Night and Day Mafia (Game Over)

[Ginngie]

How is it a stretch?

[Vedith]

Because you ignore Titus's point.
This is what happened (as clear as can be)

Rauth makes a vote while not posting in dark or game
Titus reads that as scum and votes
Aronis shows scum tells / case on Aronis makes sense
Titus has scum read on Aronis and votes

By default Aronis and Rauth are both scum.

Logical reason for Rauth voting Aronis - bussing.

[Ginngie]

Did Titus have a scum read on Aronis before voting Rauth yes or no? (hint the answer is no)

[Vedith]

Did Titus have a scum read on Aronis before voting Rauth yes or no? (hint the answer is no)

That doesn't change what I just said though.

Titus isn't saying that she scum reads both together because they are both scum or do scummy things together, but by default they are scum together.

It's 2 seperate scum reads with a logical assumption to Rauth's action.

I don't understand what you are getting at here?

[Ginngie]

Titus votes Rauth and says Rauth is bussing Aronis, but doesn't have a read on Aronis.

How is that not clearly contradictory.

[Ginngie]

I ask you, how can Titus judge sayinng two people are scum together and one is bussing the other when only ONE read exists?

[Vedith]

Titus votes Rauth and says Rauth is bussing Aronis, but doesn't have a read on Aronis.

How is that not clearly contradictory.

So you're a liar, Ginngie?
Good to know.

Titus actually calls Aronis town, then questions me to why Aronis is scum (after she votes Rauth).

Otherwise show me where she votes Rauth for the reason that Aronis is scum.

[Ginngie]

You've got to be fucking kidding me

[Vedith]

I ask you, how can Titus judge sayinng two people are scum together and one is bussing the other when only ONE read exists?

She has stated that they are scum at different times.
Anyone with a braincell can put 2 and 2 together.

Tell me, Ginngie, what's 2 + 2?

[Ginngie]

Titus is fucking voting Aronis

[Ginngie]

Are you reading the game

[Vedith]

Titus is fucking voting Aronis

Yes, I know.
Are you reading what I am saying?

It's proven that I know, as I said I will vote where Titus is and then vote Aronis.

[Vedith]

But Ginngie, the important question here is, what's 2 + 2?

[Ginngie]

You just said Titus was town reading Aronis

[Vedith]

You just said Titus was town reading Aronis

She was. Hence why I did say she is.

[Ginngie]

Okay wait a minute

[Vedith]

Wait, I was talking at work during that post - Let me try again

Hence why I said was, not is.

[Vedith]

Okay wait a minute

If you're working out my math question, no calculator please.

[Frosted Kelvin Bran]

I'd like to request that Vedith and Ginngie not take up an entire page for themselves arguing the same point back and forth.

I'd also like to state that, in this instance, Ginngie is not correct.

Titus expressed suspicion of Rauth's vote (and at the time did not believe it was bussing, due to a lack of read on Aronis).

Titus later felt that Aronis was also scummy due to later events.

Titus explains how both could be true (when asked by bulbazak) by saying that Rauth's vote, which was suspicious, could also be an attempt at bussing.

The flow of logic here is not suspicious or self-contradictory.

[Ginngie]

I know the feeling of work posting lol

P-edit: Dude I only have so many fingers

P-edit: LET ME POST IM RE READING

[Vedith]

You and Aronis are town.

VOTE: Rauthedir

Say hi to mama bear.

Prove he's scum.

VOTE: Aronis

Without going into detail, this is how reads progress.

[Frosted Kelvin Bran]

I am not arguing about whether Titus' suspicion of Aronis is well-founded. I don't think it is.

However, taking Titus' expressed suspicions at face value, there is no contradiction in the chain of events.

Bulbazak's main point of contention is feeling that Titus' reasoning for voting Aronis is weak and suspect.

I do not disagree, but 79 CE is still more suspicious / scummier / youradjectivehere.

[Vedith]

I do not disagree, but 79 CE is still more suspicious / scummier / youradjectiveher

Wagon built way too fast, CE is town.
However, if at L1 I will probably lol hammer as I've had my fill with you guys for today.

[Ginngie]

By the new look of it:
Aronis!town
Rauth!votes
Rauth!scum
Rauth!scumclaim
A conversation with FKB and votes Aronis
Aronis!scum
says bus vote

[Ginngie]

Wagon built way too fast, CE is town.

NAI

Spoiler:

Subject: Star Wars Rogue One [GAME OVER]

Vote Count 1.01

Pine [6] The Thinker, Aj the Epic, Infinity 324, Desperado, Heartless, PrettyPrincess
SirCakez [3] Drunken Piper, Aeronaut, alban
BBmolla [1] Pine-A-Tonics
ThinkBig [1] KuroiXHF
Infinity 324 [2] SirCakez, Titus
Desperado [1] BBmolla

Not Voting - [3] Klingoncelt, Lil Uzi Vert, Indigo

Rogue Leader Vote:

No one

Mod Notes - May the flavor be with you.

With 17 Alive, It Takes 9 To Lynch.

Day 1 ends in (expired on 2017-01-24 15:26:20)!

Pine-A-Tonics was scum

ask Titus, she was there

as a matter of fact, if you read the first two pages, you'll see that scum was the first RVS vote and first wagon, then turned real for 3 vote counts straight, and those are Firebringer vote counts so you know some good time passed between them :3