Mini Normal 1923: BooneyToonz IV - Five Weeks in a Boon END

[Boonskiies]

jk lel

[Tchill13]

Well my votes parked on tacos. Apparently I didn't make any great points.

[Gamma Emerald]

Both of our wagons were on town

how do you know the fykus wagon was on town?

mulch got lynched because he's the stronger town asset

WHAT. MULCH IS A BAD PLAYER MY GOD. THERE IS A REASON WHY HE WAS NEVER NIGHTKILLED AS FREAKING CONFIRMED TOWN IN 1919

Wait, Tchill scumslipped?!

No??? Opportunistic much? Fairly certain it was just a "well shit" response after Mulch said Fykus was Town

[Sergtacos]

Both of our wagons were on town

how do you know the fykus wagon was on town?

mulch got lynched because he's the stronger town asset

WHAT. MULCH IS A BAD PLAYER MY GOD. THERE IS A REASON WHY HE WAS NEVER NIGHTKILLED AS FREAKING CONFIRMED TOWN IN 1919

Wait, Tchill scumslipped?!

No??? Opportunistic much? Fairly certain it was just a "well shit" response after Mulch said Fykus was Town

i didnt say he did, i was asking, obviously you can't read.

[Gamma Emerald]

And yet you concluded as such later

[Sergtacos]

And yet you concluded as such later

Like?

[Gamma Emerald]

Thought you did, must have been someone else

[Vedith]

I need to read up soon but with work getting busy again this week I might need to save it for the weekend.
I'll post what I can though.

[Klazam]

reading more posts, I think you scum slipped and dude like i said before your posts seem so fucking scummy to me

Taco you say here that he scumslipped, explain why you're denying it

[Gamma Emerald]

reading more posts, I think you scum slipped and dude like i said before your posts seem so fucking scummy to me

Taco you say here that he scumslipped, explain why you're denying it

Fack
That's where he said it
I just skimmed and missed it when trying to find it

[Klazam]

Taco switching tunes to M and I being town is giving me MAJOR heebies for some reason. Feels uh, too easy.

[Klazam]

And what do you mean by experimenting, theories, and all that shit?

[Creative]

I'm pretty sure its between fykus and sergtacos, either one sounds fine for me.

But im going back to the one that should be lynched d1

VOTE: Fykus

[Gamma Emerald]

Why Fykus over Serg? And do you think they could be buddies?

[Tchill13]

I'm pretty sure its between fykus and sergtacos, either one sounds fine for me.

But im going back to the one that should be lynched d1

VOTE: Fykus

Today's lynch should either be creative or Sergtacos.

[Gamma Emerald]

I'm pretty sure its between fykus and sergtacos, either one sounds fine for me.

But im going back to the one that should be lynched d1

VOTE: Fykus

Today's lynch should either be creative or Sergtacos.

Why those two only?

[Tchill13]

At this point those are the only 2 I feel like there's actually enough reason to lynch.

[Gamma Emerald]

Okay

[DeasVail]

Creative:
- I still think he is town. However, I have some mild concerns.
- I am concerned by you using the fact that Fykus was the alternative wagon yesterday as a reason to suspect him. Why don't you think both major wagons were on town? And why does that come before using a person's posts as reason to suspect/not suspect them?
- Also, the in-thread speculation of power roles seems unnecessary and possibly even anti-town.

[Tchill13]

I agree with your points deasvail. They're solid.

[Gamma Emerald]

TChill I think you're engaging in selective hearing
DV thinks Creative is TOWN

[DeasVail]

Maestro:
- Very shouty but I'm not especially convinced of his town-ness.
Klazam, what makes you believe that Maestro is genuine. In your experience do his posts match with what you would expect from him?

Sergtacos: Still town to me. He's all over the place in a way that I think is unlikely from him as scum here. Very happy to engage in a conversation on this though if there is passion for scum-tacos.

SAIHAG: I like him still. Weak-Moderate town read. Vedith questioning from Day 1 seems especially good.

Tchill: Before reading their ISO I thought they'd be a scumread for me, but I'm townreading them. It's possible I'll have too many people as town now but we'll see!

Vecna: Still leaning town. However, talk to me about your Tchill scumread. I find their posting Day 2 fairly towny. There is also 1754, where they say they will die of laughter if Mulch flips town, which I feel is unlikely from scum. I would expect them to instead be trying to pretend that they think Mulch is scum, as they would have known Mulch was town and be trying not to betray that knowledge.

Vedith: I'm not sure what to think at this point. I can appreciate Vecna's meta argument, but I also am not sure if Vedith's confrontational style would come from him as scum. I will need to revisit this.

I'm going with

VOTE: Maestro

for now, but I have no solid scumreads. I will have another look at the game and attempt to amend this later.

PEdit: Creative is who I may be most likely to change my mind on. But I think I'll need to take a fresh look at old posts.

[DeasVail]

Actually,

UNVOTE: Maestro
VOTE: Creative

[Gamma Emerald]

I'm gonna die of laughter if mulch flips town.

Hm
Actually this might be a scum post
I've made a post almost exactly like this as scum in the same scenario

[Vecna]

How the game currently feels to me, even though im not very involved and cant find myself caring a great deal (mainly because everyone seems to feel totally different about things than I do):
1 scum in Creative vs Maestro
1 scum in Tchil vs Gamma emerald vs Fykus
1 scum being Vedith.

Starting to feel slightly better about DV over time.

Gamma Emerald is still probably town, but its still possible that Witcher-guy just overreacted because he really did think he was being shot, so just panic-claimed the strongest PR. Im surprised not more people have been wondering about a cop-claim surviving the night, but just claiming a roleblock instead. Its ofcourse totally possible mafia would want us to doubt him and lynch him, or are afraid of a potential doctor being out there.....but why havent they made a move yet to try and raise suspicion about Gamma Emerald? (or did I miss it?).

Sergtacos seems like very obvious town to me. He might play like a tool, but that doesnt mean like he's scum. Most of his play seems very genuine so far. Still not getting the scumreads here, same as I didnt understand at all how people could scumread Mulch.

Still clueless about Fykus, could be scum, could be town. Slot hasnt done anything to push me one way or the other.