Mini 1924: Mountainish Mafia GAME OVER!!!

[Wake1]

I hate Day 1 shenanigans. I need something to actually work with.

I need to know which members here refuse to vote certain members here Day 1.i want to know who you think is off the table no matter what for now.

[jjh927]

Well, you weren't reaction testing, you aren't casing me, you aren't trying to get other people to vote me and you aren't 1V1ing me with the added pressure of a vote, Nos. So from what I can see it serves no purpose

[Nosferatu]

just letting everyone know that i scumread you
dont see why i need to lead the crusades on you

[jjh927]

This implies to me you care more about letting people know you have scumreads than actually getting them lynched

[Gamma Emerald]

I hate Day 1 shenanigans. I need something to actually work with.

I need to know which members here refuse to vote certain members here Day 1.i want to know who you think is off the table no matter what for now.

Not really anyone rn
Might be a few once I'm caught up though

[Nosferatu]

This implies to me you care more about letting people know you have scumreads than actually getting them lynched

why should i put time and effort into seeing you get lynched before someone tells me that they town read you. telling everyone how to read you before anyone else has an opinion of you is stupid.

[jjh927]

Well, if you want me to be a counterwagon so Vedith doesn't get lynched you're gonna need to try a little harder

[Carcalilly]

Who do you think is scum, Carca

I only have gut reads right now with Zach and Dwlee.

I hate Day 1 shenanigans. I need something to actually work with.

I need to know which members here refuse to vote certain members here Day 1.i want to know who you think is off the table no matter what for now.

I personally disagree with the vedith wagon. My vote won't be placed there anytime soon.

[jjh927]

What about Vedith is town?

[Blanche]

That sounds really early for a good scumread but I'll check it out...
It's a lot later a actually. A good case with motives. Tbh Vedith has contributed a questionable amount of content in a questionable manner. I want him to react first though.

I don't know about Dwlee now... Does feel kind of off but that isn't enough to put a scum label.

Your case on Vedith makes some sense, but I'm gonna wait to see what Dunn says, I'm massively curious.

Carcalilly talk to me about the thought process here?

like why did this go from "good case" to "off the table" for you

as for me, wake, it's not so much who's off the table as it is who's on. vedith and carcalilly are the only lynches i want today, though i don't think your vote is a bad choice either. vedith and carcalilly though have constantly scumposted imo while vij only had a couple of bad posts and doesn't really have much in the way of AI content that'd be useful post flip.

i guess my "off the table" choices though are everyone sans my two scumreads, vij, and jj right now. the last two are more of a "to sort later but wouldn't jump to defend if wagonned" though. i'm liking mars so far and i have no clue how to read you ever based on last time

[Zachstralkita]

Who do you think is scum, Carca

I only have gut reads right now with Zach and Dwlee.

I hate Day 1 shenanigans. I need something to actually work with.

I need to know which members here refuse to vote certain members here Day 1.i want to know who you think is off the table no matter what for now.

I personally disagree with the vedith wagon. My vote won't be placed there anytime soon.

This post... Jesus






So do you wanna defend him then or

[Nosferatu]

Well, if you want me to be a counterwagon so Vedith doesn't get lynched you're gonna need to try a little harder

[Nosferatu]

where are we at with vedith
VOTE: vedith

[Blanche]

where are we at with vedith
VOTE: vedith

That's L-2

[Mars Argo]

For a 9:4 game, the Vedith wagon doesn't seem to have any resistance. Who are the buddies on the wagon?

[Mars Argo]

Dwlee, what are your reads?

I haven't played mafia in a while and I'm kind of lost? I guess. I'm gonna try to ISO a few people and develop some reads.

I'm reading this as a town appeal, but if you don't come out and play I'm going to take it back.

I hate Day 1 shenanigans. I need something to actually work with.

I need to know which members here refuse to vote certain members here Day 1.i want to know who you think is off the table no matter what for now.

I'm also reading this as a town appeal. I hope you are town.

[Mars Argo]

9:4 is arguably very scum-sided because in a game of 13, we need 7 for a lynch. Which means 7/9 town have to be right on the lynch. Now that I think about it, it wouldn't be hard for scum to just stay off the wagon. I retract my previous statement.

[Mars Argo]

Not trying to post a trillion times in a row, but wagon speed should definitely be heavily analyzed in a 9:4 setup. An impossible lynch is likely the correct one. An easy lynch is definitely wrong. Am I correct in saying this? This likely holds true for most mafia games, but I'd assume even moreso here. Is 9:4 common? Maybe I will read some setups like this.

[Blanche]

For a 9:4 game, the Vedith wagon doesn't seem to have any resistance. Who are the buddies on the wagon?

me




on a more serious note though i think this is a better question to ask post-flip, mostly because we don't know how the wagon is going to develop until it finishes. the theory i have in my head is that scum don't have the towncred to push a counterwagon, which suggests buddies somewhere in {Gamma, Carcalilly, Vij, JJ, maybe Wake but he hasn't pushed anything so I dont know if he counts, I guess Nos but I think JJ's the only person willing to vote there atm}, but that's kind of confbiasing on my own reads. there's also the possibility this is still an all-town wagon and scum either can't get involved or don't want to (to instill paranoia) - i've seen it happen before (D1 scum lynches with an all town wagon and no counterwagon).

case in point it's way too early to make a call imo

Not trying to post a trillion times in a row, but wagon speed should definitely be heavily analyzed in a 9:4 setup. An impossible lynch is likely the correct one. An easy lynch is definitely wrong. Am I correct in saying this? This likely holds true for most mafia games, but I'd assume even moreso here. Is 9:4 common? Maybe I will read some setups like this.

you would be right if we were in the normal queue but this game is significantly different from what you would expect

the fact it's 9:4 should tell you as much tbh. this game is extremely gimmicky from what i can tell

[Blanche]

scum could also have a strong incentive to bus

[Gamma Emerald]

Why did we just decide it was 4:9

[Blanche]

Why did we just decide it was 4:9

dunnstral said so

and i agree too

[Gamma Emerald]

Why

[Blanche]

why do I agree?

because dunnbun <3

[Gamma Emerald]

Well I'm not making any assumptions