Mini 113:Peril in Per-Djehuty (Game Over)

[MeMe]

I still think that Argoti could be a prime suspect.

I, too, think Argoti could be mafia...but he's

not

a prime suspect. At best, he's a secondary suspect as it's impossible for him to be scum if big_k isn't also scum.

[MeMe]

Um...yo?

vote: big_kahunia

Let's see what happens.

[mlaker]

Found an internet cafe so I'll probably be able to check in.

[big_kahunia]

My vote stays. Since with three masons, two medics and most likely two scum left, BlueSin and MeMe have to be scum.

That is not a bullish conclusion. The fit BlueSin and MeMe had at the start could be the same strategy MeMe played in PB's black and blue mafia when MeMe sacrificed blackhawk day1. Let's think about it, the two players disassociate from each other (a good scum tactic) and publicly set themselves against each other. MeMe lead that game as she is leading this game. I just hope we don't let the wool get pulled over our eyes.

[MeMe]

The lack of posts is really starting to bug me.

[Argoti]

I know... Lets get the dy over, lynch BlueSin, do something besides make saying "You're Scum" "No, You're Scum" back and forth.

BTG... if I was scum with big_k... and Meme/The rest are telling the truth, explain the lack of a sk kill night one.

I still think Blue and big_k are scum, but it could as easily be Blue and MeMe.

[big_kahunia]

I would have to agree, let's lynch someone since it is better than the "You're scum" war.
Also, my reference to PolarBoy's game was incorrect. It is "Black and

white

" mafia and is mini 76.

To encourage voting, maybe a deadline should be given.

[MeMe]

Alright. I'm weary enough just to get on with it.

unvote: big_k
vote: Blue

[BeyondTheGame]

Alright I think I'll be the one to nail the coffin on this one... so

Vote: Blue
Reason: The role claim was a little too inconvient considering he annouced the person who was the cop in his PM was Namarian but never said it till the next day where it was no point..

Hopefully this works out..

[BeyondTheGame]

Oops wrong code

Vote: Blue

[BlueSin]

sigh...B_K is probably scum. Trust me. I didn't say it until narn was killed to protect him. a proved cop is an easy target for scum.
Please give me a chance to say something before placing the last vote. thanks.

vote B_K

[MeMe]

According to my count, BTG's vote was #4 (the last) -- so if you've got something to say that could help us, Blue, please say it quick before night falls.

[MeMe]

Well that's weird...Thoth posted in Mish Mash but didn't close this game. Either my count's wrong or Blue doesn't get lynched at four.

Mod? Could we have an official count?

[BlueSin]

I will wait for the mod count. If I'm lynched already, I choose not to reveal anything pass down by Narn. .|.

[MeMe]

Blue - that's the second time you've refused to share information that could benefit us....but the FIRST time you've claimed to have passed down information from Narninian. Basically, you're saying that you know for a fact whether or not Narninian investigated me & found me innocent (as I've reasoned). Since you're already out as a back-up cop -- it's just play ridiculous that you wouldn't either 1) denounce my theory or 2) uphold my theory if you knew the facts.

A true cop would want the town to benefit from his knowledge. Since you seem hell-bent on sitting on what you claim to know until it's too late for any good to come of it, I'd say it's pretty definite you're lying.

[MeMe]

I've just PM'd Thoth to make sure he's paying attention to the thread...I'll let you know when/if he picks it up.

I just went through the votes again, and I'm sure they are as follows:

BlueSin

(4) - big_kahunia, Argoti, MeMe, BeyondTheGame

big_kahunia

(2) - gashlycrumb, BlueSin (though Blue placed his vote "late" -- after BTG put the final vote on Blue)

[Thoth]

I'm very sorry all. My son had over 39 degrees fever during the weekend and he just kept me occupied continuously (with my wife in China of course). I managed to get online a minute Saturday, but he immediately woke up.
He's fine again now btw with me sitting like a dead bird at work.

Todays's final vote count

BlueSin 4 (big_kahunia, Argoti, MeMe, beyondthegame)
big_kahunia 2 (gashlycrumb, BlueSin)

The town gathers around BlueSin. He protests, proclaiming his innocence, but the rest of the town will have none of that and he's quickly dragged to the nearest tree for a very smooth hanging.

BlueSin (Mafia) was lynched.

It's now Night 4. Night will end Thursday 9AM (CET). Earlier if I have all choices before that.

[Thoth]

It had taken mlaker a while to find his family back. Now he would make sure never to lose sight of them again. Just getting an icecream should be no problem though, or so he thought. Unfortunately for him someone else thought different about this. As soon as mlaker stepped around the corner he caught a bullet to the side of his head.

mlaker (lost brother) was shot.

Day 4 has started.

PS:
Thanks to everyone for the good wishes. Unfortunately my son's fever returned, but as he has no other symptoms whatsoever it really looks like there's nothing. My wife's taking him to the doctor today, just to make sure though. Glad she's back. It's a lot easier to take care of a sick child when you're with 2.

[Argoti]

Okay, so we're pretty much down to 1 mafia.

I protected BTG last night. From my view, we're down to MeMe and big_K as POSSIBLE mafia, with big_k the most likely. I know, I can also be thought of as Mafia, but meh, whatever.

