Gamma Emerald's Large Normal Review

[Gamma Emerald]

The critical parts of the setup are the willbooster, JK, weak RB, and mafia RB.
About the tracker claiming early, would it be amenable that I make it so that willbooster stops one roleblock?
Also I was worried about scum power coming in to this. I'll remove the Bullletproof and see how it looks.
@Regfan lynches will be majority, thanks for noting that.
For roleblocker resolution I'll resolve the weak roleblocker first, then the mafia roleblocker (this is so there isn't a false innocent with the weak roleblocker), then the jaikeeper.
I've noted a few issues with the Tracker: should that be removed as well?

[Gamma Emerald]

Adding the note on deadlines and lynching and a possible NAR notation, as well as fixing some formatting in the playerlist post.

Welcome to Theatre Mafia!

Moderator: Gamma Emerald
Backup Moderator: inspectorscout
Reviewers: Cephrir, Regfan, RadiantCowbells

Living Players

Players

Dead Players

Players

Links

Day 1: Post #

Deadline

YYYY-mm-dd HH:MM:SS - 5.00

Vote Counter made by Thesp which I am using

The Rules

General

> Follow the site rules.
> I make the final call on whether a rule is broken. I may contact the listmods for more serious issues.
> Do not attempt to use moderator action to break the game. You will be sorry.
> Do not attempt to make me modkill a player. Leave that call to the proper authorities.
> Play to your win condition.
> Do not communicate with players outside the game unless your role permits it. Do not communicate about ongoing games in this game. I WILL BE STRICT ABOUT THIS RULE.
> Do not attempt to encrypt or otherwise hide information. Keep your font sizes above Tiny.
> Do not quote any information given to you by the moderator. Please paraphrase.
> If there is an error or concern, please post with "@Mod" in bold in the game or send me a PM.
> Players may Bah post, as long it does not affect the gamestate significantly.
> The color #FF8000, as well as the Georgia font, is MINE. Do not use it.
> Do not use proven randomness like the dice tags to make significant game decisions like lynches.
> I have the right to add any rules necessary.

Gameplay

> Day Phases will be 14 real life days. Night Phases will be 48 hours (2 days). Extensions will be granted in extreme cases.
> Inactivity for >48 hours will result in a prod. Players will have 24 hours to respond to the prod before being replaced. 3 prods with a lack of improvement will result in force replacement.
> Please post in bold that you will be V/LA or PM me. If someone is V/LA for the length of a Night I reserve the right to replace them.
>Please use the voting tags to vote, or the votecounter will not count your vote. To help, here is the BBCode for vote tags.

Code: Select all

[vote]Player[/vote]

Or

Code: Select all

[v]Player[/v]

Make sure to use the unvote tags when unvoting as well.

Code: Select all

[unvote]Player[/unvote]

Or

Code: Select all

[uv]Player[/uv]

Also make sure to spell the player's name right as best as possible. If I miss a vote please alert me the same way as if you had questions, or vote using the proper format.
> Lynches are decided by majority. If no majority is reached by deadline the day end with a no lynch.
> Players with night actions must submit their action as "Target Player". If no action is received No Action will be taken. You may also send a No Action PM.
> Mafia may send the kill and use personal actions.
> (possible note about how NAR will work)

Sample VT Role PM

Hello, and welcome to Large Normal XXX!
You are a

Vanilla Townie

. You have your voice and vote.
You win when all antitown roles are eliminated and at least 1 town player remains alive.

[Gamma Emerald]

New role list
1 Town Willbooster
1 Town Jailkeeper
1 Town Weak Roleblocker
1 Town Tracker
1 Town Vigilante
9 Vanilla Townies
VS
1 Mafia Roleblocker
1 Mafia Neapolitan
2 Mafia Goons

[Gamma Emerald]

Be aware that your planning assumes the roles are public in game, when they will not be.

[Gamma Emerald]

Will fix the Tracker PM btw

[Gamma Emerald]

1 Town Tracker

Hello, and welcome to Large Normal XXX!
You are a

Town Tracker

. You have your voice and vote. You may also target a player each night to discover who they visited in the night. You will get results in the form of "X visited Y", "X visited no one", or "No result".
You win when all antitown roles are eliminated and at least 1 town player remains alive.

