(Warning: extreme amount of barely sorted and messy quotes)
Let me know if I missed anything
itlepip/RadiantCowbells/bombcat/UseYourActive
Spoiler: quotes
In post 110, Rikku wrote:A day (2-3?) lynch shouldn't really ever happen , I mean it can happen if Hammer is new aggressive town but yeah a lynch shouldn't really occur before last few days at earliest of D1 from what I have seen.In post 96, bombcat wrote:This is my first time playing forum mafia anywhere other than Epicmafia (which wasn't real forum mafia) so I don't know how likely it is that I'm gonna get hammered.
How so , Could you highlight what posts made you think he was scum?In post 98, Burgerking wrote:bombcat has hardclaimed scum in every post hes made
Regarding the whole drama at the start , Bomb was joke posting , Drixx took it the wrong way. Then Burgerking seems to know Bomb - but not viceversa , Interesting love triangle
Spoiler:In post 85, Burgerking wrote:omgusIn post 79, bombcat wrote:VOTE: Burgerking
I think this is a better vote than Drixx considering all he's done is lie about me to get me on people's bad side and then vote me for some unexplained liability when I was L-2
very scummy
some1 hammer this kidI can't tell if this is serious or notIn post 88, Burgerking wrote:ah yes, any vote on me is a scummy vote.
no one is doing anything ... during RVS/RQS . . . SHOCKER
In post 186, TheFlogScrogger wrote:I would like to formally call into question Bombcat's motivations for forming a finger of suspicion on Drixx early on.
I believe that it is possible that he was simply trying to form a brigade against Drixx just so that he would be able to then depart from the brigade to create an ally out of Drixx and make others less suspicious of him.
Such a tactic might be dubbed the Meeseeks scheme.
As seen above he would create a bandwagon, and then try to blame others after they join in, as they "roped him into this"
Do not fall for such feeble and see-through ploys.
VOTE: Bombcat
In post 190, TheFlogScrogger wrote:I would also like to add that Drixx could potentially be Bombcat's partner and their entire opener was a ploy. Why would Drixx assume that Bombcat voting him was a troll and that he should be kicked out?
I think that this response makes the most sense if they are mafia together and Drixx was extremely taken aback by Bombcat's vote, insulted even.
In post 197, bombcat wrote:I think floggerscrogger is trying to get a bandwagon on me so that he can blame the lynch on other meseeks who "roped him into this"
VOTE: floggerscrogger
In post 206, TheFlogScrogger wrote:I see that you have switched votes with little to no extra coercion needed and recognize that you are compliant and a logic based being. I would like to propose an unofficial alliance between you and I so that we may work together in this game.
Combined, our votes are twice the strength of any other player's vote. I believe that working together in this game may be our key to defeating the mafia and achieving victory.
What say you to my offer, bombcat?
In post 266, bombcat wrote:I don't know. I think that calling Raya his teammate is sort of weird. You claimed mafia and self voted after I already thought you were scummy so I'm gonna have a hard time turning around
In post 276, TheFlogScrogger wrote:bombcat, Raya, shuffleplay, all other members of the town...
In post 368, bombcat wrote:I sort of got the feeling Rikku was scum but I think The Flog Scrogger was pretty town. It's hard to read past the irony but I think that he legitimately believed he made Kaiser give up and out himself as mafia. I don't think he was faking that
In post 382, ThinkBig wrote:In post 26, bombcat wrote:Drixx is here to answer any mechanics-related question you might have within twenty minutes, but the moment you ask him to give a read he falls silent. I found a mafia.These posts feel really weird and contrived.In post 28, bombcat wrote:Drixx is feeling the heat it is time to get out of the kitchen Drixx
In post 397, ThinkBig wrote:I have MAJOR concerns with this post. I get the feeling that you know he isbtown from the purple.In post 393, bombcat wrote:Raya we need you to vote The King so he feels the heat and iscompelled to stop game throwing
UNVOTE:
Let me re evaluate BK and Bombcat
In post 593, ThinkBig wrote:Quickhammer? I gave him time to claim and speak. He refused to claim and contradicted himself in every post. I don't feel sorry for the hammer at all.In post 572, RadiantCowbells wrote:what was that quickhammer TB
In post 592, ThinkBig wrote:Why do you always have to be scum when I'm town?