Gut Instinct tells me to hold my vote though.

[MeMe]

Argoti - you

could

be possible mafia...but as I've been pointing out for a while now, it's impossible for you to be mafia without big_k as a partner because he'd be a back-up for no one.

vote: big_kahunia

He was my investigation last night. I didn't expect to get anything but an innocent result, but my time & hard work on the force is paying off and I'm getting better at my job:

big_kahunia is evil

. Oh...yes.

Even if you are skeptical, consider these points:
1) Everyone who's died so far has had an active game role
2) Everyone who's still alive has claimed an active game role -- except for big_k, who claims to be a back-up
3) Of those alive, big_k was the last to claim -- obviously waiting to see what would "fit"
4) If we have two scum left, we're in a lynch right or lose situation...and the scum MUST include big_k (either me & him or Argoti & him)
5) If we have just one scum left, it's either me or big_k, but lynching him is

still

the better idea, just in case there are two (and you can kill me tomorrow -- with just one scum left a bad lynch still results in a tomorrow)
6) Norinel believed me to be innocent (indicating he investigated me)

[Argoti]

Well, with 5 it's 3 to lynch... and big k has been scum in my eyes since the back up claim.

Vote: Big_Kahunia

Here's hoping we're right.

[big_kahunia]

With five alive, that would make three to lynch. I have two votes. So thank you town for giving a chance to speak.

Isn't it convenient that MeMe

now

gets a guilty result.

Even if you are skeptical, consider these points:
1) Everyone who's died so far has had an active game role
2) Everyone who's still alive has claimed an active game role -- except for big_k, who claims to be a back-up
3) Of those alive, big_k was the last to claim -- obviously waiting to see what would "fit"
4) If we have two scum left, we're in a lynch right or lose situation...and the scum MUST include big_k (either me & him or Argoti & him)
5) If we have just one scum left, it's either me or big_k, but lynching him is still the better idea, just in case there are two (and you can kill me tomorrow -- with just one scum left a bad lynch still results in a tomorrow)
6) Norinel believed me to be innocent (indicating he investigated me)

1. Just because all those who died had active roles, doesn't mean we don't have an inactive one.
2. Thoth used my back-up role to balance the game since I’m the only back-up and not many would believe me.
3. I was the

first

to claim when we all did the mass role-claim. Being forced to reveal one's role because of bandwagoning does not denote skill. One could use logic to turn the tables in order to evade a role claim. Just remember that I was open to help the town with my claim.
4. Most present minis have

3

mafia and an sk. Since two have been lynched, I am almost certain we are down to one. In our case, it seems to down to MeMe and myself. Notice how MeMe used to point to heap more suspicion on me.
5. Either way as MeMe has said, we at worst get another shot at a lynch.
6. Narninian* never said concretely one way or the other whether you were innocent or guilty.
*I know you meant Narninian and not Norinel.

Now though, let’s consider who was killed last night: mlaker. Notice how mlaker and MeMe went after each other earlier in the game. With MeMe needing someone someone to frame (myself), she didn’t killed me, but mlaker not only since he was a mason but to get a little revenge.

vote: MeMe

I won’t bring BlueSin’s second to last post since that would result in an endless battle of reverse psychology of who he was trying to frame.

[MeMe]

Most mini games have 3 mafia and 1 SK, true.

Most mini games, however, do

not

have a super-strong town in the form of 3 masons, a doc & a backup, a vigilante, and 2 cops (as your theory would stipulate)...so I'm not willing to wager that we're absolutely down to 1 scum quite yet and I'm hoping that gashly & BTG won't take that chance either.

Remaining, we either have

:
2 masons, 1 cop, and 2 scum
2 masons, 1 cop, 1 doc, and 1 scum

Just remember, folks...big_kahunia is the smart lynch because:
--If we have

two

scum left, big_kahunia is

definitely

one of them
--If we have

one

scum left, it's either me or big_k & it's an inevitable scum loss either today or tomorrow.

[BeyondTheGame]

Well.. both Big Kahunia and MeMe have made some good points.. at this point of time I'm going to lay off on my vote in order to give Gashly a chance to have some form of input...

I can say though I do find myself leaning towards that Big Kahunia is scum.. once again the back up doc role is a little too convient... Argoti not been killed at this time does give resonable cover to the person/ people left in Mafia.. it is really strange cause I know if I was Mafia I would have killed Argoti early as possible.. However Argoti could be used here as a way to maintain cover...

Also the comment on mlaker and MeMe been caught up in quite a heated discussion.. to me dosn't provide much meaning.. that discussion had been going on for a while and if MeMe didn't like mlaker and was Mafia she would have killed him long ago... Better to have someone against you dead..

I'm going to say the reason why the Mafia or Big Kahunia did choose.. mlaker..
1. By killing mlaker it allows Mafia to point out the MeMe point... Thus making MeMe look like mafia
2. Takes out the Mason group as they won't have the telling votes..

Finally, I'm inclined to go with MeMe on this one.. but I will leave my vote off till Gashly posts..

[Argoti]

I think they have not killed me to make me look suspicious. They've also been lucky with their kills in that I haven't protected the right people... Except for BlueSin Night 1.