Mini Normal 1914 - Sunshine Mafia - Game Over

[Nachomamma8]

People think the PRs are scummy and it is the general opinion there is 1 scum in that pool.

who thinks this other than twoface?

[iDanyboy]

no, not really. motion detector had a special status in that post. claiming vanilla cop from it wouldn't work because it was just a regular part of it.
People think the PRs are scummy and it is the general opinion there is 1 scum in that pool. Claiming really did just have no motivation if I was scum.

True, scum never do anything you wouldn't expect.

[MarioManiac4]

i think thinking me to be scummy in this setup pretty much requires you to see scum in the pool of PRs

[MarioManiac4]

no, not really. motion detector had a special status in that post. claiming vanilla cop from it wouldn't work because it was just a regular part of it.
People think the PRs are scummy and it is the general opinion there is 1 scum in that pool. Claiming really did just have no motivation if I was scum.

True, scum never do anything you wouldn't expect.

They do, but for reasons.
This move wouldn't have reasons.

[Fro99er]

Day 1 Vote Count 3.04

MarioManiac4 (1): mush
Vedith (1): Nachomamma8
Syndesis (3): iDanyboy, I Am Innocent, Vedith
iDanyboy (1): Syndesis
MarioManiac4 (1): BTD6_maker
mush (1): MarioManiac4

Not Voting (1): TwoFace

With 9 alive, It takes 5 to reach a Lynch.

Day 3 Ends (expired on 2017-06-22 05:15:00)

[Syndesis]

pretty sure that shooting tonight regardless of flip is the right course of action because yeah I wouldn't let me live either.

seriously considering shooting the next person to suggest that I was claiming too slowly.

nacho, I have had zero grasp of this game from like mid-D1 to mid-D3 and I'm not

terminally insane

enough to make a shot in that state.

dany case Soon tm

[iDanyboy]

VOTE: MM
One claim is not like the others.

[TwoFace]

VOTE: syn

[I Am Innocent]

I like how when syn gets to three or four votes and the thread blows up. Makes me feel even better that we're finally on the right track.

Ps I like the supposedly backwards play of the two living claim players

1 should wait until late game when RBing has a better chance of catching scum but said they used it N1 and N2
The other should shoot a waste of space early in the game but still has a shot D3???

[I Am Innocent]

Yeah at least one of these two are lying. Syn is for sure the better target.

[I Am Innocent]

Nacho you believe both claims and that town has 5 power roles? I don't see town nacho 1) believing both and then 2) voting outside of these two slots with a mislynch to spare. In the slight case ur town please tell me why vedith over at least a 50% chance of hitting scum?

[TwoFace]

It really is as simple at btd/syn/nacho

Out of all the claims the motion detector makes the most sense.

Vig makes more sense than btd's claim and since he didn't actually crumb like he says he did, he looks worse and nacho looks terrible for thinking that was a claim.

I'd rather lynch btd but I'm alone in that.

[mush]

suppp

[Nachomamma8]

i think thinking me to be scummy in this setup pretty much requires you to see scum in the pool of PRs

?????

[Nachomamma8]

If someone thinks that you're scum and you're a claimed PR then obviously they think there's scum in the PRs. I'm sure that wasn't the point you were making so what point were you making?

[Syndesis]

Spoiler: listen I am so tired and have 0.2 spoons for this game, goodbye

True, scum never do anything you wouldn't expect.

the worst doubtcasting

Then were left with Syndesis who hasn't had any votes all game, he doesn't think nacho is scummy is his only read.

blatant misrep

Schedule conflicts meant that I had a late start in the game - how is that indicative of my alignment?

How should I know if that's true? It is true that you didn't start until you were called out on it, which seems like scum trying to skate by.

What does it matter if I don't give my reasoning for reads immediately - why does it make me more likely to be scum?

This isn't my reasoning it's BTD's, I just found it weird how he calls me out for it (even though I have explained my reasoning on it) but not others, and stranger that you didn't have a problem when it was said to me.

bad nacho sus

Writes a 10 page wall and proceeds to vote for someone who hasn't been playing on day 2&3.

etc

You do a lot of hmm'ing, you throw out questions and you do no analysis and take no stances in your post.

bad me sus

I don't see how you can put Ingeel higher than Syndesis when they have done about the same.

hello more bad sus

So no reason

[snip]

Shows you haven't been scumhunting

I am literally going to eat you.

