Open 688: Diffusion of Power (Game Over)

[Titus]

Nice to see you Gamma. Gtg

We massclaimed cop/docs

Navy is scum

I am dtunk

[Kelvin Smith]

So RC is basically saying that the game revolves around him. Bullshit imo,
VOTE: RadiantCowbells
Also that cop choice by math is fucking shite but he's not-so-great at reading his sibling so eh. I wouldn't have picked Titus.

How is that what RC said at all?

[RadiantCowbells]

It's legitimately not biologically possible for me.

[Kelvin Smith]

Can you actually provide objective analysis that doesn't revolve around you being the towniest town that ever towned or is that legitimately not biologically possible for you?

For the most part, he has. The alban scum thing is something I'm not as sure of, but he has been fairly reasonable in his assessments of the gamestate.

[Kelvin Smith]

Navy is scum

Fucking why?! Did I just miss it or are you never going to answer the damn question?

[Gamma Emerald]

Hell yes
Any things I NEED to consider? If not I'll return to my reads from before I flaked.

Out of curiosity, what were your reads before you flaked? I don't put much stock into them, I'm just curious what your general feelings were when you flaked.

Also, there's a lot of stuff that I feel you should consider. Pretty much everything I've said, for instance. I can try to abridge it for you, to an extent, but I've posted a lot since joining.

I'll read eventually FYI. As for my reads, they were AS scum, Titus town, I think I was townreading Vedith, scumreading MCM mostly for the shifty switch.

[Gamma Emerald]

Nice to see you Gamma. Gtg

We massclaimed cop/docs

Navy is scum

I am dtunk

You're obv drunk
You forgot I was around most of d2
I recall Navy was CS and don't really see what was scummy about either of them rn

[Titus]

Navy is scum

Fucking why?! Did I just miss it or are you never going to answer the damn question?

Navy is avoiding this thread while town rips itself

[Kelvin Smith]

Hell yes
Any things I NEED to consider? If not I'll return to my reads from before I flaked.

Out of curiosity, what were your reads before you flaked? I don't put much stock into them, I'm just curious what your general feelings were when you flaked.

Also, there's a lot of stuff that I feel you should consider. Pretty much everything I've said, for instance. I can try to abridge it for you, to an extent, but I've posted a lot since joining.

I'll read eventually FYI. As for my reads, they were AS scum, Titus town, I think I was townreading Vedith, scumreading MCM mostly for the shifty switch.

I'm MCM. Also, the switch wasn't shifty.

Scum knew how many Cops and Docs there were from the start. Even if they didn't organize their claims pre-game or some Night before the massclaim, they still knew exactly ow many of each claim there would be and how many who all of the scum were.

I don't know when Mutton made the switch, because I didn't care to read anything from before I started, but there have been 6 players who claimed Cop, 6 players who claimed Doc, and one player who claimed both. What would scumMutton have to gain by going from Cop to Doc? Either way, there are 7 claims for a maximum of 6 roles. It draws more attention to switch than it does to stick in the same pool, so scumMutton would have little reason to switch.

On top of that, fakeCop holds more utility for scum than fakeDoc, since they can mislead/WIFOM the town with their fake results. Now, fakeDocs can do something similar by forgoing the NK and claiming to have protected someone, but that requires scum to actually give up a kill or have a killed blocked by someone else to do that. It's more risk and less reward.

[Kelvin Smith]

Navy is scum

Fucking why?! Did I just miss it or are you never going to answer the damn question?

Navy is avoiding this thread while town rips itself

Yeah, and I asked if there was actually another reason besides that. So you are saying that is the one and only reason that Navy is scum, correct?

[RadiantCowbells]

I'm having serious deja vu right now

[Titus]

Navy is scum

Fucking why?! Did I just miss it or are you never going to answer the damn question?

Navy is avoiding this thread while town rips itself

Yeah, and I asked if there was actually another reason besides that. So you are saying that is the one and only reason that Navy is scum, correct?

It's the best one. The heals are crap. The wagon motion says Navy scum. They haven't scumhunted.

[Titus]

There's no reason to TR Navy, yet major resistance

[RadiantCowbells]

Titus, have you made a decision?

I'm even willing to knock Math off the lynch list because there's two other scum and I feel like I know both of them.

[RadiantCowbells]

But when there's one scum left you are not allowed to oppose Math, regardless of whether I'm alive or not.

[Gamma Emerald]

The utility of MCM's switch depends on Math's alignment. Math is scum, it was to save him. Math is town, it was to make him look bad. I'm not sure on it yet but that's the motive I can see.

[RadiantCowbells]

So he's just scum either way, got it.

[Kelvin Smith]

Navy is scum

Fucking why?! Did I just miss it or are you never going to answer the damn question?

Navy is avoiding this thread while town rips itself

Yeah, and I asked if there was actually another reason besides that. So you are saying that is the one and only reason that Navy is scum, correct?

It's the best one. The heals are crap. The wagon motion says Navy scum. They haven't scumhunted.

Crap heals are town-indicative, at best.

The wagon motion says nobody wants to lynch a lurker when we have three scum on the board and we're a day from MyLo.

If I had a quarter for every time somebody said that X town player wasn't scumhunting, I'd be fucking rich, so get that tired shit out of here.

[Titus]

Titus, have you made a decision?

I'm even willing to knock Math off the lynch list because there's two other scum and I feel like I know both of them.

So you'd be eilling to not lynch Math tomorrow. Who do you wanna lynch?

[Gamma Emerald]

He could be RC
Not sure yet as I said

[Titus]

Navy is scum

Fucking why?! Did I just miss it or are you never going to answer the damn question?

Navy is avoiding this thread while town rips itself

Yeah, and I asked if there was actually another reason besides that. So you are saying that is the one and only reason that Navy is scum, correct?

It's the best one. The heals are crap. The wagon motion says Navy scum. They haven't scumhunted.

Crap heals are town-indicative, at best.

The wagon motion says nobody wants to lynch a lurker when we have three scum on the board and we're a day from MyLo.

If I had a quarter for every time somebody said that X town player wasn't scumhunting, I'd be fucking rich, so get that tired shit out of here.

Yeah and I have seen enough tunnels.

[RadiantCowbells]

-Alban confirmed scum
-Gamma entrance terrible

[Kelvin Smith]

The utility of MCM's switch depends on Math's alignment. Math is scum, it was to save him. Math is town, it was to make him look bad. I'm not sure on it yet but that's the motive I can see.

1. Yes, but he wasn't scum, so those weren't his motives.

2. Even if I were scum, please elaborate on how those things do anything to Math.

[Titus]

-Alban confirmed scum
-Gamma entrance terrible

I miiiight do Gamma.

Alban lock town to me.

The only docs I see could be scum if you are town are Navy and Kelvin but I reallly doubt Kelvin.

[Kelvin Smith]

-Alban confirmed scum
-Gamma entrance terrible

How is alban confirmed scum?