[Gamma Emerald]

1 Town Willbooster

Hello, and welcome to Large Normal XXX!
You are a

Town Willbooster

. You have your voice and vote. You may also target a player each night to make them immune to one roleblock.
You win when all antitown roles are eliminated and at least 1 town player remains alive.

[Gamma Emerald]

Correct me if I'm wrong: willbooster doesn't prevent weak roleblocker from dying if they both visit the same, mafia-aligned target?

Correct.

[Gamma Emerald]

Can the same player submit the night kill + roleblock while other mafia members are alive. Can they do it if they're the last alive?

How are you using this.

I'll say no here. Is that something that should explicitly be stated in the rules?

[Gamma Emerald]

Thanks

[Gamma Emerald]

Fixed to OP. It said the opposite because I'm also working on a mini theme and I wrote up the rules for it and that was one of the rules and I forgot I had that.

The Rules

General

> Follow the site rules.
> I make the final call on whether a rule is broken. I may contact the listmods for more serious issues.
> Do not attempt to use moderator action to break the game. You will be sorry.
> Do not attempt to make me modkill a player. Leave that call to the proper authorities.
> Play to your win condition.
> Do not communicate with players outside the game unless your role permits it. Do not communicate about ongoing games in this game. I WILL BE STRICT ABOUT THIS RULE.
> Do not attempt to encrypt or otherwise hide information. Keep your font sizes above Tiny.
> Do not quote any information given to you by the moderator. Please paraphrase.
> If there is an error or concern, please post with "@Mod" in bold in the game or send me a PM.
> Players may Bah post, as long it does not affect the gamestate significantly.
> The color #FF8000, as well as the Georgia font, is MINE. Do not use it.
> Do not use proven randomness like the dice tags to make significant game decisions like lynches.
> I have the right to add any rules necessary.

Gameplay

> Day Phases will be 14 real life days. Night Phases will be 48 hours (2 days). Extensions will be granted in extreme cases.
> Inactivity for >48 hours will result in a prod. Players will have 24 hours to respond to the prod before being replaced. 3 prods with a lack of improvement will result in force replacement.
> Please post in bold that you will be V/LA or PM me. If someone is V/LA for the length of a Night I reserve the right to replace them.
>Please use the voting tags to vote, or the votecounter will not count your vote. To help, here is the BBCode for vote tags.

Code: Select all

[vote]Player[/vote]

Or

Code: Select all

[v]Player[/v]

Make sure to use the unvote tags when unvoting as well.

Code: Select all

[unvote]Player[/unvote]

Or

Code: Select all

[uv]Player[/uv]

Also make sure to spell the player's name right as best as possible. If I miss a vote please alert me the same way as if you had questions, or vote using the proper format.
> Lynches are decided by majority. If no majority is reached by deadline the day end with a no lynch.
> Players with night actions must submit their action as "Target Player". If no action is received No Action will be taken. You may also send a No Action PM.
> Mafia may not send the kill and use personal actions.
> (possible note about how NAR will work)

Sample VT Role PM

Hello, and welcome to Large Normal XXX!
You are a

Vanilla Townie

. You have your voice and vote.
You win when all antitown roles are eliminated and at least 1 town player remains alive.

[Gamma Emerald]

I'll see if Regfan agrees that it's sketchy. If so I'll make it so it renders the target immune to any abilities that would roleblock it, therefore making it completely unaffected by jailkeeper.
And FYI Willbooster WILL flip it's PM.

[Gamma Emerald]

The jailkeeper is kinda integral to the setup though

[Gamma Emerald]

Like
The setup is based around the multiple roleblocking roles
I could add a couple of ascetics and use a standard doctor

[Gamma Emerald]

I'll wait for RC's input before finalizing the change

[Gamma Emerald]

No input so I'll implement the change and see RC's thoughts after the fact.

[Gamma Emerald]

New role list
1 Town Willbooster
1 Town Non Consecutive Night Jailkeeper
1 Town Weak Roleblocker
1 Town Tracker
1 Town Vigilante
9 Vanilla Townies
VS
1 Mafia Roleblocker
1 Mafia Neapolitan
2 Mafia Goons

[Gamma Emerald]

1 Town Non Consecutive Night Jailkeeper

You are a

Town Non Consecutive Night Jailkeeper

. You have your voice and vote. You may also target a player on nights not consecutive to protect them from any kill attempts that night as well as prevent their action from executing.
You win when all antitown roles are eliminated and at least 1 town player remains alive.

