Gamma, Hiraki and Nero are kindof null... the only read that I agree with Waffles on is that you are Mafia. I'm not sure if Waffles is copying anyone else, but he's certainly not copying me.

And also VOTE: Gamma He was kinda a scumread for me earlier and Im gonna trust CCC here. That said if someone could explain the backhand case, Im willing to switch votes

...the fact that one of my top two scumreads is voting for the other is a bit concerning. But we're still a long way from a lynch, so I guess it's not

too

risky to be bussing your scumbuddy right now... or perhaps one or the other of you is actually Town.

Hmmmmmmm.

[CCC]

I don't remember what read I promised I would explain anymore ;-; help

You did at one point say you would cover your read on Backhand.

[CCC]

Page 11
CCC posted a lot. It all seemed fine but unexciting from what was mostly a skim, though I must say I enjoyed his MCM impersonation.

Thank you, I wasn't sure if anyone would notice that.

Page 15
It definitely feels like CCC has talked about "scared" vs "sacred" a lot. Does it just feel like that because I'm reading all of these pages at once? Is it at all alignment-indicative if it's true? I don't know! I guess probably not!! Who has time for thinking when they have a billion pages to read!!!

It's very important to be clear and unambiguous in such matters.

This vote has my attention in a bad way. I should probably reread page 14 more closely to get a better grasp of context, but letting NTRP off this easily in order to vote for someone for not yet posting after replacing in definitely fits the narrative I was considering.

His previous vote wasn't on Paul. It was on MuttonChopMagic.

Ooookay, NTRP softed preeeetttty hard. Also, I wish CCC wouldn't make so many separate posts. It causes things to happen, like 17 pages popping up since I last posted anything useful.

I

do

tend to try to reply to one person at a time when catching up. I'm not sure that consolidating it all in one post would be any better, though - just as much to read, but bunched into fewer pages.

Page 16
Why are multiple people suggesting running someone up to teach them that softing a PR isn't good wtf

It's a bad thing for NTRP to have done in that situation as town regardless of whether or not he gets run up. And beginners probably don't usually soft PRs at 1 vote as scum anyway so...???


People I am referring to are MCM and CCC.

In context:

I had NotTheRealPaul as my top scumread. Then I saw that he had softed a PR and was reluctant to put my vote on him, just in case he

was

a PR after all.

MCM raised the very reasonable point that, at seven votes to lynch, there was absolutely nothing wrong with putting even a potential PR on three votes, if he was already being scumread. Since NTRP was

still

my top scumread, I agreed with this point, and placed my vote.

The intention was never to teach him that softing a PR isn't good. The intention was not to let myself be too controlled by a vague, unsubstantiated claim that's almost impossible to falsify, and rather to vote for the person I felt most likely to be Mafia.

A little meh about this (having such a specific condition on posting is kind of strange and an easy excuse, in theory at least) but I suspect that's not so relevant 12 pages later.

He did post his reads later, yes. They were a pretty good copy of my previously posted reads.

Page 17
This followed by this two posts later is also ???

It is rather, yes. I did not take nearly enough notice of this at the time.

I think I've lost focus. I might finish reading today but hold off on being *actually useful* until tomorrow. Bite me. (Don't actually bite me pls)

I hope you come back and catch up with brilliant focus! Bonus points if you identify the entire scumteam.

[CCC]

MuttonChopMagic - could you please not use the same avatar as Gamma Emerald? It makes reading through the thread very annoying.

[Nero Cain]

Sorry for being a bit inactive. I wasn't feeling too well yesterday.

[NotTheRealPaul]

Sorry for being a bit inactive. I wasn't feeling too well yesterday.

Dont think anyone is gonna be mad at you for not posting given Not_Mafia's play so far.

@CCC Looks like a misunderstanding. Will try to be more clear next time.

[Grendel]

Hey guys, I'm distracted by other things right now. I'll be back tomorrow (Saturday).

[Cheetory6]

I refuse to give excuses for my shitty play this game because I don't need validation unlike the rest of these losers.

[SlingshotWaffles]

I refuse to give excuses for my shitty play this game because I don't need validation unlike the rest of these losers.

VOTE: Cheet

I am not a looser.

[MuttonChopMagic]

deadline is in a bit over 4 days
prodge, hurray

[Cheetory6]

Okay let's play a game, it's called.
Why is Penguin scum or why is Penguin town?
And if you don't take a side then you're being antitown.
Okay?
Cool.

I think Penguin is scum because their content so far is essentially just trying to fit into the jokeyness that's been presented so far in an awkward way without having taken any real stances on anything and just kind of flopping around.
Klick's play in the earlygame had vibes of someone trying to seem like they had something going on underneath the surface in a showy way and he seemed overly worried about how he was being perceived.
If you disagree, fight me and with specific words why. Thanks in advance.

[Cheetory6]

Oh also nobody has joined me yet.
And I think lazy scum would have jumped on board my push if it was town I was pushing so.

[Backhand]

Yeah, I can see that. Its still absurd that we aren't just going to kill Not_Mafia, but if we get close to deadline, that would be a fine choice.

[Cheetory6]

Also jesus, one of mutton or gamma please switch your avatar.

P-Edit: Why are you wanting to kill Not_Mafia?
Explain it to me like I'm stupid.

[Gamma Emerald]

I read PP as town
The tone of the quicklynch suggestion didn't feel scummy

[Gamma Emerald]

suggestion by Klick*