In post 717, ThinkBig wrote:I'm sorry I've been rather apathetic about this game.
UNVOTE:
I disagree with RC that bombcat was objectively town. RC has been doing a lot of analysis and game solving since replacing in, though I am definitely paranoid of him.
keyenpeydee
Spoiler: quotes
Interactions with Flog start here
Summary to save quotes:
-Welcomes Flog, flog does not accept welcome says it's a showing of weakness
-Key feels like Flog is an alt
-F accuses K of quickly accusing him wrongly
-Arguments easier to read than for me to summarize which ended up with this
Summary to save quotes:
-Welcomes Flog, flog does not accept welcome says it's a showing of weakness
-Key feels like Flog is an alt
-F accuses K of quickly accusing him wrongly
-Arguments easier to read than for me to summarize which ended up with this
In post 240, keyenpeydee wrote:I'm claiming scum now lynch me so I can avoid replacing out
In post 191, keyenpeydee wrote:Kinda agree with this especially that Drixx really over-reacted that I don't think an IC should. (Drixx, you're a good IC and I'm talking about what happened on this game).In post 190, TheFlogScrogger wrote:I would also like to add that Drixx could potentially be Bombcat's partner and their entire opener was a ploy. Why would Drixx assume that Bombcat voting him was a troll and that he should be kicked out?
I think that this response makes the most sense if they are mafia together and Drixx was extremely taken aback by Bombcat's vote, insulted even.
In post 262, keyenpeydee wrote:Spoiler: A Very Big PostI don't really speak English, so sometimes I had to google Flog's words, but anyways here's the wall post:
In post 184, TheFlogScrogger wrote:I do not accept your warm greeting as it might be a showing of weakness.
Do not be mistake, I am here to dominate the game and achieve victory.I called flog an alt, which later was proven that he is not, because it feels like I know him for some reason.In post 185, keyenpeydee wrote:Feels like flog is an alt
The first post of his accusation.In post 186, TheFlogScrogger wrote:I would like to formally call into question Bombcat's motivations for forming a finger of suspicion on Drixx early on.
I believe that it is possible that he was simply trying to form a brigade against Drixx just so that he would be able to then depart from the brigade to create an ally out of Drixx and make others less suspicious of him.
Such a tactic might be dubbed the Meeseeks scheme.
As seen above he would create a bandwagon, and then try to blame others after they join in, as they "roped him into this"
Do not fall for such feeble and see-through ploys.
VOTE: Bombcat
I'm not accusing you that you're scum. Alt is a slang for Alternate Account, so I don't see a reason why would I accuse you a very NAI thing. Unless you're implying that I accuse you for being an alt which is not. And what is the thing I'm 'shying away from interpreting your words' exactly? With 5 posts you have at this time you posted this, I don't see what I'm shying away. Could you also please tell me why I'm afraid of you?In post 187, TheFlogScrogger wrote:You were quick to accuse me of something that I am not and now you are shying away from interpreting my words and placing a judgement of your own upon them keepeedeepee, are you afraid of me?
In post 190, TheFlogScrogger wrote:I would also like to add that Drixx could potentially be Bombcat's partner and their entire opener was a ploy. Why would Drixx assume that Bombcat voting him was a troll and that he should be kicked out?
I think that this response makes the most sense if they are mafia together and Drixx was extremely taken aback by Bombcat's vote, insulted even.These were the posts I agree with that made me townread flog.In post 191, keyenpeydee wrote:Kinda agree with this especially that Drixx really over-reacted that I don't think an IC should. (Drixx, you're a good IC and I'm talking about what happened on this game).In post 190, TheFlogScrogger wrote:I would also like to add that Drixx could potentially be Bombcat's partner and their entire opener was a ploy. Why would Drixx assume that Bombcat voting him was a troll and that he should be kicked out?
I think that this response makes the most sense if they are mafia together and Drixx was extremely taken aback by Bombcat's vote, insulted even.
his is why I probably didn't understand the post at my first read.In post 196, bombcat wrote:Fuck this is one of those alternate reality reads where you see into universes where entirely different events occurredIn post 186, TheFlogScrogger wrote:I would like to formally call into question Bombcat's motivations for forming a finger of suspicion on Drixx early on.