[Gamma Emerald]

Thoughts?

[Gamma Emerald]

The Neapolitan would have to be nerfed if so because I'm not touching the RB

[Gamma Emerald]

Seems okay
With two saying nerf the neap I'll do that

[Gamma Emerald]

Oh btw inspectorscout has switched to Zaphkael so I'll be changing that in the OP

[Gamma Emerald]

New role list
1 Town Willbooster
1 Town Non Consecutive Night Jailkeeper
1 Town Weak Roleblocker
1 Town Tracker
1 Town Vigilante
9 Vanilla Townies
VS
1 Mafia Roleblocker
1 Mafia Odd Night Neapolitan
2 Mafia Goons

[Gamma Emerald]

1 Mafia Odd Night Neapolitan

Hello, and welcome to Large Normal XXX!
You are a

Mafia Odd Night Neapolitan

. You have your voice and vote. You also have a factional chat, located here, and a factional kill which you may send one person to do each night. You may also target a player each odd-numbered night to discover whether they are a Vanilla Townie or not. You will will get your results in the form of "X is Vanilla Town", "X is not Vanilla Town", or "No result".
You win when your team comprises 50 percent of all players or nothing can stop it.

Welcome to Theatre Mafia!

Moderator: Gamma Emerald
Backup Moderator: Zaphkael
Reviewers: Cephrir, RadiantCowbells, Regfan

Living Players

Players

Dead Players

Players

Links

Day 1: Post #

Deadline

YYYY-mm-dd HH:MM:SS - 5.00

Vote Counter made by Thesp which I am using

Sure I can do a full list of PMs too

[Gamma Emerald]

I'm back for now
I thought this got run without me
I'll ask Zaphkael if he's still good as a back-up

[Gamma Emerald]

Wait
I forgot I can't access the sub forums on my phone
I can still work on this but actually modding this will have to wait

[Gamma Emerald]

Okay I should be able to do this now
will do the full role list and PMs

[Gamma Emerald]

1 Town Willbooster

Hello, and welcome to Large Normal XXX!
You are a

Town Willbooster

. You have your voice and vote. You may also target a player each night to make them immune to one roleblock.
You win when all antitown roles are eliminated and at least 1 town player remains alive.

1 Town Weak Roleblocker

Hello, and welcome to Large Normal XXX!
You are a

Town Weak Roleblocker

. You have your voice and vote. You may also target a player each night to prevent their action from executing. However, if you target an antitown role you will die.
You win when all antitown roles are eliminated and at least 1 town player remains alive.

1 Town Non Consecutive Night Jailkeeper

Hello, and welcome to Large Normal XXX!
You are a

Town Non Consecutive Night Jailkeeper

. You have your voice and vote. You may also target a player on nights not consecutive to protect them from any kill attempts that night as well as prevent their action from executing.
You win when all antitown roles are eliminated and at least 1 town player remains alive.

1 Town Tracker

Hello, and welcome to Large Normal XXX!
You are a

Town Tracker

. You have your voice and vote. You may also target a player each night to discover who they visited in the night. You will get results in the form of "X visited Y", "X visited no one", or "No result".
You win when all antitown roles are eliminated and at least 1 town player remains alive.

1 Town Vigilante

Hello, and welcome to Large Normal XXX!
You are a

Town Vigilante

. You have your voice and vote. You may also target a player each night to attempt to kill them.
You win when all antitown roles are eliminated and at least 1 town player remains alive.

9 Vanilla Townies

Hello, and welcome to Large Normal XXX!
You are a

Vanilla Townie

. You have your voice and vote.
You win when all antitown roles are eliminated and at least 1 town player remains alive.

1 Mafia Roleblocker

Hello, and welcome to Large Normal XXX!
You are a

Mafia Roleblocker

. You have your voice and vote. You also have a factional chat, located here, and a factional kill which you may send one person to do each night. You may also target a player each night to prevent their action from executing.
You win when your team comprises 50 percent of all players or nothing can stop it.

1 Mafia Odd Night Neapolitan

Hello, and welcome to Large Normal XXX!
You are a

Mafia Odd Night Neapolitan

. You have your voice and vote. You also have a factional chat, located here, and a factional kill which you may send one person to do each night. You may also target a player each odd-numbered night to discover whether they are a Vanilla Townie or not. You will get your results in the form of "X is Vanilla Town", "X is not Vanilla Town", or "No result".
You win when your team comprises 50 percent of all players or nothing can stop it.

