Mini 1924: Mountainish Mafia GAME OVER!!!

[Blanche]

maybe if you gave thoughts on my first posts you'd know why i'm a bad vote

i dont need to help you figure things out vedith - you're a big boy

seriously though if you're going to act like a guttownread on vij is a big deal then you're going to start wanting to give a shit about how you look to me

[Vedith]

i'm not going to convince you to vote carca unless you think she's scum

what's your read on her and why?

Why do you not want to convince me to vote where you think scum is?
What's your reason for Carca scum.

Carca is an awkward player. She says stupid shit that makes her look like scum, or makes her an easy push.
I'll decide further in the game if it's scum motivated.

[Blanche]

carca's setup discussion seems motivated more by trying to rile up reactions from people that result in a certain role outted and like kraska said her opinions seem informed

if you think she's null then that's fine but we're definitely coming back to this discussion

and i have no interest in convincing you because i want you to make your own pushes so i and the rest of the town can sort you naturally

~giggles

[Vedith]

VOTE: lycanfire

i have no names to give....

i'm innocent - just like ethel rosenberg

I don't get what I'm looking at?

[Blanche]

that part clearly wasnt meant for you

try the next post.

[Zachstralkita]

Aye I might just make a bloc with Vedith. This game is going to be fun to read.

[Vedith]

i dont need to help you figure things out vedith - you're a big boy

You'll make me blush!

seriously though if you're going to act like a guttownread on vij is a big deal then you're going to start wanting to give a shit about how you look to me

I honestly don't care.
I do care about how you get to your reads though.

and i have no interest in convincing you because i want you to make your own pushes so i and the rest of the town can sort you naturally

Why don't you have interest in me voting scum?
What if my reads are scum motivated or just wrong? Surely you

want

me to vote in the right place?

[Carcalilly]

Carca is an awkward player. She says stupid shit that makes her look like scum, or makes her an easy push.

You know me well <3

[Blanche]

Aye I might just make a bloc with Vedith.

is this one of those things were you gambit like that roman guy and make blocs with scum

i dont need to help you figure things out vedith - you're a big boy

You'll make me blush!

i'm just trying to make dunny jealous

seriously though if you're going to act like a guttownread on vij is a big deal then you're going to start wanting to give a shit about how you look to me

I honestly don't care.
I do care about how you get to your reads though.

his posts seemed natural and made me laugh. thats about it.

and i have no interest in convincing you because i want you to make your own pushes so i and the rest of the town can sort you naturally

Why don't you have interest in me voting scum?
What if my reads are scum motivated or just wrong? Surely you

want

me to vote in the right place?

it's like page 6 i'm more interested to see people figure the game out for themselves.

[Vedith]

3. The Mafia will have an appointed "Godfather" to make their kills.

on a more serious note though kraska and i have been trying to figure out what the mechanical purpose of this is but we cant think of anything

the rolecop is obvious but??

this should come up later in the game

I didn't notice the first bit.
Regardless, what do you want me to think on this? And why does this make you town?

[Vedith]

Aye I might just make a bloc with Vedith. This game is going to be fun to read.

[Blanche]

it's ok vedith

if you dont get it now you'll get it never

[Vedith]

I think Gigga = scum.
How's that for figuring the game out for myself?

VOTE: Blanche

[Blanche]

VOTE: Vedith

vedith will not be town here. discuss while the inevitable lynch goes through.

remember this folks

[Vedith]

Getting a sweat on?

[Blanche]

yeah

[Zachstralkita]

do you want me to tell you what's wrong giga because I will

[Carcalilly]

Yeah but now we're talking and I've got a wagon behind me as always. \o/

Wait it's 9:4 holy crap

guys no I never wanted the role to be outted
that's the last thing we want

I just wanted a way for us to combat this somehow.
We're all uninformed to an extent. The mafia probably doesn't know who the end all role is. Only the person with that role knows, and I don't want it to be just them with the game on their shoulders.

I want to figure out a way for us to help them without outting them. Which is difficult considering that scum can read and see everything we say.
Which is why I wondered about other power roles. If they exist, they're hidden, and none of us know about it.
It's hard to think of a balance of privacy and working together. A gamble at this point is too risky, but if I'm alive later just maybe...

[Blanche]

what's wrong with you? by all means - i'm starting to get curious.

what's wrong with me though? nothing, so i'm not interested in hearing it.

@zach

Yeah but now we're talking and I've got a wagon behind me as always. \o/

Wait it's 9:4 holy crap

carca why are you just assuming dunn is right

[Blanche]

But facts tho Carca is scum but giga was acting weird at gamestart. Would you like to explain this behavior kraska

i townread giga

[Carcalilly]

Rip I skimmed through the thing and panicked again
Aaaanyway if Dunn can lynch scum day 1 I'll gladly hand the game to them.
And if they're actually scum, we can take care of that later, lynching a scum is great even if the wagon was made by scum.

[Blanche]

[Carcalilly]

Spoiler: 113

carcalilly is town

Okay, I just need you to defend this.

Anyway, this is Mountainish (no roles???) with an end-all town role and a mafia rolecop?????

? Were you assuming, knowing that this was a closed setup, that since it appeared scumsided it was definitely completely scumsided and town was set up to lose? Just wondering. It doesn't make sense.

IDK I'm questioning the balance and the actual setup. It's closed so all we can do is speculate

Definitely an implication of closed setups... yes.

then let's fight

the mafia mechanic discussion is at least more pro-town if you really want to go the setup spec discussion because scum probably have insight to what it means while town doesnt

all we know is that we cant let the mysterious role die and thats all we really

should

know (unless you know what that role is??)

so why not discuss the godfather mechanic instead?

Oh yeah but how do we do that exactly? Doctors? No, it's mountainish? Claim before lynch? Now the mafia will get them.

Godfather mechanic is a lot less interesting Imo. :')

Again, are you assuming town has nothing to combat scum advantage? In what way is that logical?


And if you're assuming otherwise, what benefit does discussing it like this have? At all?


Please help me clarify BC scummy

Well one, I was confused because there are technically roles in a no-role mechanic. I'm pretty sure mountainish means all VT and goons but apparently not here.

So if town does actually have other PRs then it's not mountainish and Ari lied to us all.

OK so look at out confirmed information:
-Mafia has a ROLECOP
-Town has an END-ALL role
-The game is titled "mountainish"

So during the night, mafia can probably rolecop one player, then kill another. That's clearing out two. If that's all there really is then in must be easy for them to find that role.

Also, the benefits have already taken action.

[Carcalilly]

What is this strange object

[Carcalilly]

In a setup where we're already weak, PoEing town's potential utilities and highlighting the one weakness we all know as a discussion point on mechanics is really... out there, to say the least.


VOTE: Carcalilly



Y not

Out there is how to play m9