In post 464, Famethyst wrote:dreal he could be a 1 shot cop or a full cop trying to look like one
we dont have enough set up info IMO to lynch him unless you can make a strong scumcase on him and i already tr him - we dont need a repeat of MariaF the Doctor
In post 471, Fire Starter wrote:Also, big bad mod didn't pm me my location prior to day 1 and the location i picked to travel too wasnt acceptable so I blame him for lots. We able to modlynch?
I wasn't asking for it many times over, I suggested it a few times, never really pushed it with much conviction
and no, I didn't back off as soon as he claimed cop, I said I'd re-evaluate and back off until then, but stated my points why I think it might not be a true claim, ppl can agree with me or not and vote him or not based on thata agreeance, but I'm not super-invested in his lynch at all
In post 477, drealmerz7 wrote:I wasn't asking for it many times over, I suggested it a few times, never really pushed it with much conviction
and no, I didn't back off as soon as he claimed cop, I said I'd re-evaluate and back off until then, but stated my points why I think it might not be a true claim, ppl can agree with me or not and vote him or not based on thata agreeance, but I'm not super-invested in his lynch at all
again never wanted him "that bad" as you put it
But from someone who has posted fluff, excuses and talked about claiming up to post 242, then up until 459 posted about claiming, fluff, excuses, and lynching Wheme and PU (asking for a lynch on Wheme several times), and from then on defending yourself it kind of does sound like you wanted a lynch on Wheme pretty bad. Honestly these last few posts of yours are the most content filled ones so far this whole game and they are only defending yourself.
The only reads you have ever shared this game were Wheme and PU and those were hardly explained at all. Can I please have some sort of a reads list from you or a few reads at least? And please explain them.
yeah I guess it is lack of experience with me? if I wanted a lynch on someone pretty bad, it'd be very apparent
I'm just not 'into' the game and I'll have to do a full reread for coherence for any good reads or explaining them - more excuses I know
my PU read isn't well explained? I thought it was - you don't claim BP as town, you don't share that you're asking the mod about being BP, you don't do any of what they did around their role as town, imo, you do it as scum trying to pretend to be towny and setting up excuses for not being NKed
I actually wanted to challenge PU last Night and try to kill them because I feel pretty sure they're scum (I have a lot of familiarity with gamma, and few games with BTD6) and totally flaked on doing so in time :\
In post 485, drealmerz7 wrote:
my PU read isn't well explained? I thought it was - you don't claim BP as town, you don't share that you're asking the mod about being BP, you don't do any of what they did around their role as town, imo, you do it as scum trying to pretend to be towny and setting up excuses for not being NKed
I don't really see claiming BP scummy though. Plus that seemed pretty early to set up excuses to not be nked when they aren't even that active. (In my experience scum generally targets active players). You explained why you thought PU was scum but can you explain why those reasons indicate they are scum rather than town?
In post 486, drealmerz7 wrote:I actually wanted to challenge PU last Night and try to kill them because I feel pretty sure they're scum (I have a lot of familiarity with gamma, and few games with BTD6) and totally flaked on doing so in time :\
Wouldn't it be better to try to talk to them more than to kill them? Thay way you can get a more solid read based on more than just a claim.
and I have enough familiarity with gamma and BTD6 to not think they'd do that as town, especially how they did it, kind of like a fumbling derp (attempt) around their claim
if it were a player I had little or no familiarity with I'd be more likely to say it could just be anti-town naivety, for them, it scumpings me hardcore
So we've talked about UP and Wheme. What are some of your other reads? How about Fire Starter and Char? That also leaves Human, Mort and Fame (and me). Any thoughts on them?
In post 488, drealmerz7 wrote:sorry, I think some things are so blatantly obvious I don't even think to say them outloud
it's scummy because BP town wants to absorb a NK not tell scum they're BP so scum can avoid them or use a strongman if they have it
Okay, that makes sense. I haven't played with a BP before I don't think, so I'm not that familiar with the theory.
I still don't think that's enough to base a kill off of though. Sure it's anti-town but I don't see it as scummy enough for a kill.
You clearly don't understand the nature of why D7 scumreads PU. It's not a degree of anti-townness that leads to a scumread, it's that he's saying the claim is not a towny claim because town BP doesn't claim like that.