I believe that it is possible that he was simply trying to form a brigade against Drixx just so that he would be able to then depart from the brigade to create an ally out of Drixx and make others less suspicious of him.
Such a tactic might be dubbed the Meeseeks scheme.
As seen above he would create a bandwagon, and then try to blame others after they join in, as they "roped him into this"
Do not fall for such feeble and see-through ploys.
VOTE: Bombcat
Looks like bombcat is scumreading flog here.In post 197, bombcat wrote:I think floggerscrogger is trying to get a bandwagon on me so that he can blame the lynch on other meseeks who "roped him into this"
VOTE: floggerscrogger
I don't know why I face-palmed.In post 199, keyenpeydee wrote:In post 197, bombcat wrote:I think floggerscrogger is trying to get a bandwagon on me so that he can blame the lynch on other meseeks who "roped him into this"
VOTE: floggerscrogger
Why am I on this game
In post 202, TheFlogScrogger wrote:It was keepeedeepee who roped me into this, so if you don't vote him over me then you are confirmed for going directly against what you said which is very scummy according to you.In post 197, bombcat wrote:I think floggerscrogger is trying to get a bandwagon on me so that he can blame the lynch on other meseeks who "roped him into this"
VOTE: floggerscrogger
I've got you by the balls, textbook scumhunter style.In post 203, TheFlogScrogger wrote:Also note, I dropped the word textbook in my last post to strongarm you into voting keepeedeepee, but if you do not vote him then you stand a chance of looking very foolish in front of everyone. Which, seeing as you are a new user, would be very bad for your reputation, something that I am not sure you could come back from. You should bear this in mind when you choose your next words, bombcat.Can someone please explain me these three posts because I'm too dumb to understand it? I don't know where I roped flog into this.
Since I don't really know what these 2 people are saying, I got really frustrated and voted myself. People who knows me on-site knows that I self-vote and self-hammer.
In post 206, TheFlogScrogger wrote:I see that you have switched votes with little to no extra coercion needed and recognize that you are compliant and a logic based being. I would like to propose an unofficial alliance between you and I so that we may work together in this game.
Combined, our votes are twice the strength of any other player's vote. I believe that working together in this game may be our key to defeating the mafia and achieving victory.
What say you to my offer, bombcat?I thought buddying someone is scummy?
And the next posts until my last one before this is just me who was too frustrated to play this game though that bullying part is true.
I'm very contented that Flog is a newbscum who tries to vote for me with the reason I don't seem to understand because I surely haven't done anything what he said and pointed out, so I will VOTE: Flog for the reasons stated at the previous sentence.
In post 276, TheFlogScrogger wrote:bombcat, Raya, shuffleplay, all other members of the town...
I stand before you, a humble FlogScrogger, here to state my case and hopefully ascribe a sense of security in you with lynching keepeedeepee.
He is mafia.
Nothing he can say will change that, nothing he can do will alter his alignment. His mistake this game was being unlucky enough to flip scum while an expert scumhunter such as myself was here to flesh him out.
I have not only utterly ruined this shell of a mafia goon, but I've completely debased, broken down, and slaughtered him in a de facto inscrutable manner.
Now town, it is up to you, my kin, my brothers and sisters, my virtual family, to take this torch that I have laid out for you, and run with it. That torch is justice, and its destination is a noose that's been fitted to the exact measurements of keepeedeepee's neck.
In post 278, keyenpeydee wrote:Guys, we need to achieve a town win and by achieving that we shall scumhunt. The only first step in accomplishing it is to lynch Flog first. The second step will be revealed once that happens.
In post 336, keyenpeydee wrote:1. When he came in, he scumread bombcat with his own reasons and it seemed like he was really contented with bombcat being scum. Bit when I attacked him, he forced bombcat to vote for me like he didn't scumread him. That all felt like scum trying to mislynch a town (bombcat) but since there's a weaker target (Keyen), he decided to go to an easy opponent rather than to a harder opponent.In post 310, Raya36 wrote:Please explain why the only first step in scumhunting is to lynch Flog.
2. He doesn't give any real reasons as to why I am scum. Do you see him having a big wall post explaining that I'm scum? Do you see him pointing out quotes that I made explaining why is that scummy? No. You only see him convincing town ("manipulating") that I am scum with no apparent reason other than being sexist and calling me that I have a tiny and feminine hands. Makes sense?