2 Mafia Goons

Hello, and welcome to Large Normal XXX!
You are a

Mafia Goon

. You have your voice and vote. You also have a factional chat, located here, and a factional kill which you may send one person to do each night.
You win when your team comprises 50 percent of all players or nothing can stop it.

[Gamma Emerald]

btw you'll put me back in the moderating queue once we get reviewers right? Or do I have to post the /in again?

[Gamma Emerald]

ok I did it
I figured being in the moderator queue on the first page would possible help drum up interest in my game

[Gamma Emerald]

Note: tracker will get no visit on a roleblocked PR

[Gamma Emerald]

It's probably been address, but I haven't read through yet...how what happens if the Willbooster targets scum and the Weak Roleblocker targets same scum. WRB still dies, but scum is not blocked? From the wording of the PM, that's what I get.

So, the Willbooster is basically a Roleblocker-blocker, but they have to target the Roleblocker's intended target. Hrm.

Correct.

[Gamma Emerald]

Note: tracker will get no visit on a roleblocked PR

To confirm, as an example, if "the Vig" shoots player x but is roleblocked by the JK/Maf!RB/Town!WRB, player x is not killed; and, the Tracker get a "the Vig visited no one."

Yes

[Gamma Emerald]

Yep, but probably removing the NAR point as that could be used to read into the setup

[Gamma Emerald]

Thinking on it now if the WRB visits mafia and is not roleblocked, or attempts to visit a mafia roleblocker blocking it, it dies, but if it attempts visit mafia and the jailkeeper targets it, or it attempts to target a mafia other than the roleblocker and the mafia roleblocker targets it, it lives. Of course the willbooster targeting the WRB means if it targets mafia it dies.

[Gamma Emerald]

Confirming that you mean that WRB action supersedes MRB action. Also, if the Willbooster, JK, and MRB target WRB, then WRB would live.

Yes.

If so, then probably just change the JK PM to read "on non-consecutive nights" to match the flow of the others, and I'm good. What about it leaves you unclear, Reg?

Swing can still be balanced and normal (learned that from my modded game), so I'm good to pass given the above.

Got it on the JK wording, will fix.

[Gamma Emerald]

1 Town Willbooster

Hello, and welcome to Large Normal XXX!
You are a

Town Willbooster

. You have your voice and vote. You may also target a player each night to make them immune to one roleblock.
You win when all antitown roles are eliminated and at least 1 town player remains alive.

1 Town Weak Roleblocker

Hello, and welcome to Large Normal XXX!
You are a

Town Weak Roleblocker

. You have your voice and vote. You may also target a player each night to prevent their action from executing. However, if you target an antitown role you will die.
You win when all antitown roles are eliminated and at least 1 town player remains alive.

1 Town Non Consecutive Night Jailkeeper

Hello, and welcome to Large Normal XXX!
You are a

Town Non Consecutive Night Jailkeeper

. You have your voice and vote. You may also target any player on non-consecutive nights to protect them from any kill attempts that night as well as prevent their action from executing.
You win when all antitown roles are eliminated and at least 1 town player remains alive.

1 Town Tracker

Hello, and welcome to Large Normal XXX!
You are a

Town Tracker

. You have your voice and vote. You may also target a player each night to discover who they visited in the night. You will get results in the form of "X visited Y", "X visited no one", or "No result".
You win when all antitown roles are eliminated and at least 1 town player remains alive.

1 Town Vigilante

Hello, and welcome to Large Normal XXX!
You are a

Town Vigilante

. You have your voice and vote. You may also target a player each night to attempt to kill them.
You win when all antitown roles are eliminated and at least 1 town player remains alive.

9 Vanilla Townies

Hello, and welcome to Large Normal XXX!
You are a

Vanilla Townie

. You have your voice and vote.
You win when all antitown roles are eliminated and at least 1 town player remains alive.

1 Mafia Roleblocker

Hello, and welcome to Large Normal XXX!
You are a

Mafia Roleblocker

. You have your voice and vote. You also have a factional chat, located here, and a factional kill which you may send one person to do each night. You may also target a player each night to prevent their action from executing.
You win when your team comprises 50 percent of all players or nothing can stop it.

