Mini Normal 1923: BooneyToonz IV - Five Weeks in a Boon END

[Mulch]

VOTE: Stay away I have a gf

that's bcs im patient with people not with blockheads

tacos trying to advocate my lynch in the shittiest way possible

by associatives on day one

yeah man ur such a good a player

like before you try and insinuate some kind of fantasy team where me and klazam are scum maybe actually engage the people who haven't posted any content

instead of narrowing your vision like a cockroach and treating your reads like the gospel

This is one hell of an overreaction here wow

VOTE: stay away

Both are so fucking wrong and shallow

[Mulch]

Spoiler:

I said I would give my reads on people, and here they are. Spoiler tags used to hide walls of text:

For reference, my other post with the first three reads is #443

Spoiler: Creative

Creative

From the first few posts I read, he gives me a town ping.
I'm not a fan of being told what to do by other people myself
(and tend to do things my own way) so I agree with #327. I'm
specifically talking about where Creative says "I guess I missed
the part where we established that, or even the part where we
agreed that you get to say when I should be doing x or y."

In #333 Klazam mentions Creatives tone rubbing him the wrong
way. Maybe Creative touched on something there?
#424 he posts directed at me saying I don't want to get in the
game much. I don't take issue with that since I was busy
earlier. I'm pretty much answering his #424 with my earlier
posts with reads on the three ISO's I listed and this posting.

Final thoughts: Creative is neutral leaning town so far

Spoiler: Tchill13

Tchill13

Most of what I see from his post #75 to #241 is NAI, so I'm
skipping it. The vote on Mulch seems to be related to the amount
or lack of shitposts.

#253 directed at mulch, I would have likely passed over this
earlier but it's worth noting after seeing how mulch reacted to
me calling out SAIHAG and then voting SAIHAG, posts #448 and
#461. I hadn't directed anything at mulch before this. Tchill's
#325 Only reinforces that.

#329 Leans town, as some would likely just push a lynch on some
one or try to blend in and vote.
I tend to agree with his #348 in seeing Creative in a town light.

#420 asking about Keychain's posts, I will comment on that when I
go through Keychain's ISO.

Tchill13 is leaning town to me

Spoiler: Klazam

Klazam

Read through his #171 and so far I don't have a good read on
him, most of it is in reaction to the shitposts, Serge and
responding to a few posts.
#185 the vote on fykus seems to be trying to produce a
reaction. I don't see it as scum sided.

#300 Thinking M (maestro?) is town but has a slight feeling of
paranoia. While in itself I'm not reading on that, Klazam's
thoughts on other players seem to lean slight town.

After most of the shitposting ended I see fykus going back and
forth in converstion, asking questions, blending in.

Final thoughts:

If klazam is scum, he's blending in well. I can't read one way or
the other so, I'm putting him in my neutral reads area.

Spoiler: mulch

mulch

#3 I would have not mentioned this one, but considering how
mulch came at me when I put out my scum read on and voted for
SAIHAG, I'm starting to rethink that.

I do find his catching of Whymafia listing Boon's name as "Boob"
funny though.

#35 He likes quickhammers. This scum pings to me.
I disagree that quickhammering is NAI. While it's true that town
players (from my point of view) do it too, I see it as a scum
move where scum will quickhammer a town player. But then again
if done early, scum can get caught, so it's more of a WIFOM
situation.

In specific to the liking quickhammer statement, I don't like
it, it could be a scum tell. Only way to tell for sure is
through playing the game out and seeing what goes on.

Shitposting back and forth with Serge and even comments on it in
#76. NAI.

#79 (Serge: Fuck yeah, I'm town) mulch: mhhhmmm
Not sure what to make of that. My point here is that we do not
know how many scum roles there or if there are town roles along
the lines of masons or neighborish roles. mulch may be calling
them town based off gut feeling, what he saw in posts, or off
what he already knows based off his role/their roles.

It's something I will keep an eye on. For now I'm concerned
with that but it doesn't scream scum.

#89 testing reactions like any town would do.

#121 to klazam, asking for thoughts on serge and I m? What's
that?

#129 confirming Serge as town? How does he know serge is town?

