Mini 1918: Paint Mafia Threequel! Game Over!

[Aristophanes]

We flipped me and I'm purple, Ari.

Awesome!

Why would scum paint you first?

[Aristophanes]

Like,frame or coverup? That's the question

[jjh927]

Well, they left Frog alive.

[Havo]

If like in game 2, scum can paint Red but not blue, then that would mean JJ was Blue and was painted Red by scum, thus making him purple. No?

[Havo]

If like in game 2, scum can paint Red but not blue, then that would mean JJ was Blue and was painted Red by scum, thus making him purple. No?

If they can't paint Blue, then there would be no way to make Purple, unless he started out as Blue.

[jjh927]

The colours don't mix if the paint is dry and I am pretty sure this game operates on the same principle. Either some shenanigans happened that someone can enlighten us to, or someone made the decision to paint me purple.

[Aristophanes]

Well, they left Frog alive.

So? Infinity was Obvtown so he was Obv a good NK choice. What is your point here? That Frog is scum?

[Havo]

Questions is, how often and When can scum use their painting abilities?

[jjh927]

In game 2, scum had a load of different colours to choose from.

[Aristophanes]

He would have been painted purple by scum. Colours don't mix unless wet, and I believe are only wet for a night.

[MaxwellPuckett]

How do we know this game has paint-mixing mechanics
I even quoted the post where varsoon goes over previous games mechanics

Havo Id guess its at night

[Aristophanes]

Questions is, how often and When can scum use their painting abilities?

Usually once a night as a factional ability.

[jjh927]

Well, they left Frog alive.

So? Infinity was Obvtown so he was Obv a good NK choice. What is your point here? That Frog is scum?

No. It's that Frog was pushing me day 1. Frog was more obvtown than Infinity imo, and it's a good bet that with an alive Frog I'd be colourflipped at some point. This lines up.

[Bomberman]

If like in game 2, scum can paint Red but not blue, then that would mean JJ was Blue and was painted Red by scum, thus making him purple. No?

That's funny however if we lynched jj and that theory remained to be true it'd be useless for mafia given it would pseudo-confirm Townies who were colored red

Also jj the rules state Blue is town and Red is groupscum so altering or lying about that fact would be bastard

How the hell can you say TwoFace was town when he flipped mafia goon lmfao

[Havo]

So we're to believe JJ was the one scum chose to use their paint ability on last night?

[jjh927]

If colours mix then there's presumably some kind of loyal blue-painter somewhere in the town.

[MaxwellPuckett]

Well, they left Frog alive.

So? Infinity was Obvtown so he was Obv a good NK choice. What is your point here? That Frog is scum?

I dont agree that Infinity was obvtown

Also the rules state town starts and blue and scum starts as red, altering that isnt bastard
Pedit Yes I really doubt he started purple, whether he's town or scum he got painted

[aptil]

The colour of the flip is not that trustworthy as the colour was definitely changed here because scum is red and town is blue (anything other than that should be a mechanism of colour change).
So we have two things here to analyse:

1) If you believe jj was town (blue) colour changed to purple by scum last night they would need to push for his reveal . So we look for who pushed where and how .Also another possibility of town changing the colour not so sure about that role but that would be weird.

2)If you believe jj was scum(red) ) colour changed to purple by himself , he would have to somehow be eager to reveal himself and clear him by that standard . In this case he would have to act pretty damn scummy to get that flip .

[Aristophanes]

Well, they left Frog alive.

So? Infinity was Obvtown so he was Obv a good NK choice. What is your point here? That Frog is scum?

No. It's that Frog was pushing me day 1. Frog was more obvtown than Infinity imo, and it's a good bet that with an alive Frog I'd be colourflipped at some point. This lines up.

Or you knew killing him would make you too obvious and that leaving him alive would make a flip on you more likely, so rather than flip red you painted yourself purple.

It's not an open/shut case.

[jjh927]

If like in game 2, scum can paint Red but not blue, then that would mean JJ was Blue and was painted Red by scum, thus making him purple. No?

That's funny however if we lynched jj and that theory remained to be true it'd be useless for mafia given it would pseudo-confirm Townies who were colored red

Also jj the rules state Blue is town and Red is groupscum so altering or lying about that fact would be bastard

How the hell can you say TwoFace was town when he flipped mafia goon lmfao

Do you understand the concept of this game

[jjh927]

Yeah, IK it's not open and shut.

[Bomberman]

Well I think saying or 'painting' blue as red would be bastard because it'd go against the foundation set

[Bomberman]

If like in game 2, scum can paint Red but not blue, then that would mean JJ was Blue and was painted Red by scum, thus making him purple. No?

That's funny however if we lynched jj and that theory remained to be true it'd be useless for mafia given it would pseudo-confirm Townies who were colored red

Also jj the rules state Blue is town and Red is groupscum so altering or lying about that fact would be bastard

How the hell can you say TwoFace was town when he flipped mafia goon lmfao

Do you understand the concept of this game

Yeah

Cheertory said he was a mafia goon
That's mafia regardless of what color they are u nog

[jjh927]

When did I say anything about Twoface

[Havo]

The colour of the flip is not that trustworthy as the colour was definitely changed here because scum is red and town is blue (anything other than that should be a mechanism of colour change).
So we have two things here to analyse:

1) If you believe jj was town (blue) colour changed to purple by scum last night they would need to push for his reveal . So we look for who pushed where and how .Also another possibility of town changing the colour not so sure about that role but that would be weird.

2)If you believe jj was scum(red) ) colour changed to purple by himself , he would have to somehow be eager to reveal himself and clear him by that standard . In this case he would have to act pretty damn scummy to get that flip .

This makes so much sense it worries me how you came up with it tbh.