In post 1650, itlepip wrote:Thanks vedith Y'all did a great job lynching scum before I got here. I went over the posts that stood out to me in my catchup, that's why it is a fricken catchup. It was genuine reasoning and a believable progression. We don't have a scumflip so saying 'the read was wrong' isn't a useful commentary.
I'm not taking blame on the game not progressing because so many people refused to input their opinions, or give reasons to why Sesq was a bad lynch.
The only person who spoke up about the Sesq wagon was Alban.
I'm not saying your read is wrong. I think both Math and Titus are scum. Your catch up and reasoning is shit.
Although I want to lynch in Titus Math, it would mean we would have to first lynch Math to see if the clear that Math is hinting too is real or not.
If scum, Titus is also scum, if town, Titus is also town.
But I'm not really a fan of lynching outside of the doc claims.
Mutton and Alban I both town read, so I'm not interested in voting there and I want a good reason why I should move there.
Titus I won't lynch before Math so that leaves AS and Navy.
jjh had Navy as scum (also Math), and then dies. So for me, I think Navy is the best lynch, and I believe the scum to be Navy, Titus and Math.
Until I see reason to think otherwise, this is what I'm going with.