1 Mafia Odd Night Neapolitan

Hello, and welcome to Large Normal XXX!
You are a

Mafia Odd Night Neapolitan

. You have your voice and vote. You also have a factional chat, located here, and a factional kill which you may send one person to do each night. You may also target a player each odd-numbered night to discover whether they are a Vanilla Townie or not. You will get your results in the form of "X is Vanilla Town", "X is not Vanilla Town", or "No result".
You win when your team comprises 50 percent of all players or nothing can stop it.

2 Mafia Goons

Hello, and welcome to Large Normal XXX!
You are a

Mafia Goon

. You have your voice and vote. You also have a factional chat, located here, and a factional kill which you may send one person to do each night.
You win when your team comprises 50 percent of all players or nothing can stop it.

[Gamma Emerald]

Welcome to Theatre Mafia!

Moderator: Gamma Emerald
Backup Moderator: Zaphkael
Reviewers: PenguinPower, RadiantCowbells, Regfan (with special mention to Cephrir)

Living Players

Players

Dead Players

Players

Links

Day 1: Post #

Deadline

YYYY-mm-dd HH:MM:SS - 5.00

Vote Counter made by Thesp which I am using

Also updated the OP with the new reviewer. Left a mention to Ceph since he was involved.

[Gamma Emerald]

1 Town Willbooster

Hello, and welcome to Large Normal XXX!
You are a

Town Willbooster

. You have your voice and vote. You may also target a player each night to make them immune to one roleblock.
You win when all antitown roles are eliminated and at least 1 town player remains alive.

1 Town Weak Roleblocker

Hello, and welcome to Large Normal XXX!
You are a

Town Weak Roleblocker

. You have your voice and vote. You may also target a player each night to prevent their action from executing. However, if you target an antitown role you will die.
You win when all antitown roles are eliminated and at least 1 town player remains alive.

1 Town Non Consecutive Night Jailkeeper

Hello, and welcome to Large Normal XXX!
You are a

Town Non Consecutive Night Jailkeeper

. You have your voice and vote. You may also target any player on non-consecutive nights to protect them from any kill attempts that night as well as roleblocking them, prevent their action from executing.
You win when all antitown roles are eliminated and at least 1 town player remains alive.

1 Town Tracker

Hello, and welcome to Large Normal XXX!
You are a

Town Tracker

. You have your voice and vote. You may also target a player each night to discover who they visited in the night. You will get results in the form of "X visited Y", "X visited no one", or "No result".
You win when all antitown roles are eliminated and at least 1 town player remains alive.

1 Town Vigilante

Hello, and welcome to Large Normal XXX!
You are a

Town Vigilante

. You have your voice and vote. You may also target a player each night to attempt to kill them.
You win when all antitown roles are eliminated and at least 1 town player remains alive.

9 Vanilla Townies

Hello, and welcome to Large Normal XXX!
You are a

Vanilla Townie

. You have your voice and vote.
You win when all antitown roles are eliminated and at least 1 town player remains alive.

1 Mafia Roleblocker

Hello, and welcome to Large Normal XXX!
You are a

Mafia Roleblocker

. You have your voice and vote. You also have a factional chat, located here, and a factional kill which you may send one person to do each night. You may also target a player each night to prevent their action from executing.
You win when your team comprises 50 percent of all players or nothing can stop it.

1 Mafia Odd Night Neapolitan

Hello, and welcome to Large Normal XXX!
You are a

Mafia Odd Night Neapolitan

. You have your voice and vote. You also have a factional chat, located here, and a factional kill which you may send one person to do each night. You may also target a player each odd-numbered night to discover whether they are a Vanilla Townie or not. You will get your results in the form of "X is Vanilla Town", "X is not Vanilla Town", or "No result".
You win when your team comprises 50 percent of all players or nothing can stop it.

2 Mafia Goons

Hello, and welcome to Large Normal XXX!
You are a

Mafia Goon

. You have your voice and vote. You also have a factional chat, located here, and a factional kill which you may send one person to do each night.
You win when your team comprises 50 percent of all players or nothing can stop it.

[Gamma Emerald]

Figured it should be clear by what the role is but tbh I think it may have been needed

[Gamma Emerald]

All have passed fyi

[Gamma Emerald]

how 2 release this?