@250 "unvote me" That leans scummy to me.

#448 This is where he goes more scum than any post before.
My previous posts were all directed at other people and not him,
then in #448 and #461 he votes me in reaction to me producing a
scum read on SAIHAG. The quotes his #5 which has nothing to do
with anything.

The only logical reason I can think of is a scum scenario where
SAIHAG and mulch are scumteam. I went after his partner and he
countered and went after me.

@mulch...do you care to elaborate? Am I wrong?

Final thought as to mulch:

I had a neutral to slight scum read on him, but considering his

reaction to my vote on SAIHAG, it's going to scum.

Spoiler: Maestro

Maestro

Nothing that indicates alignment initially.
I'm not sure how to take the question about alt accounts -
I haven't been here long enough to really say if that's a scum
tell or not.

I don't take issue with his comment about me as I was not
involved much in the game earlier. With all of the shitposting
going on there wasn't much to get into. Different story now.

Conclusion: I can't say for sure if Maestro is scum or town.

He's true neutral to me.

Spoiler: DeasVail

DeasVail

I agree with what he said in #227 about not finding anything
that was alignment indicative regarding the first 7ish pages of
serge and mulch.

Also talks about his reads on other players in his posts that
follow. For the moment, DeasVail is leaning neutral town to me.
Not enough to go on really.

Spoiler: Keychain

Keychain

Vote on Serge seems to be because of the shitposts. It doesn't
seem scum to me.I don't have a solid read on Keychain so she is Neutral.

Tchill had asked is anyone else found Keychain's posts suspicious, and i said I would comment on it in Keychain's ISO read: I don't see anything. Tchill, was there something specific you were referring to?

Spoiler: Assemblerotws

Assemblerotws

Only one post and a random vote, VLA because of family
gathering.

Not enough to give a read off of, so I'm neutral on her.

Spoiler: Fykus

Fykus

#153 Asking what teams people are on. It might have been a joke,
but that leans scum to me. The rest seems random.

Because of the question about everyone's teams,
Fykus is neutral leaning scum to me.

Adding both of my reads lists posts and the reactions in between, my reads on people are as follows:

Scum Side:
SAIHAG
mulch

Neutral leaning Scum:
fykus

Neutral:
Sergetacos
klazam
Maestro
keychain
Assemblerotws

Neutral Leaning Town:
Creative
Tchill13
DeasVail

Town:
Keyser Söze

Reads from geralt.

Spoilers to the spoilers: They are so. Bad. So very bad. But I can sort see where the town motiivation is coming from.

[Keyser Söze]

Um mulch, any chance you could have done a single post instead of billions of posts?

I'm personally enjoying this frenetic no holds barred ride he is taking us on.

[Mulch]

1. Maestro

2. Mulch

3. Creative

4. Keychain

5. SergTacos

6. Assemblerotws

7. Geralt of Rivia

8. Fykus

9. Tchill13

10. Klazam

11. Deasvail

- Too bad there's not a darker shade of red.

12. stay away I have a gf

13. Keyser Söze

[Mulch]

Townie as fuck: Mulch, Creative, Geralt, SAIHAG, keyser
Towny: Mestro, Tchill
Null: Aseemblo, Klazam
Scummy: Keychain, Sergetacos
Scum as FUCK and I think decent chance of scum partners: Desasvail and Fykus

[Mulch]

VOTE: Deasvil

[Mulch]

If anyone disagrees with any of my reads or my townyness right now say now.

I will convince you.

[Keyser Söze]

A worthy counter wagon: VOTE: Fykas
Hi Fykas, how would you read you right now?

[Mulch]

A worthy counter wagon: VOTE: Fykas
Hi Fykas, how would you read you right now?

Why do you read scumavil town?

[Keyser Söze]

I was hoping to keep this to myself but... I think Fykas will be a slot where only votes will force them to show their true colors [with his behaviour]

In regard Deasvil, he has shown the posting 'competency' to take on any accusations head on, face to face in a more articulate fashion. I await to see him address your points [with his words]

[Mulch]

^ explain that bullshit please

[Keyser Söze]

It's as explicit as it needs to be.