I didn't realise this, this is pretty damning.

opportunistic af

I agree nacho is scummy in all his posts all he does is ask questions but does where little follow up and he doesn't have a stance on anything.
@Nacho who do you think is scum and why?

bad! nacho! sus!

also I am going to eat IaI too, I think.

[Nachomamma8]

Out of all the claims the motion detector makes the most sense.

It's like
You believed the one claim that meshed with the reads you had before
And didn't believe in the claim that didn't mesh with your reads you had before

Is it logic
Or is it TwoFace???

[Nachomamma8]

Syndesis I don't think there are many worlds where Dany is scum and decides he's okay with lynching someone other than you today. Do you disagree/see why I would say something like that?

[Vedith]

Syndesis I don't think there are many worlds where Dany is scum and decides he's okay with lynching someone other than you today. Do you disagree/see why I would say something like that?

Why do you not consider scum together?

[Vedith]

if she doesn't have a good explanation, I'll be fine with lynching her.

nacho, I have had zero grasp of this game from like mid-D1 to mid-D3 and I'm not terminally insane enough to make a shot in that state.

Verdict?

[TwoFace]

Out of all the claims the motion detector makes the most sense.

It's like
You believed the one claim that meshed with the reads you had before
And didn't believe in the claim that didn't mesh with your reads you had before

Is it logic
Or is it TwoFace???

Btd and syn haven't played like town all game. I've explained why btd's claim doesn't work.

Clearly I'm wrong about town having 4 PRs but blocker is too strong. Vig is possible but MD is weak enough that it's still balanced.

ignoring the claims btd and syn make so much sense as partners for reasons I've already explained. If you aren't going to read and respond to those and tell me where the flawed logic is, go F off.

But then again you make the most sense as the 3rd with them so I don't expect you to actually do that

[TwoFace]

Btw the last coupost lenif pages has proven that btd could have been more active. He just chose not to. When the shit got serious for him and his buddy he starts posting.

From his pov syn should be scum. Yet no vote on syn. Later when Mario claims when he didn't even have to, btd votes mario.

That's basically a scum claim. Its btd/syn.

If I'm wrong I'll quit the site

[TwoFace]

If y'all want to leave the "vig" claim alive. Vote btd instead.

If somebody wants to explain how btd/syn make sense as town given their terrible play and how it works for balance I'm all ears.

I didn't think town had 4, I definitely don't think it has 6. I pm'd mastin a while back about ideas for a role madness normal game and he basically said it would never get approved. Mastin was a reviewer for this game so I'm hedging my bets 6 roles wouldn't get approved.

If it did I'm going to be mad at mastin

[Vedith]

I'd vote BTD over Mario.

[I Am Innocent]

Spoiler: listen I am so tired and have 0.2 spoons for this game, goodbye

True, scum never do anything you wouldn't expect.

the worst doubtcasting

Then were left with Syndesis who hasn't had any votes all game, he doesn't think nacho is scummy is his only read.

blatant misrep

Schedule conflicts meant that I had a late start in the game - how is that indicative of my alignment?

How should I know if that's true? It is true that you didn't start until you were called out on it, which seems like scum trying to skate by.

What does it matter if I don't give my reasoning for reads immediately - why does it make me more likely to be scum?

This isn't my reasoning it's BTD's, I just found it weird how he calls me out for it (even though I have explained my reasoning on it) but not others, and stranger that you didn't have a problem when it was said to me.

bad nacho sus

Writes a 10 page wall and proceeds to vote for someone who hasn't been playing on day 2&3.

etc

You do a lot of hmm'ing, you throw out questions and you do no analysis and take no stances in your post.

bad me sus

I don't see how you can put Ingeel higher than Syndesis when they have done about the same.

hello more bad sus

So no reason

[snip]

Shows you haven't been scumhunting

I am literally going to eat you.

I didn't realise this, this is pretty damning.

opportunistic af

I agree nacho is scummy in all his posts all he does is ask questions but does where little follow up and he doesn't have a stance on anything.
@Nacho who do you think is scum and why?

bad! nacho! sus!

also I am going to eat IaI too, I think.

So six claims, and you list two non-claimed players who you want "to eat".

Can we please lynch this?