3. When he was pressured and being scumread, he said that he felt really stressed out because he's very awar about his true.color
In post 384, ThinkBig wrote:I read Keyn's posts as town. His frustration with dealing with my predecessor's douchebaggery feels genuine and I apologize to everyone for having to put up with that toxic behaviour. I have played with Keyn before and him claiming scum and self hammering is not alignment indicative as far as his meta is concerned.
In post 475, keyenpeydee wrote:Could you give us an explanation, TB?
In post 739, ThinkBig wrote:I really can't see keyenpeydee as scum right now.
Elbirn/ZZZX/sad1492
Spoiler: quotes
In post 254, ZZZX wrote:I really don't like you after all.In post 253, TheFlogScrogger wrote:He claimed mafia after I thoroughly interrogated him using my expert scumhunting skills.In post 240, keyenpeydee wrote:I'm claiming scum now lynch me so I can avoid replacing out
Case closed boys.
If you don't chill out I will be voting you.
In post 323, ZZZX wrote:Are you lynching him cus you think he is scum? Or to defend key? Or because he is toxic to the game?
Drixx
Spoiler: quotes
In post 22, Rikku wrote:Just one question about the rulesWhat is a situation where someone would use probable randomness and why is it gamebreaking/damaging? I assume it's a sitewide thing.
In post 24, Drixx wrote:Most games start with a random vote stage, but there's a psychological part to that. How "random" is it really? Sometimes scum will vote other scum and things like that, just to screw with VCA.
If you PROVE that it was random by using a dice tag, then you completely destroy that aspect of the game, and if you're scum it has allowed you to bypass an important stage of the game.
So what you cannot refer to as the reason for anything you do is this tag:and in that tag you do something like 1d6 or 1d100 or any sort of variation, and it simulates a dice roll.Original Roll String: 1d100(STATIC) 1 100-Sided Dice: (42) = 42
You ARE allowed; however, to claim that you did that on random.org or with dice or whatever, and people then have to decide whether you really randomized or not, and if you did then there's the further question of WHY. SAYING that you randomized something introduces new facets of gameplay. PROVING that you did ... not so much.
In post 182, TheFlogScrogger wrote:Is the vote drixx joke over? Am I late to the party?
In post 186, TheFlogScrogger wrote:I would like to formally call into question Bombcat's motivations for forming a finger of suspicion on Drixx early on.
I believe that it is possible that he was simply trying to form a brigade against Drixx just so that he would be able to then depart from the brigade to create an ally out of Drixx and make others less suspicious of him.
Such a tactic might be dubbed the Meeseeks scheme.
As seen above he would create a bandwagon, and then try to blame others after they join in, as they "roped him into this"
Do not fall for such feeble and see-through ploys.
VOTE: Bombcat
In post 190, TheFlogScrogger wrote:I would also like to add that Drixx could potentially be Bombcat's partner and their entire opener was a ploy. Why would Drixx assume that Bombcat voting him was a troll and that he should be kicked out?
I think that this response makes the most sense if they are mafia together and Drixx was extremely taken aback by Bombcat's vote, insulted even.
In post 250, TheFlogScrogger wrote:Drixx, I would like to inquire why you have not voted keepeedeepee yet? He said that he was mafia and giving up due to my expert scumhunting skills earlier.
TB's Reads List
Spoiler: list
In post 721, ThinkBig wrote:I'm still working on re-reading the game. Where I'm at right now:
RC - Town lean right now. I like the way you are pushing the game forward and trying to get this game moving.
keyenpeydee - town lean. His early frustration with my predecessor feels genuine frustration.
nancy/ZZZX - still working on it.
Raya36 - scum. Although I'm worried that the shuffleplay kill was a frame kill, I think some of Raya's post and votes feel rather opportunistic to me.
This is where I'm at now, though as I said, I'm working on re-reading the game and trying not to tunnel too much on the bombcat slot.
drixx - scum lean. Hasn't really done much scum hunting this game and has not really tried to move the game forward. I understand he is sick and has medical issues so I'm trying to give him the benefit of the doubt.
Crosses fingers and hopes the quotes didn't mess up