[Mulch]

It's as explicit as it needs to be.

Wrong, because I don't understand it, and if I don't understand it it's not explicit enough

[Keyser Söze]

Sorry, no.

[Mulch]

Sorry, no.

I can engage with you and show you why you are wrong, but only if you explain why. Your gonna be too stubborn to convince with just my scumreading merits, so I have to do this the long and painful way. Show me your thoughts. Who knows, you might even convince me.


Also, if you continue to not do this scum will keep you around because you will be detrimental to the town

[Tchill13]

VOTE: Fykus

I'm not so sure about mulch's town read on SAIHGF but I do believe Fykus is scummier here than deasvail.

[Mulch]

VOTE: Fykus

I'm not so sure about mulch's town read on SAIHGF but I do believe Fykus is scummier here than deasvail.

Why

[Mulch]

Also that was avoiding and manipulative as fuck, congratulations you've gone to null

[Klazam]

I understand keyser, and the main point is that you need to wait for fykus to respond to me/him. dont go aggro just yet, fykus and deasvail's both on your scumlist anyway.

[Mulch]

I understand keyser, and the main point is that you need to wait for fykus to respond to me/him. dont go aggro just yet, fykus and deasvail's both on your scumlist anyway.

They are fucking scum partners and I want some answers and interaction right now

[Mulch]

But desavil is scum 90% fykus 60%

[Tchill13]

Also that was avoiding and manipulative as fuck, congratulations you've gone to null

What's manipulative or avoiding about my post? You said if anyone disagrees with a town read say so now. I did with SAIHGF. Then you call out a scum team between Fykus and deasvail but you only push deasvail and give me a null read when I vote Fykus. You're the one being manipulative. It's like you want everyone to know you're scum reading Fykus but you're not voting Fykus. Also from your catchup I would have imagined sergtacos seemed scummier to you than Fykus because all I seen on Fykus was interaction reads with deasvail but I seen more reads based on sergtacos for his post alone.

[DeasVail]

Sergtacos: Probably town

DeasVail can you talk me through town!tacos

I believe his posting has a simultaneous vigour and carelessness to it that would be very surprising from someone early on in their early forum scum career. I find it difficult to imagine scum-serg doing a lot of the posting that he's done, as I would expect much of that posting would have been hindered by the thought of "but what will they think of me if I post this?".

Even if it is just a successful attempt at emulating his town-meta though, I think there is also evidence of him thinking about the game entrenched within his posting.

I'm second-guessing myself right now. I normally read this big of a overreaction as being scummy, but... Previous game had a guy who was defending, like a lot, every post he made on early d1, I was scum reading that, but I was wrong.

Need a second opinion from someone, should I be reading that reaction as town or scum, and why?

PEDIT: I'm expecting a reaction that seems more calm, refuting arugements. While here you seem excessive in your reaction, up to and including implying that I became scummy because I pointed out your blow up and voted you, that's a bit much don't have think.

Sure sarcasm I get but, well, sarcasm is a personal scumtell for me, have been ever since my first game on the site. Sarcasm is an excellent defense mechanism in where you deflect arugements made about you. Shouldn't be a real town reason to react like that. At best, you come off as a wiseass who obliquely attacks the people pushing you... Which is what is happening here.

Still second guessing myself though.

On the other hand, I found the post quite scummy. It's not very difficult for scum to fake existential reads crises and ask other people to do their scumhunting for them.

I'm going back to
VOTE: Klazam

[Mulch]

Also that was avoiding and manipulative as fuck, congratulations you've gone to null

What's manipulative or avoiding about my post? You said if anyone disagrees with a town read say so now. I did with SAIHGF. Then you call out a scum team between Fykus and deasvail but you only push deasvail and give me a null read when I vote Fykus. You're the one being manipulative. It's like you want everyone to know you're scum reading Fykus but you're not voting Fykus. Also from your catchup I would have imagined sergtacos seemed scummier to you than Fykus because all I seen on Fykus was interaction reads with deasvail but I seen more reads based on sergtacos for his post alone.

Your manipulative because your doming things I said into two things which is FykusVDeasavil

[Mulch]

LMAO desasvil just ignoring me