What even is this? You can't know who the scum are unless you're one of them. And who are you anyway? The signature indicates Dogwatch, but that's my latest idea for leaf's identity. I still need to look Dogwatch up and see if there's any comparison.
ok so a bunch of people have been doing some votes in the votethread, honestly if people don't start signing seriously it's gonna get cancerous, I'm voting TheBrie for now because those votes they made just feels weird.
Also has anyone actually used the votes seriously or is it just try to RVS despite the absolute lack of pressure since it's all anoynomous.
All the Town should sign properly from here IMO so we can catch the scum that's not signing via PoE, so The and leaf and doggie if you're actually Town please sign properly or we'll get this shit to PoE you.
If 2 people fake sign, that should leave us someone who hasn't shown their name, so calling out fakesigns (assuming Town properly signs) confirms the scum. So I'm assuming scum isn't fakesigning based off this, which is another reason to actually properly sign. Town gains nothing from not properly signing so please.
I didn't write that. But I did notice that troll post 49 was written right around the same time that Brie voted for slimer in the voting thread (post 17). They were both posted around 3:20am - 3:30am. Brie is in Australia, meaning that she has a pretty different schedule than the rest of us and would post while most of us are sleeping.
I also think "The" is TheBrie based on writing style and obviously the nickname. Post 50 in this thread looks to me like she's calling herself out in order to distance herself from the troll post to gain town cred.
To prove I'm who I say I am, I'm voting for Brie right now.
"I used to think you had this elegant-trolly, minimalist playstyle. Then I realized the playstyle is ~Lazy~
The true enlightenment was realizing that they are the same thing."
~fferyllt
"who the fuck fakeclaims Tracker like that
WHO THE FUCK DOES THAT"
~Alisae
Raya was complete random vote. Xnad was to get his attention becuase he hadn't voted yet. I did note that at the time, though I didn't specifically say I was going to vote him. Slimer was because I'm thinking Xnad is town, and his vote change had no reason behind it. I probably should have explained.
Since there actually doesn't seem to be any penalty for giving names, I'll do it now. I take credit for every post signed The, except the fake self vote on I already called out.
I also take credit (or censure) for three troll posts.
#7 was because I felt lazy.
#31 because I was bored and felt like calling out the person who self voted as myself and someone else.
And I can't deny #49 (doggie). I was trying to get reactions. See who called me out and how. Not enough was going on, so i had to create my own drama. That post does not actually reflect my own opinions on any of the players mentioned. I think Raya is town. and I think Dogwatch is town. NTRP is a complete null.
I also got to claim #40 because I didn't feel like claiming the trolls posts back then. And #36 because i wanted to see if people picked up who i was. probably should have out The is that too.
I don't know how you picked up that #57 was slimer, but good job.
I don't really like his explanation, his still not using any kind of signature, and his unvote on being called out on giving to reason for the vote. So I'm not going to move my vote of him at the moment.
In post 59, This is me wrote:I also take credit (or censure) for three troll posts.
#7 was because I felt lazy.
#31 because I was bored and felt like calling out the person who self voted as myself and someone else.
And I can't deny #49 (doggie). I was trying to get reactions. See who called me out and how. Not enough was going on, so i had to create my own drama. That post does not actually reflect my own opinions on any of the players mentioned. I think Raya is town. and I think Dogwatch is town. NTRP is a complete null.
I also got to claim #40 because I didn't feel like claiming the trolls posts back then. And #36 because i wanted to see if people picked up who i was. probably should have out The is that too.
~Brie
You're not cleared just for owning up to it though. To me this just looks like caught scum playing the "it's not what it looks like" card. It's damage control.
1. Matrix 6 setup. So we should have a decent game. The fact that the posts themselves are anonymous but not the votes are tremendously helpful. Hopefully the single machination of this game does not get the better of us. I am worried slightly about the persons trolling. Either it is bored scum who does not know how to take advantage of anonimity or just a VI in the town. This leaf person will maybe lose us the game he might be town, but if he survives towrds the end I would probably lynch him if I am alive my paranoia would win out.
The current plan is to sign our posts. We should have another plan. Plans on plans. Like concentrate our votes on the persons who are not signing their posts. Its better than nothing but I am amenable to the standard option and to do nothing.
I am forgetting something but I cant remember it
It had to do with vijarda, slimer, dogwatch, brie, and raya I think I wrote them down as possible scum. It'll come to me.
I'm want to vote for nottherealpaul since I havent seen him but he has voted and we can eliminate a few questions about who posted what. If he answers we can move on to the next person.
@thebrie any ideas on what else we can do to minimize confusion about who posted what? And do you think post 17 and 20 are written by the same person?
@NTRP I wanna know if you have posted in this thread and which posts are yours,
@Post #63 That's reasonable. I didn't expect people to trust me immediately. But seriously think about what the scum motive for the troll post could be? Is anyone seriously going to listen to something like that?
@Yakko You're a replacement right? And from what I understand you're replacing NTRP. So why are you acting like he's another player? Who do you think you are replacing? The mod hasn't officially said anything, so it's kinda confusing.
I doubt 17 and 20 were the same person. I can't see nay motive for doing that from a town standpoint, and it seems kind of stupid as scum. Also one had punctuation. It could be faked, but I doubt it was. And 20 can't be fake signed.
Not quite. In fact, just knowing that you're scum would be good enough. Assuming the role isn't the same as assuming the player. In fact, I would say he'd be more likely to forget who he was if he was scum due to more to remember, save for all he had was his name and a simple role.
-leaf
In post 64, This is me wrote:Like concentrate our votes on the persons who are not signing their posts
That's literally the whole point of signing our posts.
And my vote is on the guy who was not signing their posts (they are now but I'm lazy to get off)
But scum would make sure they weren't scum reading their partner if it was avoidable. Though I suppose he wasn't really a scum read, just someone to push until he answered. So I'll leave Yakko as a null.
Leaf, are you Dogwatch or did Dogwatch only come on to defend himself from my troll?
We have three days till deadline and all we've accomplished so far are RVS votes and some vague finger pointing.
My vote stays where it is right now. There's a lot of scum motivation behind stirring up the pot like Brie did, and not much town motivation. Her owning up to it, like I said before, looks to me like damage control more than anything.
Won't be able to post much for the next couple days, but I'll attempt a reads list this morning and see if anything else strikes me as odd.
